Emergency Department E/M Coding Audits: Preventing Downcoding and Overpayment Demands

A guide to emergency department E/M coding audits for physicians and hospitals: 2023 MDM-based professional coding, facility levels under hospital guidelines, OIG's 2026 site-of-service findings and ED E/M audit work, payer downcoding programs, critical care and modifier 25, and how to audit and appeal.

KNOWLEDGE CENTER

11/15/202611 min read

Emergency department evaluation and management (E/M) services are among the most frequently billed services in hospitals, and among the most frequently audited. For physicians and other practitioners, ED visit codes 99281 through 99285 are selected based on medical decision making. For hospitals, facility visit levels are assigned using the hospital's own internal guidelines. Both sides of the claim face scrutiny.

Audit pressure comes from several directions. OIG has tracked the shift toward higher-level ED codes for years and lists an audit of Medicare ED E/M services in its Work Plan. In March 2026, OIG reported more than $15 million in improper and potentially improper Medicare payments for claims billed with ED procedure codes but nonemergency sites of service. Medicare Advantage and commercial payers, as well as Medicaid managed care plans, have implemented automated programs that review or downcode level 4 and level 5 ED claims based on claim data.

This article explains the coding rules, the audit landscape, common errors, how to prevent inappropriate downcoding and overpayment demands, and how to respond. It is educational and does not replace legal or professional advice.

Professional ED E/M Coding

The 2023 Framework

Beginning January 1, 2023, CPT revised ED E/M codes 99281 through 99285 so that level selection is based on medical decision making (MDM). Time is not used to select ED visit levels. History and examination must be medically appropriate but do not determine the level. CMS adopted these revisions for Medicare.

The Three Elements of MDM

MDM is determined by two of three elements:

• The number and complexity of problems addressed at the encounter.

• The amount and/or complexity of data to be reviewed and analyzed, such as tests ordered or reviewed, independent interpretation of tests, review of external notes, independent historians, and discussion with other professionals.

• The risk of complications, morbidity, or mortality of patient management, including decisions about hospitalization, prescription drug management, and surgery.

Levels

• 99281: may not require the presence of a physician or other qualified health care professional.

• 99282: straightforward MDM.

• 99283: low MDM.

• 99284: moderate MDM.

• 99285: high MDM.

Documentation That Supports the Level

• A clear statement of the problems addressed and their severity.

• The differential diagnosis considered, especially for conditions that pose a threat to life or bodily function.

• Tests ordered and results reviewed, with documented interpretation when the clinician independently interprets a test.

• Review of external records and discussion with other clinicians.

• Treatments provided and the patient's response.

• The disposition decision and its rationale, such as a decision regarding hospitalization.

• Risk factors and social determinants of health that affect management.

Critical Care

Critical care services (99291 and 99292) are time-based and require that the patient have a critical illness or injury and that the clinician provide high-complexity decision making to assess, manipulate, and support vital organ function. CMS has specific rules on critical care in the ED, including how time is counted and when ED visits may be billed on the same day. Critical care time must be documented.

Split or Shared Visits

When physicians and nonphysician practitioners share an ED visit, Medicare rules for split or shared services determine who bills, based on who performed the substantive portion. Follow CMS rules in effect for the date of service.

Modifier 25

When a significant, separately identifiable E/M service is performed on the same day as a procedure, such as a laceration repair or fracture care, modifier 25 is appended to the E/M. Documentation must show that the E/M went beyond the usual preprocedure evaluation.

Facility ED Coding

Hospital Visit Levels

Under the hospital outpatient prospective payment system, hospitals report ED visit levels using CPT codes 99281 through 99285 for Type A emergency departments and HCPCS codes G0380 through G0384 for Type B emergency departments. CMS has not adopted national facility visit guidelines. Instead, since the CY 2008 OPPS final rule, CMS has required hospitals to use their own internal guidelines that reflect the resources used and that meet principles CMS established, such as following the intent of CPT code descriptors, being based on hospital facility resources, being clear and consistently applied, and being readily available for review.

