Assisted Living Medicaid Waiver Audits: Lessons From OIG State Oversight Reviews
What GAO and HHS-OIG reviews of state Medicaid waiver oversight reveal about assisted living, adult day, and residential HCBS providers, and how assisted living operators can prepare for audits.
KNOWLEDGE CENTER
11/15/202612 min read
Assisted living has become an important part of Medicaid long-term services and supports. Although Medicaid generally does not pay for room and board, most states use home and community-based services (HCBS) waivers or state plan options to pay for personal care, supervision, medication assistance, and other services delivered to Medicaid beneficiaries living in assisted living settings. For older adults and people with disabilities who need help with daily activities but not nursing home care, these programs offer an alternative to institutional placement.
Federal oversight of these services runs through the states. Under section 1915(c) waivers and related authorities, states must assure the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) that they have safeguards to protect beneficiaries' health and welfare. Over the past several years, the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) and the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General (OIG) have examined how well states meet that obligation. Their reviews of assisted living programs, adult day centers, adult family homes, and supported living settings reveal recurring gaps in state oversight and in provider compliance.
Those findings matter to assisted living operators. When OIG concludes that a state's oversight was insufficient, it typically recommends that the state strengthen inspections, monitoring, and corrective action, and in billing audits it recommends refunds. States, in turn, increase scrutiny of providers. This article summarizes what GAO and OIG have found, explains the requirements that drive those findings, and offers practical steps assisted living providers participating in Medicaid waivers can take to prepare. It is educational and neutral. Program rules vary by state, so providers should confirm requirements in their state's waiver, regulations, and provider agreements.
How Medicaid Pays for Assisted Living Services
States cover services in assisted living through several authorities, most commonly section 1915(c) HCBS waivers, and also section 1915(i), section 1915(k), section 1115 demonstrations, and managed long-term services and supports programs. Covered services may include personal care, homemaker and chore services, medication administration or assistance, nursing oversight, and supervision. Room and board is generally paid by the resident, often from Supplemental Security Income or other income, and states may set limits on what facilities can charge Medicaid residents.
Because services are delivered under a waiver, providers must meet both state licensing requirements for assisted living and the waiver's provider qualifications, service definitions, documentation standards, and person-centered planning requirements. Federal HCBS settings requirements at 42 CFR 441.301(c)(4) also apply, requiring that settings support community integration, privacy, choice, and autonomy.
GAO's Assessment of State Oversight
In January 2018, GAO reported on Medicaid assisted living services in a study requested by a bipartisan group of senators. GAO found that state Medicaid agencies in 48 states that covered assisted living services reported spending more than $10 billion, federal and state combined, on assisted living services.
GAO focused on how states oversee beneficiary health and welfare. State Medicaid agencies are required to protect beneficiary health and welfare and to operate systems to monitor for critical incidents, which are cases of potential or actual harm to beneficiaries such as abuse, neglect, or exploitation. GAO found that states reported varied approaches to oversight, particularly in how they monitored critical incidents involving beneficiaries, and that many state Medicaid agencies could not report the number of critical incidents occurring in assisted living settings. GAO recommended that CMS improve its oversight by clarifying state reporting requirements, including requiring states to report information on critical incidents and the types of residential settings where they occurred.
For providers, GAO's report helped shift attention toward incident management. States responding to GAO and to later federal rules have strengthened incident reporting requirements, investigation expectations, and data systems.
OIG's Review of New York's Assisted Living Program
OIG's March 2022 audit of New York's Medicaid Assisted Living Program (ALP) illustrates how billing and health and safety findings intersect. OIG noted that the audit was prompted in part by GAO's 2018 finding that improved CMS oversight of state monitoring of Medicaid assisted living services was needed.
In New York, beneficiaries receiving ALP services generally require supervision and personal care to carry out basic activities of daily living, and ALP providers must meet state life safety and emergency planning requirements. OIG randomly sampled 100 beneficiary-months from calendar years 2017 and 2018 and visited five providers to review life safety and emergency planning.
