Critical Access Hospital Medicare Audit Readiness: The 96-Hour Condition and Cost Report Review

A readiness guide for critical access hospitals: the two different 96-hour rules (the condition of participation and the condition of payment), physician certification, what counts toward the average, CAH cost-based payment, cost report desk reviews and audits, and how to prepare.

KNOWLEDGE CENTER

11/15/202611 min read

Critical access hospitals (CAHs) are small rural hospitals that receive special Medicare designation and cost-based payment in exchange for meeting specific requirements. CAHs may have no more than 25 inpatient beds, must generally be located a specified distance from other hospitals, must provide 24-hour emergency services, and must limit inpatient stays. Medicare generally pays CAHs 101 percent of reasonable cost for inpatient, outpatient, and swing bed services.

Two areas create recurring audit risk for CAHs. The first is the 96-hour rule, which actually consists of two different requirements: a condition of participation that limits the annual average length of stay, and a condition of payment that requires physician certification for each inpatient. The second is the Medicare cost report, which determines the CAH's final Medicare payment and is subject to desk review and audit by the Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC).

This article explains both 96-hour requirements, CAH payment, cost report review, and practical readiness steps. It is educational and does not replace legal or professional advice.

The Two 96-Hour Requirements

The Condition of Participation

Under 42 CFR 485.620(b), a CAH must provide acute inpatient care for a period that does not exceed, on an annual average basis, 96 hours per patient. This is an average across all acute inpatient stays, not a limit on any individual stay. A single patient may stay longer than 96 hours without violating the condition, as long as the annual average remains at or below 96 hours.

CMS's CAH information and Medicare Learning Network materials explain that swing bed services and beds in distinct part psychiatric or rehabilitation units are excluded from the calculation, and that hospice patients admitted to the CAH are not included in the 96-hour annual average. MACs calculate compliance with the annual average. During the COVID-19 public health emergency, CMS waived the annual average requirement from March 1, 2020, through May 11, 2023, and CMS issued memorandum QSO-23-17-CAH describing a one-time adjustment to the calculation period to account for the waiver.

The Condition of Payment

Separately, Section 1814(a)(8) of the Social Security Act and 42 CFR 424.15 require, as a condition of Medicare Part A payment for CAH inpatient services, that a physician certify that the individual may reasonably be expected to be discharged or transferred to a hospital within 96 hours after admission to the CAH. Under the regulation, the physician must provide this certification no later than one day before the date on which the claim for payment for the inpatient CAH services is submitted.

CMS guidance explains that if a physician cannot in good faith certify that an individual may reasonably be expected to be discharged or transferred within 96 hours, the CAH will not receive Medicare Part A payment for any portion of that individual's inpatient stay. The certification is about the expectation at admission, not the actual length of stay. A patient who unexpectedly stays longer than 96 hours does not invalidate a good faith certification.

Other Certification Requirements

CAH inpatient certification also includes the content required for other hospitals: the reasons for inpatient services, the estimated time the patient will need to remain in the CAH, and plans for post-hospital care, if appropriate. The 96-hour certification may be combined with these elements or documented separately.

Common 96-Hour Problems

• No documentation of the 96-hour expectation for inpatient stays.

• Certification signed after the claim was submitted.

• Certifications that appear templated without regard to the patient's expected course.

• Patients with conditions clearly expected to require stays longer than 96 hours, such as complex medical cases that ordinarily would be transferred, admitted without transfer planning.

• Annual average approaching 96 hours because of long stays.

• Confusion between acute inpatient days and swing bed days, inflating the average.

Managing the Annual Average

• Track the running annual average monthly.

• Review long stays and transfer decisions.

• Ensure that patients who move to swing bed status are discharged from acute status and admitted to swing bed status with clear documentation, so swing bed days are not counted as acute days.

• Exclude hospice patients and distinct part unit patients correctly.

When Patients Need Longer Care

When a patient's condition requires a longer acute stay than anticipated, the CAH should document the clinical reasons, consider whether transfer to a larger hospital is appropriate, and continue to monitor the annual average. The certification remains valid if it was made in good faith based on the information available at admission.

The Two-Midnight Rule and CAHs

The Two-Midnight Rule under 42 CFR 412.3 also applies to CAH inpatient admissions. CAHs must document a reasonable expectation of a medically necessary stay spanning at least two midnights, or an exception, to support inpatient status. This can feel inconsistent with the 96-hour expectation, but the two rules work together: many CAH inpatients are expected to stay more than two midnights but fewer than four days.

CAH Payment Basics

Cost-Based Payment

Under 42 CFR 413.70, Medicare generally pays CAHs 101 percent of reasonable costs for inpatient and outpatient services. Swing bed services are also paid on a reasonable cost basis. Payments during the year are interim, based on rates set by the MAC, and are reconciled at final settlement of the cost report.

