Medicaid Payment Suspension Appeal: A State-Level Credible Allegation of Fraud Rebuttal Guide
A practical guide to challenging a Medicaid payment suspension based on a credible allegation of fraud, including written rebuttals, good cause requests, state appeal paths, and examples from several states.
KNOWLEDGE CENTER
11/15/202612 min read
A Medicaid payment suspension based on a credible allegation of fraud, often abbreviated CAF, can stop a provider's Medicaid revenue overnight. Federal rules at 42 CFR 455.23 require state Medicaid agencies to suspend all Medicaid payments to a provider once they determine that a credible allegation of fraud exists and an investigation is pending, unless good cause exists not to suspend or to suspend only in part. In 2026, with federal pressure on states to strengthen program integrity, states have used this authority widely. Minnesota, for example, reported stopping payment to hundreds of providers based on credible allegations of fraud since January 2025, and Arizona suspended payments to hundreds of behavioral health providers in its response to a sober living fraud scheme.
A payment suspension is not a finding of fraud. It is a determination that an allegation is reliable enough to warrant investigation. But because suspensions can last for months or longer, and because many providers depend heavily on Medicaid, the first weeks after a suspension notice are critical. Federal rules give providers the right to submit written evidence, and states provide additional review and appeal procedures under their own laws. Using those rights effectively can lead to a suspension being lifted, narrowed, or converted to a partial suspension.
This guide explains the federal framework, how state appeal procedures vary, how to build a written rebuttal and a good cause request, and how to manage the process strategically. It is educational and not legal advice. A CAF suspension almost always accompanies a referral to the state Medicaid Fraud Control Unit, and any provider facing one should work with experienced healthcare counsel from the start.
The Federal Framework
The Suspension Requirement
Under 42 CFR 455.23(a), the state Medicaid agency must suspend all Medicaid payments to a provider after it determines there is a credible allegation of fraud for which an investigation is pending, unless the agency has good cause not to suspend payments or to suspend payment only in part. Federal funding rules give states a strong incentive to suspend, because federal financial participation is not available for payments states fail to suspend when required.
What Makes an Allegation Credible
Under 42 CFR 455.2, a credible allegation of fraud is an allegation, verified by the state, from any source, including fraud hotline complaints, claims data mining, patterns identified through provider audits, civil false claims cases, and law enforcement investigations. Allegations are considered credible when they have indicia of reliability and the state has reviewed all allegations, facts, and evidence carefully and acts judiciously on a case-by-case basis. Some states define credibility in their own statutes. California's statute, for example, has described an allegation as credible if it exhibits indicia of reliability sufficient to meet the constitutional prerequisite to a law enforcement search or seizure, and DHCS has proposed aligning the state standard with the federal definition.
Notice
The state must send notice within five days of suspending payments, unless law enforcement requests a delay, which may extend notice up to 90 days. The notice must state that payments are suspended under the regulation, describe the general allegations, explain that the suspension is temporary and the circumstances under which it will end, identify the types of claims or business units affected, inform the provider of the right to submit written evidence, and describe applicable state administrative appeal rights.
Referral and Duration
The state must refer the matter to the Medicaid Fraud Control Unit. The suspension continues until the agency or prosecuting authority determines there is insufficient evidence of fraud or legal proceedings are completed. The state must obtain certification from law enforcement at least quarterly that the matter continues to be under investigation.
Good Cause
Under 42 CFR 455.23(e), good cause not to suspend, or to end a suspension, may exist when law enforcement requests that no suspension be imposed, other remedies more effectively protect Medicaid funds, the provider's written evidence persuades the state that the suspension should be removed, beneficiary access to care would be jeopardized, law enforcement declines to certify the investigation is continuing, or suspension is not in the best interests of the Medicaid program. Under 42 CFR 455.23(f), good cause may support suspending payments only in part, for example when access to care would be jeopardized, when the allegation focuses solely on a specific type of claim or business unit, or when written evidence supports a partial suspension.
Managed Care
Under 42 CFR 438.608(a)(8), Medicaid managed care plans must suspend payments to a provider when the state determines a credible allegation of fraud exists, unless the state determines good cause exists. A state-level suspension therefore usually affects all Medicaid revenue.
How State Procedures Differ
Federal rules require states to describe their administrative appeal processes in suspension notices, but the processes themselves come from state law. Several examples illustrate the variety.
