ESRD Monthly Capitation Payment Audits: Physician Visit Documentation Requirements
A guide to ESRD monthly capitation payment audits for nephrologists: CPT 90951 through 90970, visit counting, the monthly vascular access examination, home dialysis rules and telehealth, partial months, one MCP per patient, OIG findings of $8.8 million in improper MCPs and duplicate billing, and documentation best practices.
KNOWLEDGE CENTER
11/15/202612 min read
Physicians and qualified nonphysician practitioners who manage patients with end-stage renal disease (ESRD) are paid a monthly capitation payment (MCP) for ESRD-related services. The MCP amount depends on the patient's age, whether the patient dialyzes in a center or at home, and, for center-based patients, the number of face-to-face visits during the month. Because the highest payments require four or more visits, visit documentation is central to MCP audits.
OIG has found significant MCP errors. In a June 2023 audit of Noridian's Jurisdiction E, OIG estimated about $8.8 million in improper MCPs for patients 20 and older with four or more visits, an improper payment rate of 21 percent. In a May 2021 audit, OIG found about $4 million in overpayments for claims in which more than one physician billed an MCP for the same patient in the same month, and $291,813 where the same physician billed more than once.
This article explains MCP billing rules, OIG's findings, documentation requirements, and how practices can prepare for audits. It is educational and does not replace legal or professional advice.
MCP Codes and Rules
Center-Based Patients
For patients who dialyze in a facility, CPT codes 90951 through 90962 are billed once per month based on age and number of face-to-face visits. For patients 20 years of age and older:
• 90960: four or more face-to-face visits per month.
• 90961: two to three face-to-face visits per month.
• 90962: one face-to-face visit per month.
Codes for younger age groups follow similar visit tiers. The payment amount is lowest for one visit, higher for two to three visits, and highest for four or more visits.
Home Dialysis Patients
For patients who dialyze at home, CPT codes 90963 through 90966 are billed once per month based on age. Medicare requires a complete monthly assessment of the patient. Statute and CMS guidance allow home dialysis patients to receive monthly ESRD-related clinical assessments via telehealth, subject to requirements for periodic face-to-face visits, including during the first months of home dialysis. OIG has noted that physicians must furnish at least one face-to-face visit per month for the home dialysis MCP, with contractors able to waive the requirement on a case-by-case basis, so practices should confirm current requirements for each date of service.
Partial Months
When a patient receives ESRD-related services for less than a full month, such as when the patient is hospitalized, dies, transfers, or receives a transplant, practitioners may bill per-day codes 90967 through 90970 in certain circumstances, as described in the Medicare Claims Processing Manual.
Key Billing Rules
Medicare contractor guidance summarizes the core MCP billing rules:
• Only one monthly payment is made for any ESRD patient per month.
• The MCP is billed after the month has passed, not in advance, with the last day of the month reported as the date of service.
• Payment for center-based patients is based on the beneficiary's age and the number of visits furnished during the month.
• Duplicate MCPs, or separate charges for services covered by the MCP, are denied.
• When several physicians or practitioners form a team, only one monthly payment is made for each patient.
• Payment is made at 80 percent of the approved amount after the Part B deductible.
Who Can Furnish Visits
The billing physician or practitioner may use other physicians or qualified nonphysician practitioners, such as nurse practitioners, physician assistants, and clinical nurse specialists, to furnish some visits during the month, subject to Medicare rules. The billing practitioner must furnish at least one visit and the complete monthly assessment, according to CMS guidance.
The Vascular Access Examination
At least one visit each month must include a clinical examination of the vascular access site by a physician, clinical nurse specialist, nurse practitioner, or physician assistant.
Telehealth
ESRD-related services are on the Medicare Telehealth Services List, but CMS has required that at least one visit per month be furnished in person to examine the vascular access site for center-based patients. Practices should confirm current telehealth rules, including flexibilities extended by Congress.
OIG's Findings
Noridian Jurisdiction E Audit
OIG's June 2023 audit (A-09-21-03016) covered $46.7 million in Medicare Part B payments for certain ESRD-related services, grouped into 189,683 enrollee-months for patients 20 and older with four or more visits. OIG found that Noridian made improper MCPs of $4,663 for 26 sampled enrollee-months, with enrollees responsible for $1,162 in coinsurance. OIG estimated that Noridian made about $8.8 million in improper MCPs during the audit period, an improper payment rate of 21 percent, and that enrollees may have paid up to $2.2 million in related cost sharing. OIG attributed the errors to insufficient oversight to ensure practitioners met Medicare billing requirements, and recommended that Noridian recover the sampled overpayments and use its Targeted Probe and Educate program and education to address the issue.
