Hospital Cost Report Audits and MAC Desk Reviews: What Reviewers Look For in 2026

A 2026 guide to Medicare hospital cost report review: filing and acceptance rules, tentative settlement, desk reviews and audits, the most common adjustment areas (S-10, bad debt, wage index, GME, DSH, related parties), OIG findings on MAC oversight, reopenings, protested items, and PRRB appeals.

KNOWLEDGE CENTER

11/15/202612 min read

Every Medicare-certified hospital must file an annual cost report. The cost report is far more than a compliance filing. It determines final settlement for cost-based payments, supports add-on payments such as graduate medical education and disproportionate share hospital payments, provides data for the wage index and uncompensated care distributions, and feeds national payment rate setting. Errors can shift millions of dollars.

Medicare Administrative Contractors (MACs) review every cost report through a desk review and audit selected cost reports in more depth before final settlement. In 2025, the HHS Office of Inspector General (OIG) issued a series of reports on MAC cost report oversight. One found that each of the 12 MAC jurisdictions failed to meet contract requirements for desk review and audit quality in at least one of the years examined, and others found errors in desk reviews at specific MACs. These reports suggest that MACs, under CMS direction, may scrutinize cost reports more carefully.

This article explains the cost report process, what reviewers look for, the most common adjustment areas, and how hospitals can prepare. It is educational and does not replace legal or professional advice.

The Cost Report Process

Filing

Hospitals file Form CMS-2552-10 electronically. Under 42 CFR 413.24(f)(2), cost reports are generally due on the last day of the fifth month following the close of the cost reporting period. The cost report must be accompanied by required supporting documentation and a certification signed by an officer or administrator attesting to its accuracy.

Acceptability

Under 42 CFR 413.24(f)(5), a cost report may be rejected if it is not acceptable, for example, if required documents are missing, the report does not pass edits, or required supporting documentation, such as a working trial balance or Medicare bad debt listing, is not included. Rejected cost reports must be corrected and resubmitted, and late filing can lead to suspension of interim payments.

Tentative Settlement

After accepting the cost report, the MAC may issue a tentative settlement that adjusts interim payments based on the filed cost report.

Desk Review

The MAC performs a desk review of every cost report to evaluate adequacy, completeness, accuracy, and reasonableness. OIG has described the desk review as not including detailed verification and as designed to identify issues that may warrant an audit. Desk reviews often include requests for specific documentation.

Audit

The MAC may audit cost reports based on risk and CMS priorities. Audits can be limited in scope or comprehensive, and may include on-site or remote fieldwork, testing of statistics and costs, and review of supporting documentation.

Notice of Program Reimbursement

After review, the MAC issues a Notice of Program Reimbursement reflecting final settlement, including adjustments. The notice triggers appeal rights and the reopening period.

What Reviewers Look For

Reconciliation to Financial Statements

Reviewers confirm that costs on the cost report reconcile to the hospital's trial balance and audited financial statements, and that reclassifications and adjustments are supported.

Allowable Costs

Under 42 CFR Part 413 and the Provider Reimbursement Manual, only reasonable costs related to patient care are allowable. Reviewers look for nonallowable costs such as certain advertising, lobbying, fundraising, entertainment, penalties, and costs unrelated to patient care.

Related-Party Costs

Under 42 CFR 413.17, costs for services, facilities, and supplies furnished by related organizations are allowable at the cost to the related organization, not the price charged, with limited exceptions. Reviewers request Worksheet A-8-1 support and related-party financial information.

Statistics

Reviewers test the statistics used to allocate overhead, such as square footage, full-time equivalents, and accumulated costs, against source documents.

Patient Days and Charges

Reviewers compare days and charges with the Provider Statistical and Reimbursement report and internal records.