Facility Documentation

Facility levels are typically based on interventions, such as nursing assessments, medication administration, diagnostic tests, monitoring, procedures, and coordination of care. Nursing documentation must support the interventions counted.

Revenue Codes and Site of Service

The Medicare Claims Processing Manual requires that ED procedure codes be used only for services furnished in an emergency department. Hospital ED services are reported with ED revenue codes.

The Audit Landscape

OIG

OIG's 2012 report on E/M coding trends found that physicians' billing of the highest-level ED code, 99285, increased 21 percent from 2001 to 2010. OIG lists an audit of Medicare ED E/M services in its Work Plan.

In March 2026, OIG reported (A-07-23-05139) that for 2021 and 2022, Medicare improperly paid physicians $922,524 for 9,749 procedures billed with ED procedure codes and nonemergency place of service codes, and made $14.2 million in potentially improper payments to hospitals for claims billed with ED procedure codes and nonemergency revenue center codes. OIG recommended that CMS recover improper payments, implement or refine claims processing edits, and specify in the Medicare Claims Processing Manual that hospitals must use emergency revenue center codes. CMS concurred with one recommendation and did not concur with the other four.

Medicare Contractors

MACs, Recovery Audit Contractors, and the Comprehensive Error Rate Testing contractor review ED E/M claims. Data analysis can identify practitioners or hospitals with high proportions of level 4 and level 5 visits.

Medicare Advantage, Medicaid Managed Care, and Commercial Payers

Many payers have announced programs that evaluate level 4 and level 5 ED facility or professional claims using diagnosis codes, services billed, and patient history, and that adjust or deny claims when the calculated level does not match the billed level. Some programs apply only to providers with historical patterns of high coding. These programs are governed by payer contracts, payer policies, and state law, and providers should review their contracts and appeal rights.

Common ED Coding Errors

Professional

• Level 5 billed when documentation supports moderate MDM.

• Documentation that lists tests without documenting review or interpretation.

• Problems documented as high risk without a differential diagnosis or management that reflects that risk.

• Critical care billed without documentation of time or critical illness.

• Modifier 25 appended without a separately identifiable E/M.

• Copy-forward or templated documentation that does not reflect the encounter.

• ED codes billed for services outside the ED, such as in observation or clinics.

Facility

• Facility levels assigned using guidelines that are not followed consistently or not documented.

• Interventions counted without nursing documentation.

• Levels driven by triage acuity alone without supporting interventions.

• ED codes billed with nonemergency revenue codes.

Preventing Downcoding and Overpayment Demands

Document MDM Clearly

The most effective protection against downcoding is documentation that clearly supports the MDM level. Practitioners should document the problems addressed, the differential, the data reviewed and interpreted, the risk of management decisions, and the rationale for disposition. A brief MDM summary at the end of the note can help reviewers.

Maintain Defensible Facility Guidelines

Hospitals should maintain written facility leveling guidelines that meet CMS principles, apply them consistently, train nursing staff, and audit compliance. Guidelines should be reviewed periodically and updated when services change.

Monitor Coding Patterns

• Track the distribution of ED levels by practitioner and site.

• Compare with peer benchmarks.

• Investigate unusual patterns.

Audit Regularly

• Audit a sample of ED encounters for each practitioner at least annually and more often for outliers.

• Audit facility levels against internal guidelines.

• Audit critical care and modifier 25 use.

• Check site-of-service and revenue coding.

Educate

• Provide feedback to practitioners based on audits.

• Train on the 2023 MDM framework and common pitfalls.

• Train nurses on facility documentation.

Review Payer Contracts and Policies

• Review payer ED leveling policies and their effective dates.

• Understand the data the payer uses and the appeal process.

• Negotiate contract terms that require medical record review before adjustments when possible.