OIG found that New York verified that the providers it visited met life safety and emergency planning requirements. However, claims for 9 of the 100 sampled beneficiary-months included unallowable ALP services. Deficiencies included beneficiary assessments and care plans that were missing or not valid, including timeliness issues; services that did not meet Medicaid billing requirements or the beneficiary's care plan; and incomplete required documentation, including documentation of nurse aide qualifications. OIG estimated that New York improperly claimed at least $1.9 million in federal Medicaid reimbursement and noted that the health and safety of some beneficiaries may have been put at risk because their assessments and care plans were not valid. OIG recommended that New York refund the federal share and strengthen oversight so that providers complete timely, valid assessments, bill only for services provided, maintain required documentation, and deliver services under valid care plans.
OIG's HCBS Health and Safety Audit Series
OIG has conducted a broad series of health and safety audits of HCBS settings serving vulnerable adults, including adult day care centers, adult foster care and adult family homes, and supported living settings. While these audits do not all involve assisted living facilities, they apply the same federal waiver health and welfare requirements and reveal the kinds of problems state surveyors and OIG auditors look for in residential and community settings.
Adult Day Care and Adult Day Health
OIG's adult day audits have found widespread noncompliance:
• Kentucky did not comply with federal waiver and state requirements at 14 of 20 adult day health care facilities reviewed, and OIG concluded the state's annual inspections were insufficient to ensure a continuously safe and nonhazardous environment.
• Maryland did not comply with federal waiver and state requirements at 20 adult day care facilities audited; 18 did not comply with one or more health and safety requirements, all 20 failed one or more administrative requirements, and OIG identified 253 instances of noncompliance.
• Ohio did not comply at 18 of 19 adult day facilities audited, because its inspections were insufficient, and OIG recommended that the state ensure providers correct 117 instances of noncompliance.
• South Carolina did not comply at 19 of 20 adult day care facilities.
• New Jersey did not ensure providers complied with requirements at all 20 adult day health services facilities audited.
Adult Family Homes and Foster Care
OIG reported in 2024 that Washington State's oversight could better ensure that adult family homes serving vulnerable adults comply with health and safety and administrative requirements. An earlier OIG review found that Minnesota, Illinois, Wisconsin, and Mississippi did not comply with federal waiver and state requirements in overseeing adult day care centers and foster care homes.
Supported Living Settings
OIG's series on residential settings for people with developmental disabilities found that Indiana did not fully comply with federal waiver and state health, safety, and administrative requirements at 30 residential settings, that North Dakota could better ensure compliance at 44 residential settings, including oversight of infection control, and that Missouri's oversight of individualized supported living providers could be improved in some areas. OIG completed a Connecticut audit in this series in September 2026.
Common Themes
Across these audits, OIG repeatedly found:
• Physical environment hazards, such as accessible chemicals and medications, unsafe electrical conditions, tripping hazards, and inadequate maintenance.
• Fire safety and emergency preparedness gaps, including missing drills, expired extinguishers, and incomplete emergency plans.
• Infection control weaknesses.
• Missing or incomplete staff background checks and training.
• Administrative deficiencies, such as incomplete participant records and care plans.
• State inspections that were too infrequent or not thorough enough to detect continuing problems.
OIG's recommendations typically directed states to ensure providers correct identified deficiencies, improve oversight and monitoring, and work with providers to improve facilities, staffing, and training.
Why These Findings Matter to Assisted Living Providers
When OIG finds that a state's inspections were insufficient, the state is likely to inspect more often, inspect more thoroughly, and follow up more aggressively on corrective action. When OIG finds billing problems, the state is likely to audit provider claims and recover overpayments. Assisted living providers participating in Medicaid waivers should expect:
• More frequent and unannounced health and safety inspections.
• Review of assessments, person-centered service plans, and documentation of services billed.
• Verification of staff qualifications and background checks.
• Closer scrutiny of incident reporting and investigation.
• Review of compliance with HCBS settings requirements.
• Expectations to correct deficiencies quickly and document correction.
The Federal Requirements Behind the Findings
Health and Welfare Assurances
States operating 1915(c) waivers must assure CMS that necessary safeguards have been taken to protect beneficiaries' health and welfare, including adequate standards for providers. CMS evaluates state performance through waiver assurances and performance measures.
Person-Centered Planning
Under 42 CFR 441.301(c), services must be delivered under a person-centered service plan based on an assessment of functional need, reviewed at least every 12 months and when needs change. The plan must identify services, providers, risks, and backup plans. OIG's New York audit found missing or invalid assessments and care plans, which illustrates how central these documents are.