Duplicate MCP Audit
OIG's May 2021 audit (A-07-19-05117) reviewed $12.2 million in MCPs for 53,608 at-risk claims for 2016 through 2018. OIG found that 23,695 claims reported monthly ESRD codes more than once for the same beneficiary in the same month, including 21,763 claims billed by different physicians, with about $4 million in overpayments, and 1,932 claims billed by the same physician, with $291,813 in overpayments. Beneficiaries may have paid up to $1.1 million in related cost sharing. OIG concluded that CMS did not have adequate claims processing controls and recommended system edits, which CMS implemented.
Medical Review Findings
Medicare contractors' medical reviews and the Comprehensive Error Rate Testing program have found MCP claims with insufficient documentation of face-to-face visits, claims billed at the four-or-more-visit level when documentation supported fewer visits, and claims missing documentation of the vascular access examination.
Documentation Requirements
Each Visit
Each face-to-face visit should be documented with:
• The date of the visit.
• The name and credentials of the practitioner who furnished the visit.
• The patient's location, such as the dialysis unit.
• A note describing the encounter, such as the patient's status, issues addressed, and plan.
• Signature of the practitioner.
The Monthly Assessment
The monthly complete assessment should address the patient's dialysis adequacy, fluid status, laboratory results, medications, anemia and mineral bone disease management, vascular access, nutritional and psychosocial issues, and coordination with the dialysis facility's plan of care.
Vascular Access
At least one note each month should document a clinical examination of the vascular access site.
Visit Counting
The number of visits documented must support the CPT code billed. Rounding brief walk-bys, chart reviews, or conversations with staff up to visits does not meet the face-to-face requirement.
Home Dialysis
For home patients, documentation should show the monthly assessment, the modality of each visit (in person or telehealth), and compliance with face-to-face requirements.
Common Audit Findings
• Four or more visits billed when fewer were documented.
• Visits documented without dates or practitioner identification.
• Brief notes that do not describe a face-to-face encounter.
• Missing vascular access examination.
• MCP billed before the end of the month.
• More than one practitioner billing an MCP for the same patient and month.
• Separate E/M services billed for ESRD-related care covered by the MCP.
• Partial month codes billed incorrectly.
• Home MCP billed without monthly assessment documentation.
Coordination With Dialysis Facilities
Nephrology practices and dialysis facilities share documentation responsibilities. OIG's dialysis facility audits cited missing monthly physician progress notes in facility records. Practices should ensure that visit notes are available to the facility and that the facility's plan of care reflects physician input. Some practices document directly in the facility's electronic record, while others send notes through interfaces.
Avoiding Duplicate Billing
Duplicate MCPs often occur when patients transfer between practices, when coverage physicians bill separately, or when practices fail to coordinate within groups. Practices should:
• Designate one billing practitioner for each patient each month.
• Communicate with other practices when patients transfer.
• Use partial month codes correctly when appropriate.
• Review remittances for denials indicating duplicates.
Building an MCP Compliance Program
• Use a monthly visit log for each patient that records dates, practitioners, and vascular access exams.
• Reconcile the log with notes before billing.
• Bill only after the month ends.
• Audit a sample of MCP claims quarterly for visit counts, documentation, and vascular access exams.
• Train practitioners on documentation and visit counting.
• Monitor the distribution of 90960, 90961, and 90962 claims.
• Return overpayments within 60 days under 42 CFR 401.305.
Responding to an MCP Audit
• Calendar deadlines, generally 45 days for MAC requests and 30 days for UPIC requests.
• Gather all visit notes for each sampled month, with dates, practitioners, and signatures.
• Prepare a visit summary for each month showing dates and the vascular access exam.
• Include a cover letter explaining how documentation supports the code billed.
• If documentation supports a lower tier, argue for adjustment rather than full denial.
• Appeal unfavorable determinations under 42 CFR Part 405, Subpart I, submitting all evidence by the reconsideration level and filing within the deadlines that limit recoupment under 42 CFR 405.379.
A Hypothetical Example
A nephrology group receives a TPE review of 90960 claims. Several months are found to have only three documented visits, and some notes lack the practitioner's signature. The group implements a monthly visit log reconciled before billing, requires electronic signatures on all notes, trains practitioners to document the vascular access exam explicitly, and refunds overpayments for months with insufficient visits. In the next TPE round, nearly all claims are supported.
MCP and Other E/M Services
The MCP covers most ESRD-related physician services during the month. Practitioners generally should not bill separate E/M services for ESRD-related care covered by the MCP. However, services unrelated to ESRD, or certain services such as hospital visits during an inpatient stay, may be billed separately according to Medicare rules. When a patient is hospitalized, the practitioner may need to bill per-day codes for the days the patient was outside the hospital, depending on the circumstances. Practices should review the Medicare Claims Processing Manual's instructions on which services are included in the MCP and which may be billed separately, and document the reason for any separate service.
