Florida Medicaid AHCA Audit: Preparing for Agency for Health Care Administration Review and Recoupment
How Florida's AHCA Office of Medicaid Program Integrity audits providers under section 409.913, including records rules, sampling, payment withholding, sanctions, hearings, and practical preparation steps.
KNOWLEDGE CENTER
11/15/202611 min read
Florida's Medicaid program serves millions of residents, most through Statewide Medicaid Managed Care, with a smaller fee-for-service component. The Agency for Health Care Administration (AHCA) administers the program, and its Office of Medicaid Program Integrity (MPI) audits and investigates providers suspected of overbilling or defrauding Florida Medicaid, recovers overpayments, issues administrative sanctions, and refers cases of suspected fraud for criminal investigation.
The legal framework for Florida Medicaid program integrity is concentrated in a single, detailed statute: section 409.913, Florida Statutes. It sets records requirements, authorizes statistical sampling and extrapolation, governs payment withholding and prepayment review, defines sanctions, and imposes significant limits on the evidence providers may present to contest an overpayment. AHCA's administrative sanctions rule, Rule 59G-9.070 of the Florida Administrative Code, implements the sanctions provisions.
Florida's rules are demanding. Overpayment determinations must be based only on information available before the audit report is issued, and providers generally may not present records to contest an overpayment unless the records are contemporaneous and, if requested during the audit, were provided to the agency. Sanctions can apply even when a provider repays after a preliminary report. Preparation before an audit matters more in Florida than almost anywhere else.
This article explains how AHCA audits work, what section 409.913 requires, the sanctions and recoupment tools AHCA uses, and how providers can prepare and respond. It is educational and not legal advice. Providers facing AHCA audits, sanctions, or fraud referrals should consult experienced Florida healthcare counsel.
The Statutory Framework: Section 409.913
The Program Integrity Mandate
Section 409.913 directs AHCA to operate a program to oversee the activities of Florida Medicaid recipients, providers, and their representatives to ensure that fraudulent and abusive behavior and neglect of recipients occur to the minimum extent possible, and to recover overpayments and impose sanctions as appropriate.
Provider Duties
The statute imposes an affirmative duty on providers to present claims that are true and accurate and that are for goods and services that have actually been furnished to the recipient and are medically necessary.
Records Retention and Access
Under section 409.913(9), providers must keep Medicaid-related medical, professional, financial, and business records for five years after furnishing the service or goods. AHCA may review records during normal business hours, with 24-hour notice if patient treatment would be disrupted. Providers must tell the agency where records are kept, and agency access is not limited during litigation. Refusing or failing to provide records, or failing to keep records made at the time of service, are grounds for sanctions.
Notice to the Address on File
Under section 409.913(6), notice is presumed sufficient if sent to the address on the provider's enrollment file, and U.S. Postal Service proof of mailing, or certified or registered mail, is sufficient proof. Providers must keep their address current. Many Florida providers have lost rights because notices went to outdated addresses.
How AHCA Selects and Conducts Audits
Random and Targeted Audits
Under section 409.913(2), at least 5 percent of audits must be random. AHCA monitors overutilization and billing patterns and uses data analytics to select targeted audits.
Prepayment Review
Under section 409.913(3), AHCA may place a provider on prepayment review for up to one year without suspicion of fraud. Claims are adjudicated within 90 days of receipt of complete documentation, or within 180 days if there is reliable evidence of fraud, misrepresentation, abuse, or neglect. Prepayment review can severely affect cash flow, so providers should submit complete documentation with each claim.
Statistical Methods
Under section 409.913(20), overpayment determinations must use accepted auditing, accounting, analytical, statistical, or peer-review methods, which may include sampling and extension to the population. AHCA may introduce statistical results as evidence of overpayment. Peer-review findings are admissible as evidence of medical necessity.
Audit Reports
Under section 409.913(21), AHCA issues an audit report showing the overpayment calculation. The determination must rest only on information available before the report was issued and, for documentation, on contemporaneous records. Addenda to notes may be considered if they are germane to the note. In practice, AHCA has used a preliminary audit report followed by a final audit report, and AHCA's sanctions rule provides that satisfaction of an overpayment following a preliminary audit report will not avoid sanctions at the final audit report unless AHCA offers amnesty.
The Audit Report as Evidence
Under section 409.913(22), the audit report and supporting work papers are evidence of the overpayment.
Evidence Limits: Why Preparation Is Everything
Section 409.913(22) sharply limits what providers can use to contest an overpayment. A provider may not present records to contest an overpayment unless the records are contemporaneous and, if requested during the audit, were provided to the agency. Testimony about purchases, sales, or inventory of drugs, goods, or supplies must be supported by written invoices, inventory records, or other documentary evidence. All evidence must be exchanged at least 14 days before the hearing or it may be excluded. Addenda or modifications to notes may be considered only if made before notification of the audit, germane to the note, and the note itself was contemporaneous.