Incident Management
The 2024 Medicaid Access Rule strengthened federal requirements for HCBS incident management, including expectations that states operate incident management systems, define critical incidents, require providers to report them, investigate them, and use data to improve quality, with phased implementation dates. Providers should expect state requirements for incident reporting timelines, investigation, and follow-up to tighten as states implement these provisions.
HCBS Settings Requirements
Assisted living settings that receive Medicaid HCBS funding must meet federal settings requirements, including resident choice of setting, privacy in living units, lockable doors, control over schedules and activities, access to food at any time, visitors at any time, and a lease or similar legally enforceable agreement. Any modifications to these rights must be supported by an assessed need and documented in the person-centered plan.
Building Audit Readiness for Assisted Living Waiver Providers
Assessments and Service Plans
• Make sure every Medicaid resident has a current assessment and person-centered service plan before services are billed.
• Track reassessment and plan review dates, including reviews triggered by changes in condition.
• Confirm that services delivered and billed match the plan.
• Obtain required signatures and keep copies of plans developed by case managers.
Service Documentation
• Document services delivered each day, consistent with the waiver's service definitions and billing units.
• Use task-based documentation for personal care and medication assistance.
• Reconcile documentation with billing before claims are submitted.
• Do not bill for days when the resident was hospitalized or away unless the waiver allows it.
Staff Qualifications
• Complete background checks before staff begin work and keep evidence on file.
• Track required training and certifications, such as nurse aide or medication aide qualifications, and their expiration dates.
• Screen staff against federal and state exclusion lists.
Health and Safety
• Conduct regular environmental inspections focused on the hazards OIG commonly finds, such as accessible chemicals, unsecured medications, electrical hazards, water temperatures, and maintenance problems.
• Maintain fire safety equipment and conduct and document drills on all shifts.
• Keep emergency preparedness plans current and train staff.
• Follow infection prevention practices and document them.
Incident Management
• Train staff to recognize and report critical incidents, including abuse, neglect, exploitation, serious injuries, medication errors, and unexpected deaths.
• Report incidents within required timeframes to the state, case managers, and other required parties.
• Investigate incidents, document findings, implement corrective actions, and update care plans.
• Review incident trends and use them to improve care.
HCBS Settings Compliance
• Use residency agreements that provide protections comparable to a lease.
• Respect privacy, choice, and autonomy, and document any individualized modifications in the person-centered plan.
Internal Audits
• Conduct periodic internal audits of resident records, billing, staff files, and the physical environment.
• Use mock inspections based on state survey tools and OIG audit patterns.
• Track findings to correction.
Responding to an Audit or Inspection
• Cooperate fully and provide records promptly.
• Correct immediate hazards on the spot when possible and document correction.
• Review findings carefully and submit corrective action plans that address root causes.
• For billing audits, assemble assessments, plans, service documentation, and staff qualifications for each sampled claim, and respond with specific evidence.
• Use available appeal processes within deadlines.
• Report and return identified overpayments as required by section 1128J(d) of the Social Security Act.
Medication Assistance and Administration
Medication management is one of the highest-risk areas in assisted living and a frequent focus of state inspections. Depending on state law and the waiver's service definitions, staff may assist residents with self-administration, or licensed or certified staff may administer medications. Documentation should include current physician orders, medication administration or assistance records showing each dose, documentation of refusals and missed doses with follow-up, secure storage, disposal records, and evidence that staff assisting with medications are trained and qualified as required. OIG's New York audit found missing documentation of nurse aide qualifications, which illustrates how staff qualification gaps can turn into billing findings when the service billed requires qualified staff.
Case Management Coordination
In most waiver programs, an independent case manager or care coordinator develops or oversees the person-centered plan, authorizes services, and monitors the resident. Assisted living providers should keep copies of current plans and authorizations from case managers, communicate changes in condition promptly, and document that communication. When a resident's needs change significantly, the provider should request a plan review rather than delivering and billing services that are not in the plan. Good coordination reduces the risk that services billed do not match the authorized plan, one of the deficiencies OIG identified in New York.