Common Adjustment Areas in 2026

Worksheet S-10 and Uncompensated Care

CMS uses Worksheet S-10 data on uncompensated care, including charity care and non-Medicare bad debt, to distribute uncompensated care payments to disproportionate share hospitals. MACs audit S-10 data for selected hospitals. Reviewers examine whether charity care was written off under a written financial assistance policy, whether amounts are properly reported, whether patient-level detail supports totals, and whether deductible and coinsurance amounts for insured patients are handled correctly. Hospitals should maintain patient-level listings, the financial assistance policy, and documentation of eligibility determinations.

Medicare Bad Debt

Under 42 CFR 413.89, Medicare bad debts are allowable when they relate to covered services, result from uncollectible deductibles and coinsurance, follow reasonable collection efforts, and are determined to be uncollectible using sound business judgment. CMS clarified requirements in recent rulemaking, including standards for reasonable collection effort and indigence determinations. Reviewers check collection efforts, the 120-day collection period, write-off dates, indigence determinations, and crossover claims for dual-eligible beneficiaries, including state Medicaid remittance advice requirements.

Wage Index Data

Worksheet S-3 wage data feeds the area wage index. MACs conduct wage index desk reviews under CMS instructions, and hospitals have opportunities to review and request corrections during the annual wage index timeline. Reviewers look at salaries, hours, contract labor, fringe benefits, and exclusion of non-IPPS areas.

Graduate Medical Education

Reviewers examine resident full-time equivalent counts, rotations, caps, rolling averages, and agreements with nonhospital sites. Documentation includes rotation schedules, Intern and Resident Information System data, and affiliation agreements.

Disproportionate Share Hospital Data

Reviewers examine Medicaid eligible days, including documentation that patients were eligible for Medicaid on the days claimed, and the treatment of days for patients in Medicaid expansion and demonstration populations, which has been the subject of litigation and rulemaking.

Organ Acquisition

Transplant hospitals report organ acquisition costs, which CMS has scrutinized in recent rulemaking. Reviewers examine cost allocation and organ counts.

Provider-Based Physician and Professional Costs

Reviewers examine time studies, allocation between Part A and Part B, and reasonable compensation equivalents.

OIG's Recent Findings on MAC Oversight

March 2025 Report

In its March 2025 report (A-04-22-06264), OIG found that for fiscal years 2019 through 2021, each of the 12 MAC jurisdictions failed to comply with contract requirements for audit and reimbursement desk review and audit quality for at least one of the three years. CMS identified 287 audit issues across the MAC jurisdictions. OIG attributed the problems to factors such as limited CMS guidance, limited feedback, inadequate training, and staffing and workload issues. CMS generally concurred with OIG's recommendations and had begun addressing some issues.

Desk Review Error Reports

In 2025, OIG issued reports on cost reports that individual MACs settled with a desk review only and later reopened to correct final settlements. For example, OIG found that all 15 such cost reports at Wisconsin Physicians Service contained obvious errors or were inconsistent with Medicare requirements, with corrected settlements totaling $1.2 million in net overpayments, and that all of the associated desk reviews for 118 cost reports reopened by Novitas contained errors. OIG issued a similar report for National Government Services.

What This Means for Hospitals

These reports signal that CMS and MACs are under pressure to improve the quality of desk reviews and audits. Hospitals should expect more detailed documentation requests, more reopenings to correct errors, and closer scrutiny of complex areas.

Reopenings

Under 42 CFR 405.1885, a MAC may reopen a cost report determination within three years of the Notice of Program Reimbursement, and a provider may request reopening within the same period. Reopenings can be initiated to correct errors in either direction. Determinations procured by fraud or similar fault may be reopened at any time. Hospitals should track the reopening window for each cost report and respond carefully to reopening notices.

Protecting Appeal Rights

Protested Items

Under 42 CFR 413.24(j), when a hospital believes an item is allowable but is not allowable under Medicare policy, the hospital must self-disallow the item and report it as a protested amount, with supporting documentation, to preserve appeal rights. Hospitals should identify protested items carefully and document the basis.