The practical consequences are significant:
• Documents not produced during the audit generally cannot be used later.
• Records created after the fact will not help and may hurt.
• Providers must respond to every record request completely and on time.
• Providers should keep a log of everything produced.
Payment Withholding
Reliable Evidence of Fraud
Under section 409.913(25)(a), AHCA may withhold payments upon reliable evidence of fraud, willful misrepresentation, abuse, or a crime. If no violation is found, withheld payments must be paid within 14 days, with interest at 10 percent per year after that. This authority operates alongside federal rules at 42 CFR 455.23 requiring suspension upon a credible allegation of fraud, unless good cause exists.
Withholding After an Overpayment Determination
Under section 409.913(27), after a probable cause determination of overpayment and notice, AHCA withholds payments unless, within 30 days of notice, the provider repays in full or agrees to a satisfactory repayment plan. Withholding continues during any hearing.
Sanctions
Section 409.913(16) and Rule 59G-9.070 authorize a range of sanctions, including:
• Suspension for up to one year.
• Termination for one to 20 years.
• Fines of up to $5,000 per violation, with each day of an ongoing violation counted separately.
• Fines of up to $10,000 for certain false submissions, including false enrollment, prior authorization, drug exception, or cost report submissions.
• Liens, prepayment review, follow-up reviews every six months, and corrective action plans of up to three years.
Mandatory termination or suspension applies in certain conviction or exclusion situations. AHCA must consider statutory factors when choosing a sanction. Rule 59G-9.070 states that notice of sanctions is by written correspondence and that the final notice is the point of entry for administrative proceedings under Chapter 120, Florida Statutes. AHCA must report sanctions to other state regulators within five business days in certain cases.
Costs, Interest, and Repayment
• Overpayments bear interest at 10 percent per year from the date of final determination, and payment arrangements must be made within 30 days after the final order.
• Under section 409.913(23), AHCA may recover investigative and legal costs, including attorney fees and expert witness costs, if the provider did not contest the findings or the agency prevailed. Costs must be reasonable relative to the seriousness of the violation, and payment may be spread over time if immediate payment would cause extreme hardship.
• Failure to repay or pay a fine within 30 days after a final order, absent a repayment agreement, requires termination, and reimbursement is withheld until the balance is paid if the provider does not pay or comply with a repayment plan.
Administrative Hearings
Providers may challenge final audit determinations and sanctions through administrative proceedings under Chapter 120, Florida Statutes, typically before an administrative law judge at the Division of Administrative Hearings. Under section 409.913(31), hearings must be held within 90 days after an administrative law judge is assigned, absent exceptionally good cause. Venue for program integrity cases may be in Leon County at the agency's discretion. The final notice specifies the deadline to request a hearing, and providers must calendar it immediately and file a petition that complies with Chapter 120 and the agency's rules.
Referral to the Medicaid Fraud Control Unit
Under section 409.913(4), AHCA must refer suspected criminal violations to the Medicaid Fraud Control Unit in the Office of the Attorney General. AHCA and the Attorney General maintain a memorandum of understanding covering information sharing and the return of cases the agency can handle administratively. Complaints and investigative information are confidential until certain events occur, such as final agency action or referral for prosecution.
Managed Care Plans
Most Florida Medicaid members are enrolled in managed care plans, which must maintain program integrity functions, conduct audits, and report suspected fraud. Florida's Office of Program Policy Analysis and Government Accountability has reviewed AHCA's oversight of fraud, waste, and abuse across fee-for-service and managed care and reported on AHCA's efforts to strengthen managed care program integrity. Providers should understand each plan's audit procedures and appeal rights and coordinate their responses with any AHCA review.
Preparing for an AHCA Audit
Keep Contemporaneous, Complete Records
Because only contemporaneous records can be used, documentation must be complete at the time of service. Notes should be signed and dated, and addenda should be clearly labeled and germane.
Keep Your Enrollment Address Current
Notices sent to the enrollment address are presumed sufficient. Update addresses promptly and monitor mail and portals.
Retain Records for at Least Five Years
Maintain medical, financial, and business records for at least five years after service, and know where they are stored.
Build a Record Production Process
Designate a coordinator, track every request, produce complete records by the deadline, and keep a log and copy of everything produced.
Audit Yourself
Conduct internal audits using sampling, identify errors, and correct them before AHCA finds them. Consider whether amnesty or voluntary repayment programs are available when problems are found.
Monitor Your Data
Review utilization and billing patterns compared with peers, because AHCA uses analytics to select audits.
Prepare for Prepayment Review
Develop a process to submit complete documentation with claims quickly if placed on prepayment review.
Screen for Exclusions
Screen owners and staff against federal and Florida exclusion lists.
Responding to an Audit
• Read every letter carefully and calendar deadlines.