Optional Method for Outpatient Services

CAHs may elect the optional method, often called Method II, under which the CAH bills for both facility and professional services for practitioners who have reassigned their billing rights to the CAH. Professional services are paid at 115 percent of the fee schedule amount. Election and reassignment rules must be followed carefully.

Distinct Part Units

CAHs may operate distinct part psychiatric and rehabilitation units of up to 10 beds each. These units are paid under the applicable prospective payment systems, not on a cost basis.

The CAH Cost Report

Why the Cost Report Matters More for CAHs

Because CAH payment is based on cost, the cost report directly determines how much Medicare pays. Errors in costs, statistics, allocations, or days can significantly change final payment.

Key Cost Report Areas for CAHs

• Allowable costs and their classification in cost centers.

• Statistics used to allocate overhead, such as square footage, hours, or accumulated costs.

• Inpatient days, separating acute, swing bed, observation, and distinct part days.

• Charges and the ratio of cost to charges for ancillary services.

• Swing bed costs, including the method for carving out swing bed routine costs.

• Professional component costs and provider-based physician costs.

• Ambulance costs, if the CAH qualifies for cost-based ambulance payment.

• Medicare bad debts.

• Related-party costs.

• Method II professional services.

Desk Reviews and Audits

MACs perform a desk review of every cost report to determine the adequacy, completeness, accuracy, and reasonableness of the data, and conduct audits as warranted before final settlement. OIG has noted that the desk review does not include detailed verification and is designed to identify issues that may warrant an audit. Recent OIG work has found weaknesses in MAC oversight. In March 2025, OIG reported that each of the 12 MAC jurisdictions failed to meet contract requirements for audit and reimbursement desk review and audit quality for at least one of fiscal years 2019 through 2021, and later 2025 audits of individual MACs found desk review errors in cost reports that were reopened to correct final settlements. These findings suggest that MACs may increase the rigor of desk reviews, which CAHs should anticipate.

Common CAH Cost Report Adjustments

• Disallowance of nonallowable costs, such as certain advertising, lobbying, or entertainment.

• Reclassification of costs between cost centers.

• Adjustments to statistics that do not match source documentation.

• Adjustments to inpatient and swing bed days.

• Disallowance of bad debts that do not meet requirements, such as reasonable collection efforts.

• Related-party cost adjustments.

• Adjustments to physician and professional costs.

Preparing for Cost Report Review

Documentation

Maintain a cost report support binder or electronic file that includes:

• The trial balance and reconciliation to the cost report.

• Workpapers for every reclassification and adjustment.

• Source documents for statistics.

• Census reports separating acute, swing bed, observation, and distinct part days.

• Bad debt listings with collection documentation.

• Related-party disclosures and cost support.

• Contracts for physician and professional services.

• Prior year audit adjustments and how they were addressed.

Internal Review

• Review the cost report before filing, with someone other than the preparer.

• Compare key statistics and costs with prior years and explain variances.

• Confirm that prior audit adjustments have been addressed.

• Confirm that day counts match the census and billing systems.

Responding to MAC Requests

• Respond to desk review and audit requests promptly and completely.

• Provide organized workpapers.

• Discuss proposed adjustments at the exit conference and provide additional support.

• Track agreed and disputed adjustments.

Appeal Rights

If the CAH disagrees with the final settlement, reflected in the Notice of Program Reimbursement, it may appeal to the Provider Reimbursement Review Board under 42 CFR 405.1835 within 180 days, if the amount in controversy is at least $10,000 for an individual appeal. CAHs may also request reopening within three years of the Notice of Program Reimbursement under 42 CFR 405.1885. For items the CAH believes are not allowable under Medicare policy but wishes to preserve for appeal, it may claim them as protested amounts under 42 CFR 413.24(j).

Other CAH Audit Risks

Swing Beds

Swing bed claims must meet SNF coverage requirements, including the qualifying stay, daily skilled need, and certification. Swing bed days and costs must be separated correctly on the cost report.

Emergency Services

CAHs must meet emergency service conditions of participation, including on-site response time requirements for practitioners on call.

Location and Designation

CAHs must continue to meet location requirements. Changes in roads or nearby hospitals can raise questions, and state survey agencies and CMS review compliance.

Outpatient Services

Outpatient services must meet Medicare coverage requirements. CAHs are also subject to outpatient medical review, including prior authorization for certain hospital outpatient services.

Building a CAH Readiness Program

• Assign responsibility for monitoring the 96-hour annual average and certification compliance.

• Build the 96-hour certification into admission workflows, with a hold on billing until it is complete.

• Train physicians and advanced practice providers on both 96-hour rules and the Two-Midnight Rule.