Provider Reimbursement Review Board

Under 42 CFR 405.1835 through 405.1837, hospitals may appeal final determinations to the Provider Reimbursement Review Board within 180 days of the Notice of Program Reimbursement. Individual appeals require an amount in controversy of at least $10,000, and group appeals require at least $50,000 in the aggregate. Group appeals are required in some circumstances when commonly owned or controlled providers share an issue. The Board has detailed rules on filing, preliminary position papers, and deadlines, and missing deadlines can lead to dismissal.

Administrator Review and Judicial Review

Board decisions may be reviewed by the CMS Administrator and then by federal district court.

Preparing for Desk Review and Audit

Before Filing

• Reconcile the cost report to the trial balance and audited financial statements.

• Prepare workpapers for each reclassification and adjustment.

• Review statistics and their source documentation.

• Review S-10, bad debt, wage index, GME, and DSH data for completeness and accuracy.

• Compare key metrics with prior years and explain significant changes.

• Identify protested items.

• Have a reviewer other than the preparer review the report.

During Review

• Respond to requests promptly with organized documentation.

• Assign a single coordinator.

• Track requests, responses, and proposed adjustments.

• Use exit conferences to resolve disagreements.

After Settlement

• Review the Notice of Program Reimbursement and adjustment report.

• Decide whether to appeal or request reopening.

• Address recurring adjustments in future cost reports.

Building a Cost Report Compliance Program

• Assign ownership of the cost report process and each major data area.

• Maintain written procedures for cost report preparation.

• Train staff on Medicare cost principles and reporting instructions.

• Monitor CMS rulemaking and transmittals affecting cost reports.

• Conduct internal audits of high-risk areas such as S-10 and bad debt.

• Track MAC adjustments over time.

• Ensure the certifying officer understands the attestation.

A Hypothetical Example

A hospital receives an S-10 audit notice. Its review finds that some charity care accounts were written off without a completed financial assistance application, and that patient-level listings included accounts from outside the cost reporting period. The hospital corrects its listing, documents eligibility determinations, and works with the MAC to resolve adjustments. It then revises its charity care write-off process and adds a pre-filing review of S-10 data. The following year's S-10 review results in minimal adjustments.

Medicare Advantage and the Cost Report

Hospitals report Medicare Advantage days and charges on the cost report in specified places, and these data affect calculations such as disproportionate share and graduate medical education payments. Reviewers may examine whether Medicare Advantage days are reported correctly and whether information needed for certain payments, such as the submission of no-pay claims for Medicare Advantage enrollees to support indirect medical education and other calculations, was completed. Hospitals should confirm that their billing processes generate required information claims and that cost report data match internal records.

Interim Rate Reviews

In addition to final settlement, MACs review interim payment rates for providers paid on a cost basis, including critical access hospitals, and for pass-through items such as graduate medical education and organ acquisition. Hospitals can request interim rate reviews when circumstances change, and MACs may adjust rates based on filed cost reports. Accurate interim rates reduce large settlement swings.

Common Myths About Cost Report Review

Myth: A Desk Review Means the Cost Report Was Accepted as Filed

A desk review can result in adjustments, and the cost report may still be reopened within three years.

Myth: Small Errors Do Not Matter

Small errors in statistics or days can have large effects through allocation and payment formulas.

Myth: Protested Items Are Unnecessary if the Hospital Plans to Appeal

Under 42 CFR 413.24(j), hospitals must claim items as protested amounts to preserve appeal rights for self-disallowed items.

Myth: Cost Reports Are Only a Finance Department Responsibility

Data come from many departments, including patient accounts, human resources, health information management, and graduate medical education.

Questions Leadership Should Ask

• Who owns each major area of the cost report?

• Do we reconcile the cost report to audited financial statements?

• How did we perform on our last S-10, wage index, and bad debt reviews?

• Are we tracking reopening windows and appeal deadlines?

• Have we identified protested items for the current year?

• Does the certifying officer understand the attestation?

Key Takeaways

• Cost reports are due five months after year end and must be acceptable to be processed.

• Every cost report receives a desk review, and some are audited.

• High-risk areas include S-10, bad debt, wage index, GME, DSH, related parties, and statistics.