• Produce all requested records completely, because unproduced records generally cannot be used later.
• Review preliminary findings claim by claim and respond with contemporaneous documentation.
• Scrutinize sampling and extrapolation and consider expert review.
• Evaluate the risk of sanctions in addition to overpayment.
• Request an administrative hearing within the deadline stated in the final notice if appropriate.
• Exchange evidence at least 14 days before the hearing.
• Engage counsel when fraud is suspected, withholding is imposed, or sanctions are significant.
Common Mistakes
• Letting notices go to an outdated address.
• Failing to produce all requested records during the audit.
• Creating or modifying records after notification of the audit.
• Assuming repayment after a preliminary report avoids sanctions.
• Missing the hearing request deadline.
• Underestimating prepayment review's cash flow impact.
• Overlooking managed care plan audits.
Cost Report and Institutional Provider Reviews
Institutional providers that file Medicaid cost reports face additional risks. Section 409.913 treats including an unallowed cost in a cost report as a potential violation subject to sanctions, and fines of up to $10,000 may apply to certain false cost report submissions. Institutional providers should maintain documentation for all reported costs, follow cost reporting instructions carefully, disclose related-party transactions, and correct errors promptly. When AHCA questions a cost, providers should respond with documentation and preserve their right to contest the issue through administrative proceedings.
Change of Ownership Considerations
Florida law addresses outstanding overpayments when ownership changes. Legislative changes to section 409.913 provided that outstanding overpayments include amounts identified in a preliminary audit report issued to the transferor on or before the effective date of a change of ownership. Buyers of Florida Medicaid providers should conduct diligence on pending audits, preliminary audit reports, and potential overpayments, and should address these risks in transaction documents.
Lessons From Oversight Reviews of AHCA
Independent reviews of AHCA's program integrity work, including reports by Florida's Office of Program Policy Analysis and Government Accountability and the Florida Auditor General, and CMS's focused program integrity reviews of Florida, have examined how AHCA detects fraud and abuse, recovers overpayments, imposes sanctions, and oversees managed care plans. These reviews help providers understand the agency's priorities and the pressures it faces to recover funds and impose sanctions. When oversight bodies recommend stronger enforcement, providers can expect more audits and less flexibility.
Working With Managed Care Plans in Florida
Because most Florida Medicaid members receive services through managed care, providers often face plan audits and recoveries in addition to AHCA reviews. Plans must report suspected fraud and abuse to AHCA, and AHCA may pursue its own review based on plan referrals. Providers should track plan audit requests separately, understand each plan's dispute processes, and make sure records produced to plans are consistent with records produced to AHCA, because inconsistent production can create credibility problems.
Building a Florida-Specific Compliance Calendar
Florida's rules reward providers that track dates carefully. A compliance calendar should include record request deadlines, preliminary and final audit report response dates, hearing request deadlines stated in final notices, the 30-day window to repay or agree to a repayment plan after notice of a probable cause determination, the 14-day evidence exchange deadline before hearings, record retention dates, and enrollment revalidation dates. Assigning a single owner to the calendar reduces the risk of missed deadlines.
Responding to Prepayment Review
Prepayment review can last up to a year and can strain cash flow even when no fraud is suspected. Providers placed on prepayment review should confirm exactly what documentation AHCA requires with each claim, assign staff to assemble complete packets, track each claim's status and the 90-day adjudication period, and analyze denials for patterns. Denials during prepayment review often reveal documentation weaknesses that, once corrected, improve both payment and audit readiness. Providers should also ask whether follow-up reviews or corrective action plans will be required after prepayment review ends.
Voluntary Repayment and Amnesty
When internal audits identify overpayments, Florida providers should consider how to repay. Section 409.913 allows AHCA to create amnesty programs for voluntary repayment under rules it adopts, and AHCA's sanctions rule references amnesty as a way to avoid sanctions following a preliminary audit report. Providers should evaluate available voluntary repayment options with counsel and keep in mind the federal obligation to report and return identified overpayments. Voluntary correction before an audit is generally viewed far more favorably than repayment after AHCA identifies the problem.
Communicating During an Audit
Clear, professional communication with AHCA auditors helps the process. Providers should designate a single contact, confirm requests in writing, ask for clarification when requests are unclear, and document all communications. If records cannot be produced by a deadline, request an extension in writing before the deadline passes. Courteous, organized communication can prevent misunderstandings that later become findings.
Written follow-up after phone calls or meetings creates a record that can be important later in a hearing, where the audit file and work papers are treated as evidence.
Keeping these records organized from the first contact helps counsel build a clear timeline if the matter proceeds to a hearing.
Myths About AHCA Audits
Myth: Missing Records Can Be Provided at Hearing
Records not provided during the audit when requested generally cannot be used to contest an overpayment.