California
California's Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) Investigations Division states that after a preliminary investigation establishes a credible allegation of fraud, DHCS is required by Welfare and Institutions Code section 14107.11 to place a temporary payment suspension on the provider, unless good cause exists for no suspension or a partial suspension, and must refer the matter to the California Department of Justice's Division of Medi-Cal Fraud and Elder Abuse. California law has also allowed providers to request a meeting with DHCS officials within 30 days after a temporary withhold or temporary suspension letter.
Arizona
The Arizona Health Care Cost Containment System (AHCCCS) has explained that payment suspensions end, or are rescinded, when legal proceedings related to the alleged fraud are completed or when AHCCCS determines there is insufficient evidence of fraud, including when additional information shows the provider was not at fault. AHCCCS published a one-page overview of rescinding a credible allegation of fraud and reported holding 117 informal settlement conferences between May 2023 and August 2025.
Wisconsin
Wisconsin's Department of Health Services has published guidance stating that its Office of the Inspector General initiates the payment suspension process and that a suspension ends upon, among other things, a ruling by the state's Division of Hearings and Appeals in the suspended entity's favor or a successful argument for a good cause exception.
Arkansas
Arkansas's Office of Medicaid Inspector General has stated that providers seeking a good cause exception should submit relevant documentation in writing within 10 days after receiving notice of suspension.
Ohio
Ohio adopted a rule, effective June 2, 2026, governing suspension of Medicaid provider claims payments during a pending audit or investigation, which incorporates the federal good cause exceptions and requires providers to cooperate fully with the state's audit and review process.
Minnesota
Minnesota's Department of Human Services may withhold or reduce payments if it determines there is a credible allegation of fraud for which an investigation is pending. A 2026 report by Minnesota's Office of the Legislative Auditor noted questions about how the state's statutory and regulatory definitions interact, and providers have litigated the duration of withholds under state law.
The Lesson
Deadlines can be very short, such as 10 days for written good cause submissions in some states or 30 days to request a meeting in others. Appeal forums range from informal conferences to formal administrative hearings. Providers must read their notice carefully and calendar every deadline immediately.
The First Ten Days
Retain Counsel
Engage healthcare counsel experienced in Medicaid fraud and payment suspension matters. Counsel should evaluate both the administrative challenge and the underlying criminal and civil exposure, because statements made in a rebuttal can affect the investigation.
Preserve Records
Issue a written litigation hold. Suspend deletion of emails, texts, and electronic records. Instruct staff not to alter clinical or billing documentation.
Analyze the Notice
Identify the general allegations, the claims or business units affected, the deadlines for written evidence and good cause requests, and the available appeal procedures. Note whether the notice describes partial suspension options.
Assess Financial Runway
Calculate how long the organization can operate without Medicaid revenue. This informs whether to prioritize a partial suspension request, an access-to-care argument, or other remedies.
Protect Patients
Develop a plan to maintain safe care and continuity. Patient harm from abrupt closure can create additional liability and undermines good cause arguments.
Request Information
Through counsel, ask the agency for more detail about the allegations to the extent it will share. Some agencies provide more information at informal meetings.
Building the Written Rebuttal
Federal rules guarantee the right to submit written evidence. A strong rebuttal is factual, organized, and supported by documents. It typically includes the following elements.
A Clear Summary
Begin with a concise summary of why the suspension should be lifted or narrowed, identifying the specific regulatory bases, such as written evidence under 455.23(e)(3), access to care under 455.23(e)(4), or partial suspension under 455.23(f).
Responses to Each General Allegation
Address each allegation described in the notice. If the notice says the provider billed for services not rendered, provide evidence that services were delivered, such as signed progress notes, attendance records, electronic visit verification data, appointment logs, and staff time records. If the notice says services were provided by unqualified staff, provide licenses, certifications, background checks, and training records. If the notice cites billing patterns, explain the clinical or operational reasons for those patterns with supporting data.
A Claims Sample Analysis
Where appropriate, counsel may commission an independent review of a sample of claims to show that documentation supports billing. The methodology should be explained, and results should be presented honestly. A sample that reveals problems should be discussed with counsel before submission.
Evidence of Compliance Infrastructure
Describe the compliance program, including policies, training, audits, exclusion screening, and corrective actions taken in the past. Evidence that the provider identified and corrected problems and returned overpayments supports good faith.
