Dialysis Facility Survey and Medicare Audit Readiness: A Combined Mock Audit Approach
How dialysis facilities can prepare for state surveys and Medicare audits at the same time: the ESRD Core Survey and the 2026 move of guidance to SOM Appendix H, conditions for coverage, OIG audit risk areas, and a step-by-step combined mock audit with checklists.
KNOWLEDGE CENTER
11/15/202611 min read
Dialysis facilities face two kinds of external review that often feel separate. State survey agencies and accrediting organizations survey facilities for compliance with the ESRD conditions for coverage in 42 CFR Part 494. Medicare contractors and OIG audit claims for compliance with payment rules. In practice, the two overlap. OIG's provider compliance audits of dialysis facilities have treated incomplete assessments, plans of care, and physician progress notes, which are conditions for coverage, as reasons that claims did not meet Medicare requirements. Survey findings can reveal documentation weaknesses that auditors will also find.
In May 2026, CMS issued QSO-26-09-ESRD, relocating the ESRD interpretive guidance and survey procedures to Appendix H of the State Operations Manual, updating guidance to reflect regulatory changes and prior QSO memos, and adding guidance and survey processes for home dialysis in nursing homes. This is a good moment for facilities to review their readiness.
This article explains the survey process and audit risks, and describes a combined mock audit approach that tests both at once. It is educational and does not replace legal or professional advice.
The ESRD Survey Process
The Core Survey
CMS introduced the ESRD Core Survey process in 2012. It begins with a focus on the survey tags CMS considers most critical for safety and quality and uses facility-specific data, such as the Dialysis Facility Report, to target areas for review. Core Survey tasks include presurvey preparation, an environmental tour, an entrance conference, observations of hemodialysis care and infection control, water and dialysate review, dialyzer reprocessing review when applicable, medical record reviews, patient and staff interviews, review of the quality assessment and performance improvement program, personnel file reviews, and an exit conference.
V-Tags
Survey deficiencies are cited using V-tags that correspond to regulatory requirements. CMS publishes lists of V-tags and Core Survey triggers that lead surveyors to investigate further or cite deficiencies. Commonly reviewed areas include infection control, water and dialysate quality, patient assessment, plan of care, care at home, patient rights, QAPI, personnel qualifications, and emergency preparedness.
The 2026 Relocation to Appendix H
According to QSO-26-09-ESRD, CMS is relocating the ESRD interpretive guidance and survey protocol from the CMS ESRD facility web page to Appendix H of the State Operations Manual, after which the guidance will no longer be available on the CMS ESRD web page. The memo describes updates reflecting recent regulatory changes and prior memos, including guidance on home dialysis in nursing homes under the care at home condition at 42 CFR 494.100, as well as technical revisions such as removing obsolete instructions and reorganizing surveyor worksheets. Facilities should obtain the current Appendix H and use it for self-assessments.
Conditions for Coverage That Matter for Both Survey and Audit
Patient Assessment and Plan of Care
Under 42 CFR 494.80 and 494.90, the interdisciplinary team must complete comprehensive assessments and individualized plans of care within required time frames and update them. OIG cited incomplete assessments and plans of care in its DCI audit, and surveyors review them in medical records.
Care at Home
Under 42 CFR 494.100, facilities offering home dialysis must provide training, monitoring, and support, including periodic monitoring of home adaptation and review of home records. OIG's ongoing home dialysis audit and the new survey guidance on home dialysis in nursing homes make this a priority.
Medical Records
Under 42 CFR 494.170, facilities must maintain complete and accurate medical records. Records are the foundation of both survey and audit.
Infection Control and Water Quality
Under 42 CFR 494.30 and 494.40, facilities must follow infection control and water and dialysate quality standards. These are major survey focuses and can also affect patient outcomes and claims for related services.
QAPI
Under 42 CFR 494.110, facilities must maintain a quality assessment and performance improvement program. Using QAPI to monitor documentation and billing compliance strengthens both survey and audit readiness.