Using Nonphysician Practitioners
Many nephrology practices use nurse practitioners and physician assistants to furnish some monthly visits. Their visits can count toward the visit total when they meet Medicare requirements, including state scope of practice and supervision rules. Documentation should clearly identify who performed each visit. Practices should also ensure that the billing practitioner's own involvement, including the complete monthly assessment, is documented.
Documentation Templates
A well-designed MCP template helps practitioners capture required elements. Useful features include:
• A header with the patient, month, and dialysis unit.
• A visit log listing the date, practitioner, and setting of each visit.
• A checkbox and narrative field for the vascular access examination.
• Sections for dialysis adequacy, fluid status, labs, anemia, mineral bone disease, medications, nutrition, psychosocial issues, and plan.
• A signature and date field for each visit and for the monthly assessment.
Templates should prompt for patient-specific information rather than default text, since cloned notes undermine credibility in audits.
Rounding Logistics
Many nephrologists round on patients during dialysis sessions. Visits during rounds count as face-to-face visits when the practitioner sees the patient, evaluates the patient's condition, and documents the encounter. Brief greetings, chart reviews without seeing the patient, or discussions with dialysis staff alone do not count. Practices should schedule rounds so that the planned number of visits is achievable and documented, and should not bill the four-or-more tier unless four visits actually occurred.
Common Myths About MCP Billing
Myth: Seeing the Patient on Rounds Automatically Counts as a Visit
The visit must be a face-to-face encounter that is documented.
Myth: The MCP Can Be Billed at the Start of the Month
The MCP is billed after the month ends.
Myth: Coverage Physicians Can Bill Their Own MCP
Only one MCP is paid per patient per month, so coverage arrangements must be coordinated.
Myth: Telehealth Visits Count Without Limits
At least one visit per month for center-based patients must be in person to examine the vascular access, and home dialysis patients have specific face-to-face requirements.
Questions Leadership Should Ask
• Do we keep a monthly visit log for every MCP patient?
• Is the vascular access exam documented every month?
• How often do we bill 90960 compared with 90961 and 90962, and is it supported?
• How do we prevent duplicate MCPs when patients transfer?
• Are visit notes available to the dialysis facility?
• When did we last audit MCP claims?
Key Takeaways
• MCP codes depend on age, setting, and, for center-based patients, the number of face-to-face visits.
• At least one monthly visit must include a vascular access examination.
• Only one MCP is paid per patient per month, billed after the month ends.
• OIG found a 21 percent improper payment rate in Jurisdiction E and millions in duplicate MCPs nationally.
• Visit logs, templates, and regular audits reduce risk.
Home Dialysis MCP Documentation
Home dialysis MCPs require a complete monthly assessment rather than a specific number of visits. Documentation should include a review of the patient's home treatment records, laboratory results, fluid status, medications, access or catheter care, and any problems reported, along with the plan for the coming month. When visits are conducted via telehealth, the note should document the modality and the patient's location. Practices should track compliance with face-to-face visit requirements for home patients, particularly during the initial months on home dialysis, and document any contractor waivers.
Coordinating With Dialysis Facility Records
Dialysis facilities rely on physician notes to meet their own documentation requirements, and OIG has cited facilities for missing monthly physician progress notes. Practices and facilities should agree on how notes will be shared, such as through direct documentation in the facility record or through electronic interfaces, and should audit periodically to confirm that notes reach the facility record.
Learning From Contractor Education
MACs publish education on MCP billing and documentation, often based on medical review findings. These materials frequently highlight claims billed at the four-or-more tier with only three documented visits, notes without signatures, and missing vascular access documentation. Reviewing this education with practitioners, along with the practice's own audit results, helps prevent repeat errors.
Billing Staff Responsibilities
Billing staff should verify that the visit log supports the code before submitting each MCP claim, confirm that the month has ended, check for other MCP claims for the patient, and apply partial month codes correctly. Billing systems can include edits that hold MCP claims until visit counts are confirmed. Clear communication between practitioners and billing staff prevents most errors.
Measuring MCP Compliance
Track the distribution of MCP codes by practitioner, the percentage of months with documented vascular access exams, the number of duplicate MCP denials, and internal audit accuracy rates. Report results to practice leadership quarterly. Unusual patterns, such as nearly every patient billed at 90960, should prompt review to confirm that visits are documented. Consistent tracking also helps practices respond quickly when contractors request records.
Coverage Arrangements
When a practice uses coverage physicians from another group during vacations or other absences, the arrangement should specify that the regular practice continues to bill the MCP and that the covering physician's visits are documented and shared. Medicare's reciprocal billing and fee-for-time compensation arrangements have specific rules, so practices should confirm how they apply to MCP services.