Corrective Actions Taken
If the internal review identifies genuine problems, describe corrective actions already taken, such as removing individuals, changing processes, retraining staff, and refunding overpayments. Acknowledging and fixing problems can support a partial suspension or alternative remedy even if the agency does not lift the suspension entirely.
Exhibits and Index
Organize exhibits with an index and cross-references. Reviewers are more likely to engage with a submission that is easy to navigate.
Building the Good Cause Request
Access to Care
The access-to-care exception applies when a provider is the sole community physician or the sole source of essential specialized services in a community, or serves a large number of beneficiaries in a federally designated medically underserved area. Evidence may include:
• Number of active Medicaid patients and services they receive.
• Maps showing the nearest alternative providers and travel distances.
• Wait times and capacity at alternative providers.
• Federal designations of the service area, such as health professional shortage areas or medically underserved areas.
• Clinical consequences of disruption, such as interrupted medication for opioid use disorder or loss of specialized pediatric services.
• Letters from referring physicians, hospitals, or community organizations.
Partial Suspension
If the allegations focus on one service, location, or business unit, show that the rest of the operation is separate and unaffected. Evidence may include separate billing identifiers, staff, locations, and compliance histories. Propose that suspension apply only to the implicated claims.
Alternative Remedies
Propose remedies that protect Medicaid funds while allowing continued payment, such as prepayment review of claims, an independent monitor, enhanced documentation requirements, or holding payments in escrow. CMS guidance has discussed escrow arrangements as a possible approach in some circumstances. These proposals show the agency it can protect the program without a full suspension.
Best Interests of the Program
Explain why continued payment, perhaps with safeguards, is in the best interests of the Medicaid program, for example because of the provider's role in the community, the quality of its care, or the limited nature of the allegations.
The Meeting or Informal Conference
Where state law provides a meeting or informal conference, prepare carefully:
• Submit written materials in advance where allowed.
• Bring counsel and a small team that can speak knowledgeably about operations, clinical care, and billing.
• Focus on facts and documents, not general denials.
• Propose concrete solutions, such as partial suspension or prepayment review.
• Follow up in writing with any additional information requested.
Be mindful that statements made in these settings may be shared with investigators.
Formal Administrative Appeals
If informal efforts fail, formal administrative appeal rights under state law may be available. These may include hearings before an administrative law judge, with opportunities to present witnesses and evidence. Courts generally give agencies latitude in suspension decisions, and some states limit what can be challenged, so counsel should assess the likely benefit and the interaction with any criminal investigation. Judicial review may be available after administrative remedies are exhausted.
Coordinating With Managed Care Plans
Because plans generally must suspend payments when the state does, providers should notify their plans through counsel, confirm how each plan is implementing the suspension, and seek clarification of which claims are affected, especially if the state imposes a partial suspension. When a suspension is lifted or narrowed, confirm that each plan updates its systems promptly.
Parallel Proceedings
A CAF suspension usually accompanies an MFCU referral and may coincide with Medicare actions, licensing investigations, or civil false claims inquiries. Strategy must account for all of these:
• Statements in an administrative rebuttal can be used in criminal or civil proceedings.
• Individuals may have interests that differ from the organization's and may need separate counsel.
• Medicare may impose its own suspension under 42 CFR 405.371.
• Enrollment termination or exclusion may follow if allegations are substantiated.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
• Missing short deadlines for written evidence or meeting requests.
• Submitting general denials without documentation.
• Altering records after notice.
• Making statements without counsel that create criminal exposure.
• Ignoring access-to-care evidence that could support good cause.
• Failing to propose alternatives to a full suspension.
• Allowing patient care to collapse, which harms patients and undermines credibility.
• Overlooking managed care implementation of the suspension.
Tracking the Suspension Over Time
A suspension is not a single event but an ongoing status. Because the state must periodically confirm with law enforcement that the matter remains under investigation, circumstances can change. Providers should calendar periodic check-ins through counsel, ask whether the investigation has progressed, and renew good cause requests when new facts arise, such as completed corrective actions, changes in leadership, or new access-to-care information. If law enforcement declines to certify that the matter continues to be under investigation, that itself can be a basis for ending the suspension.
Documenting Financial and Patient Impact
Detailed records of the suspension's impact strengthen later arguments. Track withheld amounts by month, staff reductions, closed programs, patients transferred, and service interruptions. This information can support access-to-care and best-interests arguments, inform settlement discussions, and help quantify damages if a suspension is later found to have been improper.