Governance and Medical Director
Under 42 CFR 494.150 and 494.180, the medical director and governing body are responsible for quality, policies, and staff. Leadership oversight of compliance is reviewed by surveyors and expected by OIG.
Medicare Audit Risk Areas
OIG's dialysis audits and Medicare medical review focus on:
• Assessments and plans of care that do not meet requirements.
• Treatments that were not completed or not documented.
• Height and weight measurements that do not comply with requirements.
• Missing monthly physician progress notes.
• Drug administration and dispensing documentation, especially for home patients.
• Comorbidity coding and other payment adjustments.
• Consolidated billing of ESRD-related labs, drugs, and supplies.
• Medicare secondary payer coordination.
• Additional treatments without medical justification.
The Combined Mock Audit Approach
A combined mock audit tests survey and payment compliance with the same records and team, saving time and revealing connections between clinical and billing issues.
Step 1: Assemble the Team
Include a nurse reviewer familiar with the conditions for coverage, a billing and coding reviewer familiar with ESRD PPS rules, a water treatment or biomedical reviewer, and an infection control reviewer. Consider an external reviewer for objectivity.
Step 2: Gather Data
Review the Dialysis Facility Report, quality measures, prior survey results, plans of correction, internal audit results, claim denial data, and any contractor or OIG correspondence. Identify outliers that might trigger survey focus or audit selection.
Step 3: Select a Sample
Select a sample of patients that includes new admissions, long-term patients, home dialysis patients, patients with recent hospitalizations, patients with infections, and patients receiving additional treatments or high-cost drugs. For each patient, select one or more months of claims.
Step 4: Conduct Survey-Style Observations
Observe hemodialysis care, including hand hygiene, glove use, station cleaning, medication preparation, vascular access care, and patient monitoring. Review water treatment logs and testing, dialysate preparation, and equipment maintenance. Conduct an environmental tour.
Step 5: Review Medical Records Against Both Standards
For each sampled patient, review:
• Assessments and reassessments for timeliness and completeness.
• Plans of care for required elements and updates.
• Physician orders and prescriptions.
• Treatment flow sheets for each billed treatment.
• Drug orders, administration records, and claims.
• Height and weight measurements and claim reporting.
• Comorbidity documentation for adjustments billed.
• Monthly physician progress notes.
• Home dialysis training, monitoring, and dispensing records.
• Patient rights, education, and grievance documentation.
Step 6: Compare Records to Claims
For each sampled month, compare the claim to the record: number of treatments billed and documented, drugs and units billed and administered, adjustments claimed and supported, lab values reported and recorded, and modifiers applied.
Step 7: Interview Staff and Patients
Interview staff about infection control, emergency procedures, patient assessment, and documentation practices. Interview patients about their care, education, and rights. Interviews often reveal gaps that records do not.
Step 8: Review QAPI and Governance
Review QAPI minutes, data, and action plans. Confirm that the medical director and governing body oversee compliance, including billing compliance.
Step 9: Report and Correct
Prepare a report that classifies findings as survey deficiencies, payment errors, or both. Develop corrective action plans with owners and deadlines. For payment errors, evaluate overpayment obligations under 42 CFR 401.305 and return identified overpayments. Re-audit to confirm correction.
Mock Audit Checklist
Survey Readiness
• Current policies and procedures aligned with Appendix H.
• Infection control practices observed and documented.
• Water and dialysate testing logs complete.
• Equipment maintenance records current.
• Emergency preparedness plan, training, and drills documented.
• Personnel files with qualifications, training, and competencies.
• Patient rights and grievance processes documented.
• QAPI program active with data and action plans.
Payment Readiness
• Assessments and plans of care timely and complete.
• Orders and prescriptions current and signed.
• Treatment flow sheets complete for every billed treatment.
• Drug units billed match administration records.
• Height and weight reported correctly.
• Comorbidity adjustments supported.
• Monthly physician notes present.