• OIG's 2025 reports on MAC oversight point to more rigorous reviews.

• Preserve appeal rights through protested items and timely PRRB filings.

Data Integrity Across Systems

Cost report data come from general ledger, payroll, patient accounting, health information management, and other systems. Inconsistencies between systems are a common source of desk review questions. For example, patient days in the census system may not match days on billed claims, salaries on Worksheet S-3 may not match payroll records, and charity care write-offs in the patient accounting system may not match the financial assistance log. Hospitals should establish reconciliations between these systems before filing and document how differences were resolved.

Working With the MAC Auditor

Relationships matter. Hospitals that communicate openly with MAC auditors, respond promptly, and explain their methods tend to resolve issues faster. Practical steps include:

• Holding an entrance conference to understand the scope and timeline.

• Providing a list of contacts for each area.

• Using a secure portal or shared folder for document exchange.

• Asking for clarification when a request is unclear.

• Reviewing proposed adjustments promptly and providing written responses with support.

• Documenting agreements and disagreements at the exit conference.

When disagreements remain, hospitals should decide whether to accept adjustments, preserve them for appeal, or pursue reopening, considering the amount at stake and the strength of the hospital's position.

Lessons From OIG's Hospital Audits

OIG regularly audits individual hospitals' Medicare billing and payments, and some findings affect cost reporting, such as reporting of bad debts, wage data, and outlier payments. Hospitals should review OIG reports involving similar hospitals and assess whether the same issues could exist in their own data.

Planning for the Year Ahead

Hospitals should treat the cost report as a year-round process. Monthly reconciliations of days, charges, and key statistics, quarterly reviews of S-10 and bad debt data, and early collection of GME and wage index documentation reduce year-end pressure. A cost report calendar that tracks filing deadlines, wage index review dates, S-10 audit timelines, reopening windows, and PRRB deadlines helps prevent missed opportunities.

Training and Succession

Cost report expertise is often concentrated in a few people. Hospitals should document procedures, cross-train staff, and keep workpapers organized so that knowledge is not lost when staff change. Outside reviewers can provide an independent check on complex areas and help train internal staff.

Using Peer Data

HCRIS cost report data are publicly available, and hospitals can compare their own costs, statistics, and payment data with peers. Large differences may signal reporting errors or areas that reviewers will question. Peer comparisons can also support explanations when a hospital's data are unusual for legitimate reasons, such as a unique service line.

Responding to Wage Index Reviews

The annual wage index review gives hospitals a limited window to review their wage data as reported in public use files and to request corrections. Hospitals that miss the deadlines may be unable to correct errors that affect payments for an entire year. Assign responsibility for monitoring CMS wage index timelines, review the public files carefully, and respond to MAC requests during the review.

The Certifying Officer's Role

The cost report certification statement, signed by an officer or administrator, attests that the cost report is true, correct, and complete and prepared from the books and records of the provider in accordance with applicable instructions. False statements can carry civil and criminal liability. The certifying officer should understand the major areas of the cost report, review key changes, ask questions about significant adjustments, and confirm that internal review steps were completed before signing.

Frequently Asked Questions

When are hospital cost reports due?

Generally on the last day of the fifth month after the end of the cost reporting period.

What is the difference between a desk review and an audit?

A desk review is performed on every cost report and does not include detailed verification. An audit is a more in-depth review performed on selected cost reports.

How long can a cost report be reopened?

Generally within three years of the Notice of Program Reimbursement, with exceptions for fraud or similar fault.

How do hospitals preserve appeal rights for items not allowable under Medicare policy?

By claiming them as protested amounts on the cost report under 42 CFR 413.24(j).

What are the PRRB amount in controversy thresholds?

$10,000 for individual appeals and $50,000 for group appeals.

Conclusion

Cost report review is becoming more rigorous as CMS responds to OIG findings on MAC oversight. Hospitals that reconcile carefully, document every adjustment, focus on high-risk areas such as S-10, bad debt, wage index, GME, and DSH, preserve appeal rights through protested items, and respond to reviews promptly will protect their reimbursement.