Responding to Audits and Downcoding

Medicare Audits

• Calendar the deadline, generally 45 days for MAC additional documentation requests.

• Submit the complete ED record, including triage, nursing notes, physician notes, orders, results, and disposition.

• Include a cover letter summarizing the MDM elements or facility interventions that support the level.

• Appeal denials under 42 CFR Part 405, Subpart I, submitting all evidence by the reconsideration level.

• For postpayment overpayments, file redetermination within 30 days and reconsideration within 60 days to limit recoupment under 42 CFR 405.379.

Payer Downcoding

• Review the payer's explanation and the policy relied on.

• Request medical record review if the adjustment was based on claim data alone.

• Submit documentation showing that the billed level is supported.

• Use the contract dispute process and, where applicable, state external review or prompt pay protections.

• Track adjustments and outcomes to identify inappropriate patterns.

Overpayment Obligations

When an internal audit finds overpayments, evaluate the obligation to report and return them under the 60-day rule at 42 CFR 401.305. Correct claims and refund overpayments as required.

Building an ED Coding Compliance Program

• Assign a compliance lead for ED coding.

• Maintain written professional and facility coding policies.

• Use certified coders or trained auditors.

• Audit regularly and track results.

• Educate practitioners and nurses.

• Monitor payer policies and contracts.

• Integrate site-of-service checks into billing edits.

A Hypothetical Example

An emergency medicine group receives a Medicare Advantage plan notice that a large share of its level 5 claims will be downcoded based on diagnosis codes. An internal audit finds that most level 5 visits are supported, but documentation often omits interpretation of test results and the differential diagnosis. The group adds an MDM summary section to its template, trains physicians, and appeals downcoded claims with records. It also finds a small number of level 5 claims that should have been level 4, corrects them, and refunds the difference. Over the next year, its appeal success rate improves and downcoding declines.

MDM Documentation Examples

The difference between levels often lies in how clearly the clinician documents reasoning. Consider chest pain. A note that lists a normal electrocardiogram and troponin and states "chest pain, discharged" may support only a lower level. A note that documents the differential diagnosis including acute coronary syndrome, pulmonary embolism, and aortic dissection, describes the clinician's independent interpretation of the electrocardiogram, reviews prior records, documents risk stratification, and explains the decision regarding hospitalization or discharge with follow-up better reflects high-complexity decision making when the clinical situation warrants it.

Similarly, for abdominal pain, documenting the conditions considered, the imaging ordered and reviewed, the discussion with a surgeon, and the decision about admission shows the problems, data, and risk elements that drive the level.

Documentation should never exaggerate. Reviewers compare the documented differential and management with the presentation, and inflated documentation creates its own compliance risk.

The Role of Coders and Clinical Documentation Specialists

Professional and facility coders play a central role. Coders should be trained on the 2023 MDM framework and the hospital's facility guidelines. When documentation is unclear, coders should query clinicians using compliant, non-leading queries. Some organizations use clinical documentation specialists in the ED to provide real-time feedback. Coding software that suggests levels can help, but humans should validate suggested levels, especially for level 5 and critical care.

Common Myths About ED Coding

Myth: Time Spent With the Patient Determines the Level

ED E/M levels are selected based on MDM. Time applies to critical care, not ED visit levels.

Myth: Ordering Many Tests Automatically Supports a High Level

Data is one element. The problems addressed and the risk of management also matter.

Myth: Facility Levels Must Match Professional Levels

Facility and professional levels are determined under different rules and may differ.

Myth: Payer Downcoding Must Be Accepted

Providers may have appeal and dispute rights under payer contracts and policies.

Questions Leadership Should Ask

• What is our level distribution by practitioner, and how does it compare with peers?

• Are our facility guidelines written, consistently applied, and audited?

• Do we audit critical care and modifier 25?

• Are ED codes billed only for ED services with ED revenue codes?