• Home dialysis records complete.
• Consolidated billing applied correctly.
• Medicare secondary payer verified.
Using Results in QAPI
Integrating mock audit results into QAPI turns a one-time review into continuous improvement. Facilities can track metrics such as timely assessment completion, flow sheet completeness, drug reconciliation variances, and physician note availability, alongside clinical quality measures.
Preparing Staff
Staff should understand that surveyors and auditors are looking at the same records. Training should explain why documentation matters for patient safety, survey compliance, and payment. Practice interviews help staff feel comfortable during surveys.
A Hypothetical Example
A dialysis facility conducts a combined mock audit before its expected recertification survey. The team finds that hand hygiene compliance between stations is inconsistent, that several plans of care were updated late, and that three months of claims for home patients included drugs without dispensing documentation. The facility retrains staff on infection control, implements plan of care tracking, adds a signed dispensing log for home patients, and refunds the unsupported drug charges where they affected payment. At the survey, no condition-level deficiencies are cited, and a later internal audit shows improved home documentation.
Linking Survey Findings to Payment Risk
Some survey findings point directly to payment risk. A finding that assessments or plans of care were not completed on time suggests that related claims may not meet Medicare requirements, as OIG concluded in its DCI audit. A finding that treatment monitoring was not documented suggests that treatment flow sheets may not support billed treatments. A finding about home dialysis monitoring suggests that home claims, including drugs and supplies, may lack documentation. When a survey cites deficiencies in these areas, facilities should evaluate whether claims during the affected period were properly supported and whether overpayments exist.
The reverse is also true. Payment audits that find missing documentation may indicate clinical gaps that surveyors would cite. Treating survey and audit findings as two views of the same system helps facilities address root causes.
Infection Control as a Survey Priority
Infection control remains one of the most frequently cited areas in dialysis surveys. Surveyors observe hand hygiene, glove changes, station disinfection, medication preparation in clean areas, catheter care, and isolation practices for patients with hepatitis B. Facilities should conduct regular observational audits, use data from infection surveillance, and report results through QAPI. While infection control is primarily a survey issue, outbreaks can lead to hospitalizations and increased costs, and documentation of infection-related services must be accurate.
Water and Dialysate Quality
Water treatment systems and dialysate quality are critical to patient safety. Surveyors review water testing logs, chlorine and chloramine monitoring, cultures and endotoxin testing, equipment maintenance, and staff competency. Facilities should keep logs complete and investigate any out-of-range results promptly. A mock audit should include a detailed review of the water treatment system and logs by a qualified reviewer.
Emergency Preparedness
Under 42 CFR 494.62, facilities must maintain emergency preparedness programs that include risk assessment, policies, communication plans, training, and testing. Surveyors review plans and exercise documentation. Facilities should also ensure that patients are educated on emergency procedures, including what to do if they cannot reach the facility.
Common Myths About Dialysis Surveys and Audits
Myth: Surveys and Audits Are Unrelated
They review the same records, and conditions for coverage deficiencies can affect payment compliance.
Myth: A Clean Survey Means Claims Are Compliant
Surveys sample a limited number of records and focus on safety and quality. Claims may still have billing errors.
Myth: Mock Audits Are Only for Problem Facilities
All facilities benefit from regular mock audits, especially before recertification or after rule changes.
Myth: The New Appendix H Changes the Requirements
The relocation mainly reorganizes and updates guidance, but facilities should review the changes, especially for home dialysis in nursing homes.
Questions Leadership Should Ask
• When did we last conduct a combined survey and payment mock audit?
• Have we reviewed the new Appendix H guidance?
• Are assessments and plans of care timely for every patient?
• Do home dialysis records support both survey and payment requirements?
• Are infection control and water quality audits reported through QAPI?
• How do we evaluate survey findings for payment impact?
Key Takeaways
• ESRD survey guidance moved to SOM Appendix H under QSO-26-09-ESRD in 2026.