Hospitalized Patients and Transfers
When an ESRD patient is hospitalized during the month, MCP billing depends on how long the patient was outside the hospital and whether the practitioner furnished the complete monthly assessment. In some cases, practitioners bill per-day codes for the days the patient was not hospitalized, and bill hospital visits separately. When patients transfer between practices mid-month, the practices should coordinate so that only one practitioner bills for the month or per-day codes are used appropriately. Document the dates of hospitalization and transfer in the record.
Practices should keep these records organized by patient and month.
Clear records simplify later audits.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many visits are needed for 90960?
Four or more face-to-face visits in the month for patients 20 and older dialyzing in a center.
Can more than one practitioner bill an MCP for the same patient?
No. Only one MCP is paid per patient per month.
When should the MCP be billed?
After the month ends, using the last day of the month as the date of service.
Is a vascular access exam required?
Yes. At least one visit each month must include a clinical examination of the vascular access site.
What did OIG find in Jurisdiction E?
An estimated $8.8 million in improper MCPs, a 21 percent improper payment rate, for patients with four or more visits.
Conclusion
MCP audits test whether visit documentation supports the code billed. Practices that log every visit, document face-to-face encounters and vascular access exams clearly, bill after the month ends, avoid duplicate billing, and audit regularly will be well prepared for OIG and contractor review.
How HealthBridge Can Help
HealthBridge is a healthcare management consulting firm that helps nephrology practices audit MCP claims, build visit tracking systems, train practitioners on documentation, coordinate with dialysis facilities, and respond to audits. If your practice bills ESRD monthly capitation payments, please get in touch with us. We will be happy to help you with this topic.
References
• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General. Noridian Healthcare Solutions, LLC, Made $8.8 Million in Improper Monthly Capitation Payments to Physicians and Qualified Nonphysician Practitioners in Jurisdiction E for Certain Services Related to End-Stage Renal Disease (A-09-21-03016). https://oig.hhs.gov/oas/reports/region9/92103016.asp
• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General. Medicare Made Millions of Dollars in Overpayments for End-Stage Renal Disease Monthly Capitation Payments (A-07-19-05117). https://oig.hhs.gov/oas/reports/region7/71905117.asp
• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General. Work Plan: Review of Monthly ESRD-Related Visits Billed by Physicians or Other Qualified Healthcare Professionals. https://oig.hhs.gov/reports-and-publications/workplan/summary/wp-summary-0000369.asp
• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Medicare Claims Processing Manual, Chapter 8, Outpatient ESRD Hospital, Independent Facility, and Physician/Supplier Claims. https://www.cms.gov/Regulations-and-Guidance/Guidance/Manuals/downloads/clm104c08.pdf
• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Medicare Benefit Policy Manual, Chapter 11, End Stage Renal Disease. https://www.cms.gov/Regulations-and-Guidance/Guidance/Manuals/downloads/bp102c11.pdf
• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Medicare Telehealth Services List. https://www.cms.gov/medicare/coverage/telehealth/list-services
• U.S. Social Security Administration. Social Security Act, Section 1881, Medicare Coverage for End Stage Renal Disease Patients. https://www.ssa.gov/OP_Home/ssact/title18/1881.htm
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 414.314, Monthly Capitation Payment Method. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-414/subpart-D/section-414.314
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR Part 405, Subpart I, Determinations, Redeterminations, Reconsiderations, and Appeals Under Original Medicare. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-405/subpart-I
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 405.379, Limitation on Recoupment of Provider and Supplier Overpayments. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-405/subpart-C/section-405.379
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 401.305, Requirements for Reporting and Returning of Overpayments. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-A/part-401/subpart-D/section-401.305

Some or all of the services described herein may not be permissible for HealthBridge US clients and their affiliates or related entities.
The information provided is general in nature and is not intended to address the specific circumstances of any individual or entity. While we strive to offer accurate and timely information, we cannot guarantee that such information remains accurate after it is received or that it will continue to be accurate over time. Anyone seeking to act on such information should first seek professional advice tailored to their specific situation. HealthBridge US does not offer legal services.
HealthBridge US is not affiliated with any department of public health agencies in any state, nor with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). We offer healthcare consulting services exclusively and are an independent consulting firm not affiliated with any regulatory organizations, including but not limited to the Accrediting Organizations, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), and state departments. HealthBridge is an anti-fraud company in full compliance with all applicable federal and state regulations for CMS, as well as other relevant business and healthcare laws. The badges, icons, and achievement graphics displayed on this website represent proprietary performance metrics, volume milestones, and internal corporate recognition issued exclusively by our corporate affiliate network at SummitRidge. These visual markers are utilized solely as historical indicators of enterprise growth, operational longevity, and volume-based milestones cleared within our shared corporate ecosystem.
© 2026 HealthBridge US, a California corporation. All rights reserved.
For more information about the structure of HealthBridge, visit www.myhbconsulting.com/governance