• Separate acute and swing bed documentation clearly.

• Maintain cost report support files and conduct pre-filing reviews.

• Track MAC adjustments and address recurring issues.

• Audit a sample of inpatient and swing bed claims quarterly.

A Hypothetical Example

A CAH's MAC notes during a desk review that swing bed days appear low compared with census data, and the CAH's internal review finds that some patients who moved to swing bed status were never formally discharged from acute status, inflating acute days and the 96-hour average. The CAH revises its transition workflow to require an acute discharge order and swing bed admission order, corrects its census reporting, and documents the correction for the MAC. It also adds a billing hold until the 96-hour certification is complete for every inpatient claim. Its next desk review has fewer adjustments.

Writing a Good Faith 96-Hour Certification

A strong certification reflects the physician's actual clinical judgment. For most CAH inpatients, such as patients admitted for pneumonia, cellulitis, heart failure exacerbations, or postoperative care after a minor procedure, a stay of fewer than 96 hours is a reasonable expectation. The certification can be brief, but it should be patient specific and signed by a physician. Useful practices include:

• Including a 96-hour certification statement in the admission order set, with an option to indicate that the expectation cannot be certified.

• Prompting the physician to document the expected length of stay and post-discharge plan.

• Requiring a physician signature, since the statute and regulation refer to physician certification.

• Holding claims in the billing system until the certification is complete.

• Auditing a sample of certifications each quarter.

When a physician cannot certify a 96-hour expectation, the CAH should consider whether transfer to another hospital is appropriate. If the patient is admitted anyway, the CAH should understand that Medicare Part A will not pay for the stay and should follow beneficiary notice and billing rules.

Coordinating the CoP and Payment Rules

Because the condition of participation and the condition of payment are separate, CAHs should manage them separately but with shared data. The annual average is a facility-level metric monitored by quality and finance staff and evaluated by the MAC and surveyors. The certification is a claim-level requirement monitored by health information management and billing staff. A single dashboard showing monthly average length of stay, stays exceeding 96 hours, transfers, and certification completion rates helps leaders see both.

Common Myths About CAH Audits

Myth: Any Stay Over 96 Hours Is a Violation

The condition of participation is an annual average. Individual stays may exceed 96 hours.

Myth: The 96-Hour Certification Is Optional if the Average Is Low

The certification is a condition of payment for each inpatient claim, regardless of the annual average.

Myth: Cost-Based Payment Means Audits Do Not Matter

Because payment is based on cost, cost report adjustments directly change final payment.

Myth: Swing Bed Days Count Toward the Acute Average

Swing bed services are excluded, but only if the transition from acute to swing bed status is properly documented and reported.

Questions Leadership Should Ask

• What is our current annual average length of stay, and how close is it to 96 hours?

• Is a physician-signed 96-hour certification present for every inpatient claim?

• Are acute and swing bed days separated correctly in census and cost reporting?

• What were the main adjustments in our last cost report desk review or audit?

• Do we maintain organized cost report support files?

• Are we tracking reopening windows and appeal deadlines?

Key Takeaways

• The 96-hour condition of participation is an annual average; the 96-hour certification is a claim-level condition of payment.

• The certification must be made in good faith and signed no later than one day before the claim is submitted.

• CAHs are generally paid 101 percent of reasonable cost, so the cost report determines final payment.

• OIG's findings on MAC oversight suggest more rigorous desk reviews.

• Clear acute and swing bed transitions, certification workflows, and cost report support reduce risk.

Survey and Designation Considerations

State survey agencies evaluate CAH compliance with the conditions of participation, including the length of stay standard, using CMS's State Operations Manual. If a CAH's annual average exceeds 96 hours, it may be cited and required to submit a plan of correction, and persistent noncompliance can threaten CAH designation. CAHs should be prepared to show surveyors how they calculate and monitor the average, how they manage long stays and transfers, and how they distinguish acute from swing bed care. Keeping calculation workpapers and monthly monitoring reports makes surveys smoother.

Planning the Annual Cost Report Cycle

CAHs benefit from a calendar that maps the full cost report cycle: closing the fiscal year, preparing workpapers, internal review, filing within five months, responding to tentative settlement and desk review questions, reviewing the Notice of Program Reimbursement, and tracking appeal and reopening deadlines. Assigning a date and owner to each step prevents last-minute filings, missing support, and missed appeal rights.

Medicare Bad Debt for CAHs

Medicare bad debts are reimbursed for CAHs on a cost basis, making them an important part of the CAH cost report. To be allowable under 42 CFR 413.89, bad debts must relate to covered services and uncollected Medicare deductibles and coinsurance, follow reasonable collection efforts, and be determined uncollectible using sound business judgment. For dual-eligible beneficiaries, CAHs generally must bill the state Medicaid program and obtain a remittance advice. Reviewers frequently adjust bad debts that lack collection documentation, so CAHs should keep complete files for each account claimed.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the 96-hour rule a limit on each patient's stay?