• What share of our claims are downcoded by payers, and what is our appeal success rate?

• Do practitioners receive regular feedback?

Key Takeaways

• Professional ED levels are based on MDM under the 2023 framework.

• Facility levels depend on hospital guidelines that meet CMS principles.

• OIG found over $15 million in improper and potentially improper payments tied to ED codes billed with nonemergency sites of service.

• Payers increasingly downcode level 4 and 5 claims based on claim data.

• Clear documentation, defensible guidelines, regular audits, and appeals reduce risk.

Observation and Admission Decisions in the ED

Many ED visits end with a decision about observation or inpatient admission. Documentation of that decision supports both the E/M level, since decisions regarding hospitalization are part of the risk element, and the hospital's patient status determination. Clinicians should document why observation or admission is needed, or why the patient can be safely discharged. When patients are placed in observation, hospitals must follow observation billing and notice requirements, and ED services should be billed with the correct codes and revenue centers.

Telehealth and ED Services

Some health systems use telehealth to support emergency departments, such as remote emergency physicians or specialist consults in rural EDs. Billing rules for telehealth ED services differ from in-person services and have changed over time. Organizations should confirm which codes, modifiers, and place of service codes apply for each date of service, and should audit these claims separately, since site-of-service errors are a focus of OIG's 2026 report.

Measuring Success

A strong ED coding program tracks:

• Level distribution trends over time.

• Internal audit accuracy rates.

• Payer downcoding rates and appeal outcomes.

• Medicare review findings.

• Turnaround time for queries and corrections.

These measures show whether education and documentation improvements are working.

Physician and Hospital Coordination

Professional and facility claims for the same ED visit are reviewed separately, but they draw on the same medical record. When documentation is weak, both claims may be at risk. Emergency physician groups and hospitals should share audit findings, coordinate education, and align documentation templates so that physician notes support professional MDM and nursing documentation supports facility interventions. Joint compliance meetings help identify issues such as site-of-service coding errors that affect both claims.

Responding to High-Coder Designations

Some payers identify providers whose coding patterns exceed thresholds and subject them to prepayment review. When designated, providers should request the data used, review a sample of their own claims, appeal inaccurate designations, and implement corrective actions. Demonstrating accurate coding through internal audits can help providers exit these programs.

Preparing Clinicians for Audit Season

Brief, regular education sessions before payer audit cycles and after policy changes help clinicians stay current. Sessions should use real examples, review common errors, and explain how auditors read notes. Short tip sheets attached to the documentation template can remind clinicians of key MDM elements during busy shifts.

Documentation Integrity

Templates and macros can improve completeness, but they also create risk when they insert findings or statements that were not part of the encounter. Organizations should review templates periodically, limit default normal findings, and remind clinicians to edit carried-forward content. Auditors watch for identical language across many notes, which can undermine otherwise valid claims.

Self-Audits and Corrections

When an internal audit finds coding errors, correct claims within payer timelines and refund overpayments as required. Document the review, the errors found, and the corrective actions taken, since this record demonstrates an effective compliance program.

Repeated errors by the same clinician should trigger focused education and follow-up audits.

Frequently Asked Questions

How are ED professional E/M levels selected?

Based on medical decision making under the 2023 CPT framework. Time is not used to select ED visit levels.

How are facility ED levels selected?

Using the hospital's own internal guidelines, which must meet principles established by CMS.

What did OIG report in March 2026?

That Medicare improperly paid physicians $922,524 and made $14.2 million in potentially improper payments to hospitals for ED procedure codes billed with nonemergency sites of service in 2021 and 2022.

Can payers downcode ED claims?

Many payers have policies to review or adjust level 4 and level 5 claims. Rights depend on the payer contract, policy, and state law.

What is the best defense against downcoding?

Clear documentation of MDM for professional claims and consistent, documented facility guidelines for hospital claims.