How HealthBridge Can Help

HealthBridge is a healthcare management consulting firm that helps hospitals prepare and review cost reports, audit high-risk areas, respond to MAC desk reviews and audits, manage reopenings, and support PRRB appeals. If your hospital is preparing for cost report review, please get in touch with us. We will be happy to help you with this topic.

References

• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 413.24, Adequate Cost Data and Cost Finding. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-413/subpart-B/section-413.24

• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 413.17, Cost to Related Organizations. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-413/subpart-A/section-413.17

• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 413.89, Bad Debts, Charity, and Courtesy Allowances. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-413/subpart-F/section-413.89

• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR Part 405, Subpart R, Provider Reimbursement Determinations and Appeals. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-405/subpart-R

• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Provider Reimbursement Manual, Part 2, Chapter 40, Hospital and Hospital Health Care Complex Cost Report, Form CMS-2552-10. https://www.cms.gov/regulations-and-guidance/guidance/transmittals/downloads/r6p240.pdf

• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Cost Reports. https://www.cms.gov/data-research/statistics-trends-and-reports/cost-reports

• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Provider Reimbursement Review Board. https://www.cms.gov/medicare/regulations-guidance/provider-reimbursement-review-board

• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General. Medicare Administrative Contractors Did Not Consistently Meet Medicare Cost Report Oversight Requirements (A-04-22-06264). https://oig.hhs.gov/documents/audit/10238/A-04-22-06264-highlights.pdf

• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General. Wisconsin Physicians Service Government Health Administrators Reopened and Corrected Cost Report Final Settlements for Desk Reviews Only With Obvious Errors (A-06-24-04001). https://oig.hhs.gov/reports/all/2025/wisconsin-physicians-service-government-health-administrators-reopened-and-corrected-cost-report-final-settlements-for-desk-reviews-only-with-obvious-errors-to-correct-payments-made-to-medicare-providers/

• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General. Novitas Solutions, Inc., Reopened and Corrected Cost Report Final Settlements for Desk Reviews Only With Obvious Errors (A-06-24-05003). https://www.oig.hhs.gov/documents/audit/10908/A-06-24-05003-highlights.pdf

• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General. National Government Services, Inc., Reopened and Corrected Cost Report Final Settlements for Desk Reviews Only With Obvious Errors (A-06-24-05004). https://www.oig.hhs.gov/documents/audit/10914/A-06-24-05004-highlights.pdf

• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General. Work Plan: Medicare Administrative Contractor Cost Report Oversight, Contract Review. https://www.oig.hhs.gov/reports/work-plan/browse-work-plan-projects/medicare-administrative-contractor-cost-report-oversightcontract-review/

Some or all of the services described herein may not be permissible for HealthBridge US clients and their affiliates or related entities.

The information provided is general in nature and is not intended to address the specific circumstances of any individual or entity. While we strive to offer accurate and timely information, we cannot guarantee that such information remains accurate after it is received or that it will continue to be accurate over time. Anyone seeking to act on such information should first seek professional advice tailored to their specific situation. HealthBridge US does not offer legal services.

HealthBridge US is not affiliated with any department of public health agencies in any state, nor with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). We offer healthcare consulting services exclusively and are an independent consulting firm not affiliated with any regulatory organizations, including but not limited to the Accrediting Organizations, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), and state departments. HealthBridge is an anti-fraud company in full compliance with all applicable federal and state regulations for CMS, as well as other relevant business and healthcare laws. The badges, icons, and achievement graphics displayed on this website represent proprietary performance metrics, volume milestones, and internal corporate recognition issued exclusively by our corporate affiliate network at SummitRidge. These visual markers are utilized solely as historical indicators of enterprise growth, operational longevity, and volume-based milestones cleared within our shared corporate ecosystem.

© 2026 HealthBridge US, a California corporation. All rights reserved.

For more information about the structure of HealthBridge, visit www.myhbconsulting.com/governance

Legal

Resources