• Surveys and Medicare audits review the same records, and conditions for coverage deficiencies can affect claims.
• A combined mock audit tests infection control, water quality, assessments, plans of care, treatment documentation, drug billing, and home dialysis records together.
• Integrating results into QAPI supports continuous improvement.
• Payment errors found in mock audits should be corrected and evaluated for overpayment obligations.
Personnel and Competency Review
Surveyors review personnel files for qualifications, licensure, patient care technician certification, orientation, annual competency, and training. Billing compliance depends on the same staff documenting care accurately. A mock audit should review a sample of personnel files for qualifications and competencies, and should confirm that training includes documentation and billing basics, such as completing flow sheets, documenting shortened treatments, and recording drug administration. Gaps in competency documentation can be cited by surveyors and can undermine confidence in records during payment audits.
Patient Rights, Grievances, and Involuntary Discharge
The conditions for coverage include patient rights, grievance procedures, and specific requirements for involuntary discharge. Surveyors review grievance logs, patient education records, and discharge documentation. While these requirements do not directly affect billing, they are part of the overall compliance picture and can lead to complaints that trigger surveys. A mock audit should include interviews with patients about their understanding of rights and grievance procedures.
Home Dialysis in Nursing Homes
CMS's survey guidance on home dialysis in long-term care facilities, now incorporated into Appendix H, addresses situations where dialysis facilities provide home dialysis services to nursing home residents. Requirements include written agreements between the dialysis facility and the nursing home, training of nursing home staff, monitoring, and communication. Facilities with these arrangements should review agreements, training records, and monitoring documentation. Billing for these services must also follow ESRD PPS rules for home dialysis, including documentation of treatments and supplies.
After the Mock Audit
The value of a mock audit depends on follow-through. Assign each finding to an owner with a deadline, track progress in QAPI, and re-audit to confirm correction. Report results to the governing body. For findings that involve payment, document the evaluation of overpayment obligations. Keep mock audit reports and corrective action records, which can demonstrate a facility's commitment to compliance if issues arise later.
Scheduling and Frequency
Facilities should conduct a full combined mock audit at least annually and before expected recertification surveys, with focused reviews of high-risk areas, such as infection control, home dialysis, and drug billing, each quarter. Organizations with multiple facilities can rotate reviewers to bring fresh perspectives.
Using Data to Prepare
The Dialysis Facility Report and Care Compare data show how a facility performs on clinical measures relative to peers. Surveyors use these data in presurvey preparation, and auditors use claims data to select targets. Facilities should review both before a mock audit and focus on outliers, such as high hospitalization rates, infection rates, or unusual billing patterns. Explaining outliers with documentation helps during surveys and audits.
Multi-Facility Organizations
Organizations operating many dialysis facilities can standardize mock audit tools, train a team of internal reviewers, and compare results across facilities. Standardization helps identify systemic problems, such as a billing system error affecting every facility, and best practices that can be shared.
Documentation of Mock Audit Methods
Document the mock audit's scope, sample selection, tools, reviewers, and findings. A clear record shows that the facility conducted a meaningful review, supports QAPI, and helps future reviewers compare results over time. When mock audits are conducted under the direction of counsel, facilities should follow counsel's guidance on privilege.
Communicating Results to Staff
Share mock audit results with staff in a constructive way. Celebrate strong areas, explain gaps, and describe the changes being made. Staff who understand the reasons for changes are more likely to sustain them, and open communication prepares them for real surveys and audits.
Regular communication also builds a culture in which staff raise concerns early.
Leaders should model that openness.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the ESRD Core Survey?
The survey process CMS introduced in 2012 that focuses on the most critical safety and quality areas and uses facility data to target review.
Where is the ESRD survey guidance now?
In Appendix H of the State Operations Manual, according to QSO-26-09-ESRD.
Why combine survey and audit preparation?
Because surveys and audits review the same records, and OIG has treated conditions for coverage deficiencies as reasons claims did not meet Medicare requirements.
How often should facilities conduct mock audits?