Conclusion

ED E/M coding faces scrutiny from OIG, Medicare contractors, and payers. Practitioners who document MDM clearly, hospitals that apply defensible facility guidelines, and organizations that audit regularly, monitor payer policies, and appeal inappropriate adjustments will reduce downcoding and overpayment demands.

How HealthBridge Can Help

HealthBridge is a healthcare management consulting firm that helps emergency physician groups and hospitals audit ED professional and facility coding, design documentation templates, review facility leveling guidelines, train practitioners and nurses, respond to audits, and appeal downcoding. If ED coding audits are a concern, please get in touch with us. We will be happy to help you with this topic.

References

• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General. Emergency Department Procedure Codes Used on Medicare Claims for Services Billed With Nonemergency Department Sites of Service Resulted in Over $15 Million in Improper and Potentially Improper Payments (A-07-23-05139). https://oig.hhs.gov/reports/all/2026/emergency-department-procedure-codes-used-on-medicare-claims-for-services-billed-with-nonemergency-department-sites-of-service-resulted-in-over-15-million-in-improper-and-potentially-improper-payments

• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General. Work Plan: Audit of Medicare Emergency Department Evaluation and Management Services. https://oig.hhs.gov/reports-and-publications/workplan/summary/wp-summary-0000612.asp

• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General. Coding Trends of Medicare Evaluation and Management Services (OEI-04-10-00180). https://oig.hhs.gov/oei/reports/oei-04-10-00180.pdf

• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Medicare Claims Processing Manual, Chapter 12, Physicians/Nonphysician Practitioners. https://www.cms.gov/Regulations-and-Guidance/Guidance/Manuals/downloads/clm104c12.pdf

• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Medicare Claims Processing Manual, Chapter 4, Part B Hospital (Including Inpatient Hospital Part B and OPPS). https://www.cms.gov/Regulations-and-Guidance/Guidance/Manuals/downloads/clm104c04.pdf

• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Evaluation and Management Services Guide (Medicare Learning Network). https://www.cms.gov/outreach-and-education/medicare-learning-network-mln/mlnproducts/downloads/eval-mgmt-serv-guide-icn006764.pdf

• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Hospital Outpatient Prospective Payment System. https://www.cms.gov/medicare/payment/prospective-payment-systems/hospital-outpatient

• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR Part 405, Subpart I, Determinations, Redeterminations, Reconsiderations, and Appeals Under Original Medicare. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-405/subpart-I

• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 405.379, Limitation on Recoupment of Provider and Supplier Overpayments. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-405/subpart-C/section-405.379

• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 401.305, Requirements for Reporting and Returning of Overpayments. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-A/part-401/subpart-D/section-401.305

Some or all of the services described herein may not be permissible for HealthBridge US clients and their affiliates or related entities.

The information provided is general in nature and is not intended to address the specific circumstances of any individual or entity. While we strive to offer accurate and timely information, we cannot guarantee that such information remains accurate after it is received or that it will continue to be accurate over time. Anyone seeking to act on such information should first seek professional advice tailored to their specific situation. HealthBridge US does not offer legal services.

HealthBridge US is not affiliated with any department of public health agencies in any state, nor with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). We offer healthcare consulting services exclusively and are an independent consulting firm not affiliated with any regulatory organizations, including but not limited to the Accrediting Organizations, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), and state departments. HealthBridge is an anti-fraud company in full compliance with all applicable federal and state regulations for CMS, as well as other relevant business and healthcare laws. The badges, icons, and achievement graphics displayed on this website represent proprietary performance metrics, volume milestones, and internal corporate recognition issued exclusively by our corporate affiliate network at SummitRidge. These visual markers are utilized solely as historical indicators of enterprise growth, operational longevity, and volume-based milestones cleared within our shared corporate ecosystem.

© 2026 HealthBridge US, a California corporation. All rights reserved.

For more information about the structure of HealthBridge, visit www.myhbconsulting.com/governance

Legal

Resources