Room and Board and Resident Funds
Because Medicaid does not pay for room and board, residents typically pay those costs from their own income. States may limit what facilities can charge Medicaid residents, require that residents retain a personal needs allowance, and prohibit supplementation arrangements that conflict with program rules. Providers should keep clear records of room and board charges, collections, and any resident funds they manage, and should make sure billing to Medicaid includes only covered waiver services. Errors in this area can lead to findings in both billing audits and resident rights reviews.
Preparing Staff for Inspections and Audits
Front-line staff are often the first people inspectors and auditors meet. Staff should know where records are kept, how to report incidents, how to describe residents' care plans, and how to answer questions accurately. Leaders should prepare staff before inspection windows, encourage them to raise safety concerns at any time, and make clear that records must never be altered after an audit request.
Staff who understand why documentation and safety practices matter are far more likely to follow them consistently between inspections.
Myths About Assisted Living Waiver Oversight
Myth: Assisted Living Is Not Subject to Federal Oversight
While CMS does not certify assisted living facilities as it does nursing homes, federal waiver requirements apply to Medicaid-funded services, and OIG and GAO review state oversight.
Myth: Licensing Inspections Are Enough
OIG has repeatedly found that state inspections were insufficient to ensure continuously safe environments. Providers should maintain compliance continuously, not only before inspections.
Myth: Billing Audits Only Look at Claims
OIG's New York audit linked billing findings to assessments, care plans, and staff qualifications.
Myth: Incident Reporting Is Optional When No Harm Occurs
Many states require reporting of incidents with potential for harm, and federal requirements are strengthening incident management.
Questions Leadership Should Ask
• Does every Medicaid resident have a current, valid assessment and person-centered plan?
• Do our service records support every unit billed?
• Are staff background checks and qualifications documented for everyone?
• When did we last inspect our environment for the hazards OIG commonly finds?
• Are incidents reported, investigated, and used for improvement?
• Do our residency agreements and practices meet HCBS settings requirements?
Key Takeaways
• GAO found that 48 states spent more than $10 billion on Medicaid assisted living services and that state oversight of critical incidents varied widely.
• OIG's audit of New York's Assisted Living Program found unallowable services in 9 of 100 sampled beneficiary-months, largely due to invalid assessments and care plans, billing that did not match care plans, and missing staff qualification documentation.
• OIG's HCBS health and safety audits of adult day, adult family home, and supported living settings in many states found widespread noncompliance and insufficient state inspections.
• Federal requirements for person-centered planning, incident management, and HCBS settings drive what states and auditors examine.
• Assisted living providers that maintain valid plans, accurate service documentation, qualified staff, safe environments, and strong incident management are best prepared.
How HealthBridge Can Help
HealthBridge helps assisted living providers participating in Medicaid waivers prepare for state inspections and billing audits. Our team can review assessments, person-centered service plans, and service documentation against your state's waiver requirements; reconcile documentation with billing; verify staff qualifications and background checks; and conduct environmental and emergency preparedness walkthroughs modeled on OIG audit findings. We help providers strengthen incident management, HCBS settings compliance, and internal audit programs, and we support corrective action plans and audit responses. If your assisted living community wants to strengthen Medicaid waiver audit readiness, please get in touch with us. We will be happy to help you with this topic.