The condition of participation is an annual average. The condition of payment requires a good faith certification that the patient is expected to be discharged or transferred within 96 hours.

When must the 96-hour certification be signed?

No later than one day before the claim for the inpatient stay is submitted.

Are swing bed days included in the 96-hour average?

No. Swing bed services and distinct part unit beds are excluded, and hospice patients are not counted.

How are CAHs paid?

Generally at 101 percent of reasonable cost for inpatient, outpatient, and swing bed services, settled through the cost report.

Can CAHs appeal cost report adjustments?

Yes, to the Provider Reimbursement Review Board within 180 days of the Notice of Program Reimbursement, subject to amount in controversy requirements.

Conclusion

CAH audit readiness depends on understanding the two different 96-hour requirements, documenting physician certification for every inpatient, monitoring the annual average, and maintaining an accurate, well-supported cost report. CAHs that build these practices into daily operations will protect their designation and their cost-based payment.

How HealthBridge Can Help

HealthBridge is a healthcare management consulting firm that helps critical access hospitals monitor 96-hour compliance, design certification workflows, separate acute and swing bed documentation, prepare and review cost reports, respond to MAC desk reviews and audits, and support appeals. If your CAH wants to strengthen its audit readiness, please get in touch with us. We will be happy to help you with this topic.

References

• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 485.620, Condition of Participation: Number of Beds and Length of Stay. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-G/part-485/subpart-F/section-485.620

• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 424.15, Requirements for Inpatient CAH Services. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-424/subpart-B/section-424.15

• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 413.70, Payment for Services of a CAH. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-413/subpart-E/section-413.70

• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 412.3, Admissions. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-412/subpart-A/section-412.3

• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 405.1835, Right to Board Hearing. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-405/subpart-R/section-405.1835

• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 405.1885, Reopening a Contractor Determination or Reviewing Entity Decision. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-405/subpart-R/section-405.1885

• U.S. Social Security Administration. Social Security Act, Section 1814, Conditions of and Limitations on Payment for Services. https://www.ssa.gov/OP_Home/ssact/title18/1814.htm

• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Critical Access Hospitals (Certification and Compliance). https://www.cms.gov/medicare/health-safety-standards/certification-compliance/critical-access-hospitals

• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. QSO-23-17-CAH, One-Time Change to CAH Annual Average 96-Hour Patient Length of Stay Calculations to Account for the COVID-19 PHE. https://www.cms.gov/medicare/provider-enrollment-and-certification/surveycertificationgeninfo/policy-and-memos-states/3888948/one-time-change-critical-access-hospital-cah-annual-average-96-hour-patient-length-stay-calculations

• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Quality, Safety and Oversight Certification and Compliance for Critical Access Hospitals. https://www.hhs.gov/guidance/document/quality-safety-and-oversight-certification-and-compliance-critical-access-hospitals

• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General. Medicare Administrative Contractors Did Not Consistently Meet Medicare Cost Report Oversight Requirements (A-04-22-06264). https://oig.hhs.gov/documents/audit/10238/A-04-22-06264-highlights.pdf

• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. State Operations Manual, Appendix W, Critical Access Hospitals. https://www.cms.gov/medicare/provider-enrollment-and-certification/guidanceforlawsandregulations/downloads/som107ap_w_cah.pdf

Some or all of the services described herein may not be permissible for HealthBridge US clients and their affiliates or related entities.

The information provided is general in nature and is not intended to address the specific circumstances of any individual or entity. While we strive to offer accurate and timely information, we cannot guarantee that such information remains accurate after it is received or that it will continue to be accurate over time. Anyone seeking to act on such information should first seek professional advice tailored to their specific situation. HealthBridge US does not offer legal services.

HealthBridge US is not affiliated with any department of public health agencies in any state, nor with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). We offer healthcare consulting services exclusively and are an independent consulting firm not affiliated with any regulatory organizations, including but not limited to the Accrediting Organizations, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), and state departments. HealthBridge is an anti-fraud company in full compliance with all applicable federal and state regulations for CMS, as well as other relevant business and healthcare laws. The badges, icons, and achievement graphics displayed on this website represent proprietary performance metrics, volume milestones, and internal corporate recognition issued exclusively by our corporate affiliate network at SummitRidge. These visual markers are utilized solely as historical indicators of enterprise growth, operational longevity, and volume-based milestones cleared within our shared corporate ecosystem.

© 2026 HealthBridge US, a California corporation. All rights reserved.

For more information about the structure of HealthBridge, visit www.myhbconsulting.com/governance

Legal

Resources