At least annually, with more frequent focused reviews of high-risk areas.
What should facilities do with payment errors found in a mock audit?
Correct them, evaluate overpayment obligations, and return identified overpayments within required time frames.
Conclusion
Surveys and Medicare audits both depend on complete, accurate records and sound clinical practice. A combined mock audit lets dialysis facilities test infection control, water quality, assessments, plans of care, treatment documentation, drug billing, and home dialysis records together, and fix problems before surveyors or auditors find them.
How HealthBridge Can Help
HealthBridge is a healthcare management consulting firm that helps dialysis facilities conduct combined survey and Medicare mock audits, develop corrective action plans, integrate compliance into QAPI, train staff, and respond to surveys and audits. If your facility wants to prepare for both, please get in touch with us. We will be happy to help you with this topic.
References
• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. QSO-26-09-ESRD, Relocating and Revising CMS Surveyor Guidance for End-Stage Renal Disease Facilities (May 15, 2026). https://www.cms.gov/files/document/qso-26-09-esrd-original-release-date-2026-05-15.pdf
• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. End Stage Renal Disease Facility Providers (Guidance for Laws and Regulations). https://www.cms.gov/medicare/health-safety-standards/guidance-for-laws-regulations/dialysis
• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. QSO-18-24-ESRD (Revised), Guidance and Survey Process for Reviewing Home Dialysis Services in a Long-Term Care Facility. http://www.cms.gov/files/document/qso-18-24-esrd-revised.pdf
• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Survey and Certification Letter 13-18, ESRD Core Survey Process. https://www.cms.gov/medicare/provider-enrollment-and-certification/surveycertificationgeninfo/downloads/survey-and-cert-letter-13-18.pdf
• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. ESRD Core Survey Field Manual and Tools (Dialysis Guidance). https://www.hhs.gov/guidance/document/dialysis
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR Part 494, Conditions for Coverage for End-Stage Renal Disease Facilities. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-G/part-494
• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General. Medicare Dialysis Services Provider Compliance Audit: Dialysis Clinic, Inc. (A-05-20-00010). https://oig.hhs.gov/oas/reports/region5/52000010.asp
• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General. Work Plan: Medicare Part B Audit of Home Dialysis Services (A-05-24-00006). https://www.oig.hhs.gov/reports-and-publications/workplan/summary/wp-summary-0000826.asp
• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Medicare Benefit Policy Manual, Chapter 11, End Stage Renal Disease. https://www.cms.gov/Regulations-and-Guidance/Guidance/Manuals/downloads/bp102c11.pdf
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 401.305, Requirements for Reporting and Returning of Overpayments. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-A/part-401/subpart-D/section-401.305

Some or all of the services described herein may not be permissible for HealthBridge US clients and their affiliates or related entities.
The information provided is general in nature and is not intended to address the specific circumstances of any individual or entity. While we strive to offer accurate and timely information, we cannot guarantee that such information remains accurate after it is received or that it will continue to be accurate over time. Anyone seeking to act on such information should first seek professional advice tailored to their specific situation. HealthBridge US does not offer legal services.
HealthBridge US is not affiliated with any department of public health agencies in any state, nor with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). We offer healthcare consulting services exclusively and are an independent consulting firm not affiliated with any regulatory organizations, including but not limited to the Accrediting Organizations, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), and state departments. HealthBridge is an anti-fraud company in full compliance with all applicable federal and state regulations for CMS, as well as other relevant business and healthcare laws. The badges, icons, and achievement graphics displayed on this website represent proprietary performance metrics, volume milestones, and internal corporate recognition issued exclusively by our corporate affiliate network at SummitRidge. These visual markers are utilized solely as historical indicators of enterprise growth, operational longevity, and volume-based milestones cleared within our shared corporate ecosystem.
© 2026 HealthBridge US, a California corporation. All rights reserved.
For more information about the structure of HealthBridge, visit www.myhbconsulting.com/governance