References
• U.S. Government Accountability Office. Medicaid Assisted Living Services: Improved Federal Oversight of Beneficiary Health and Welfare Is Needed (GAO-18-179). https://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-18-179
• HHS Office of Inspector General. New York Verified That Medicaid Assisted Living Program Providers Met Life Safety and Emergency Planning Requirements But Did Not Always Ensure That Assisted Living Program Services Met Federal and State Requirements (A-02-19-01017). https://oig.hhs.gov/oas/reports/region2/21901017.asp
• HHS Office of Inspector General. Kentucky Did Not Comply With Federal Waiver and State Requirements at 14 of 20 Adult Day Health Care Facilities Reviewed (A-04-18-00123). https://oig.hhs.gov/reports/all/2019/kentucky-did-not-comply-with-federal-waiver-and-state-requirements-at-14-of-20-adult-day-health-care-facilities-reviewed
• HHS Office of Inspector General. Maryland Did Not Comply With Federal Waiver and State Requirements at 20 Adult Day Care Facilities Audited (A-03-24-00201). https://oig.hhs.gov/reports/all/2025/maryland-did-not-comply-with-federal-waiver-and-state-requirements-at-20-adult-day-care-facilities-audited/
• HHS Office of Inspector General. Ohio Did Not Comply With Federal Waiver and State Requirements at 18 of 19 Adult Day Care Facilities Audited (A-05-23-00006). https://oig.hhs.gov/reports/all/2025/ohio-did-not-comply-with-federal-waiver-and-state-requirements-at-18-of-19-adult-day-care-facilities-audited/
• HHS Office of Inspector General. South Carolina Did Not Comply With Federal Waiver and State Requirements at 19 of 20 Adult Day Care Facilities (A-04-24-00137). https://oig.hhs.gov/reports/all/2025/south-carolina-did-not-comply-with-federal-waiver-and-state-requirements-at-19-of-20-adult-day-care-facilities
• HHS Office of Inspector General. New Jersey Did Not Ensure Providers Complied With Federal and State Requirements at All 20 Adult Day Health Services Facilities Audited (A-02-24-01009). https://oig.hhs.gov/reports/all/2025/new-jersey-did-not-ensure-providers-complied-with-federal-and-state-requirements-at-all-20-adult-day-health-services-facilities-audited/
• HHS Office of Inspector General. Washington State's Oversight Could Better Ensure That Adult Family Homes Comply With Health and Safety and Administrative Requirements (A-09-23-02002). https://oig.hhs.gov/reports/all/2024/washington-states-oversight-could-better-ensure-that-adult-family-homes-comply-with-health-and-safety-and-administrative-requirements/
• HHS Office of Inspector General. Four States Did Not Comply With Federal Waiver and State Requirements in Overseeing Adult Day Care Centers and Foster Care Homes (A-05-19-00005). https://oig.hhs.gov/oas/reports/region5/51900005.asp
• HHS Office of Inspector General. Indiana Did Not Fully Comply With Federal Waiver and State Health, Safety, and Administrative Requirements at 30 Residential Settings (A-05-24-00013). https://oig.hhs.gov/reports/all/2025/indiana-did-not-fully-comply-with-federal-waiver-and-state-health-safety-and-administrative-requirements-at-30-residential-settings
• HHS Office of Inspector General. North Dakota Could Better Ensure That Providers Fully Comply With Federal Waiver and State Health, Safety, and Administrative Requirements at 44 Residential Settings (A-07-24-04137). https://oig.hhs.gov/reports/all/2026/north-dakota-could-better-ensure-that-providers-fully-comply-with-federal-waiver-and-state-health-safety-and-administrative-requirements-at-44-residential-settings/
• HHS Office of Inspector General. Missouri's Oversight of Certified Individualized Supported Living Provider Health and Safety Could Be Improved in Some Areas (A-07-21-03247). https://oig.hhs.gov/oas/reports/region7/72103247.asp
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 441.301, Contents of request for a waiver. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-C/part-441/subpart-G/section-441.301
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 441.302, State assurances. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-C/part-441/subpart-G/section-441.302
• U.S. Code. 42 U.S.C. 1320a-7k(d), Reporting and returning of overpayments. https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid:USC-prelim-title42-section1320a-7k

Some or all of the services described herein may not be permissible for HealthBridge US clients and their affiliates or related entities.
The information provided is general in nature and is not intended to address the specific circumstances of any individual or entity. While we strive to offer accurate and timely information, we cannot guarantee that such information remains accurate after it is received or that it will continue to be accurate over time. Anyone seeking to act on such information should first seek professional advice tailored to their specific situation. HealthBridge US does not offer legal services.
HealthBridge US is not affiliated with any department of public health agencies in any state, nor with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). We offer healthcare consulting services exclusively and are an independent consulting firm not affiliated with any regulatory organizations, including but not limited to the Accrediting Organizations, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), and state departments. HealthBridge is an anti-fraud company in full compliance with all applicable federal and state regulations for CMS, as well as other relevant business and healthcare laws. The badges, icons, and achievement graphics displayed on this website represent proprietary performance metrics, volume milestones, and internal corporate recognition issued exclusively by our corporate affiliate network at SummitRidge. These visual markers are utilized solely as historical indicators of enterprise growth, operational longevity, and volume-based milestones cleared within our shared corporate ecosystem.
© 2026 HealthBridge US, a California corporation. All rights reserved.
For more information about the structure of HealthBridge, visit www.myhbconsulting.com/governance