Myth: Paying the Preliminary Amount Ends the Matter
Satisfaction after a preliminary audit report does not avoid sanctions unless AHCA offers amnesty.
Myth: Prepayment Review Means Fraud Is Suspected
AHCA may impose prepayment review for up to one year without suspicion of fraud.
Myth: Costs Are Always Borne by the Agency
AHCA may recover investigative and legal costs when the provider does not contest or the agency prevails.
Questions Leadership Should Ask
• Is our enrollment address current, and who monitors notices?
• Are our records contemporaneous, complete, and retained for five years?
• Can we produce all requested records on time?
• Are we prepared for prepayment review?
• Have we audited ourselves recently using sampling?
• Do we understand the sanctions that could accompany an overpayment?
• Do we have counsel experienced in Florida Medicaid hearings?
Key Takeaways
• AHCA's Office of Medicaid Program Integrity audits providers, recovers overpayments, imposes sanctions, and refers suspected fraud under section 409.913.
• Providers must keep records for five years, keep enrollment addresses current, and produce records on request.
• Overpayments may be determined through sampling and extrapolation, and audit reports and work papers are evidence.
• Providers generally may not use records to contest an overpayment unless they are contemporaneous and were provided when requested.
• Sanctions include suspension, termination, fines, prepayment review, and corrective action plans, and AHCA may recover costs and interest.
How HealthBridge Can Help
HealthBridge helps Florida Medicaid providers prepare for and respond to AHCA audits. Our team can audit your documentation for contemporaneous completeness, build record production processes, conduct sample-based internal audits, analyze billing patterns, and prepare for prepayment review. When an audit arrives, we can help organize production, analyze preliminary findings and extrapolation, prepare responses, and support counsel in administrative proceedings. If your organization wants to strengthen its readiness for AHCA review, please get in touch with us. We will be happy to help you with this topic.
References
• The Florida Senate. 2025 Florida Statutes, Section 409.913, Oversight of the integrity of the Medicaid program. https://www.flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2025/409.913
• Florida Administrative Code. Rule 59G-9.070, Administrative Sanctions on Providers, Entities, and Persons. https://flrules.org/gateway/ruleno.asp?id=59G-9.070
• Florida Department of State. Notice of rule development, Rule 59G-9.070. https://flrules.org/gateway/notice_Files.asp?ID=9066704
• Agency for Health Care Administration. Office of Medicaid Program Integrity. https://ahca.myflorida.com/health-quality-assurance/office-of-medicaid-program-integrity.html
• Office of Program Policy Analysis and Government Accountability. Biennial Review of AHCA's Oversight of Fraud, Waste, and Abuse in Florida's Medicaid Program (Report 22-03). https://oppaga.fl.gov/Documents/Reports/22-03.pdf
• Office of Program Policy Analysis and Government Accountability. AHCA Reorganized to Enhance Managed Care Program Oversight (Report 16-03). https://oppaga.fl.gov/Documents/Reports/16-03.pdf
• Florida Auditor General. Agency for Health Care Administration Medicaid Program Integrity Operational Audit (Report 2018-172). https://www.flauditor.gov/pages/pdf_files/2018-172.pdf
• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Florida Focused Program Integrity Review Final Report (January 2018). https://www.cms.gov/medicare-medicaid-coordination/fraud-prevention/fraudabuseforprofs/downloads/flfy17.pdf
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 455.23, Suspension of payments in cases of fraud. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-C/part-455/subpart-A/section-455.23
• U.S. Code. 42 U.S.C. 1320a-7k(d), Reporting and returning of overpayments. https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid:USC-prelim-title42-section1320a-7k

Some or all of the services described herein may not be permissible for HealthBridge US clients and their affiliates or related entities.
The information provided is general in nature and is not intended to address the specific circumstances of any individual or entity. While we strive to offer accurate and timely information, we cannot guarantee that such information remains accurate after it is received or that it will continue to be accurate over time. Anyone seeking to act on such information should first seek professional advice tailored to their specific situation. HealthBridge US does not offer legal services.
HealthBridge US is not affiliated with any department of public health agencies in any state, nor with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). We offer healthcare consulting services exclusively and are an independent consulting firm not affiliated with any regulatory organizations, including but not limited to the Accrediting Organizations, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), and state departments. HealthBridge is an anti-fraud company in full compliance with all applicable federal and state regulations for CMS, as well as other relevant business and healthcare laws. The badges, icons, and achievement graphics displayed on this website represent proprietary performance metrics, volume milestones, and internal corporate recognition issued exclusively by our corporate affiliate network at SummitRidge. These visual markers are utilized solely as historical indicators of enterprise growth, operational longevity, and volume-based milestones cleared within our shared corporate ecosystem.
© 2026 HealthBridge US, a California corporation. All rights reserved.
For more information about the structure of HealthBridge, visit www.myhbconsulting.com/governance