Organized impact records also help leadership make informed decisions about staffing, program continuity, and financing while the suspension remains in place.
Sharing appropriate parts of these records with the agency, through counsel, can make the human and community consequences of a suspension concrete.
Myths About Payment Suspension Appeals
Myth: Nothing Can Be Done Until the Investigation Ends
Federal rules guarantee the right to submit written evidence, and good cause exceptions and state appeal rights can lead to lifted or narrowed suspensions.
Myth: A Strong Denial Letter Is Enough
Agencies respond to documented evidence and practical solutions, not general denials.
Myth: Partial Suspensions Are Rare and Not Worth Requesting
Federal rules expressly allow partial suspensions, and they can preserve operations when allegations are limited.
Myth: The Rebuttal Is Separate From the Criminal Case
Information submitted to the agency can be shared with investigators, so rebuttals must be prepared with counsel.
Questions Leadership Should Ask
• What deadlines does our notice set, and have we calendared them?
• Which good cause exceptions might apply to us?
• Can we document that services were delivered and staff were qualified?
• Are the allegations limited to one service or location?
• How long can we operate without Medicaid revenue?
• Have we coordinated with managed care plans?
• Is our counsel addressing both the administrative and criminal dimensions?
Key Takeaways
• Under 42 CFR 455.23, states must suspend Medicaid payments upon a credible allegation of fraud unless good cause exists not to suspend or to suspend only in part.
• Providers have a federal right to submit written evidence, and states provide additional review and appeal procedures that vary widely, with deadlines as short as 10 days.
• Effective rebuttals respond to each allegation with documents, show compliance infrastructure and corrective actions, and propose alternatives.
• Good cause requests can rest on access to care, partial suspension, alternative remedies, or the program's best interests.
• Because suspensions accompany fraud referrals, every step should be coordinated with counsel to manage parallel proceedings.
How HealthBridge Can Help
HealthBridge supports providers facing Medicaid payment suspensions, working alongside their legal counsel. Our team can help organize documentation to respond to each allegation, conduct privileged claims and documentation reviews at counsel's direction, analyze billing data to explain patterns, and assemble access-to-care evidence for good cause requests. We help providers propose and implement alternative safeguards such as prepayment review processes and enhanced documentation controls, model cash flow, and strengthen compliance programs for the future. If your organization is facing a payment suspension or wants to be prepared for one, please get in touch with us. We will be happy to help you with this topic.
References
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 455.23, Suspension of payments in cases of fraud. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-C/part-455/subpart-A/section-455.23
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 455.2, Definitions. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-C/part-455/subpart-A/section-455.2
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 438.608, Program integrity requirements under the contract. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-C/part-438/subpart-H/section-438.608
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 405.371, Suspension, offset, and recoupment of Medicare payments. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-405/subpart-C/section-405.371
• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Medicaid Payment Suspension Toolkit. https://www.cms.gov/medicare-medicaid-coordination/fraud-prevention/fraudabuseforprofs/downloads/medicaid-paymentsuspension-toolkit-0914.pdf
• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. MFCU Coordination Best Practices under 42 CFR 455.21. https://www.cms.gov/files/document/medicaid-fraud-control-unit-mcfu-coordination.pdf
• California Department of Health Care Services. Provider Fraud. https://www.dhcs.ca.gov/individuals/provider-fraud/
• California Department of Health Care Services. Administrative Sanctions and Utilization Controls. https://www.dhcs.ca.gov/individuals/administrative-sanctions-utilization-controls/
• Arizona Health Care Cost Containment System. Sober Living Fraud Response. https://azahcccs.gov/SoberLivingFraud
• Arizona Health Care Cost Containment System. Presentation to Senate Health and Human Services Special Hearing (August 18, 2025). https://www.azahcccs.gov/Fraud/Downloads/AHCCCS_Aug_18_2025_HHS_Special_Hearing.pdf
• Wisconsin Department of Health Services. Medicaid Payment Suspension (P-01843). https://www.dhs.wisconsin.gov/publications/p01843.pdf
• Arkansas Office of Medicaid Inspector General. Good Cause Exception to Suspension. https://static.ark.org/eeuploads/omig/GOOD_CAUSE_EXCEPTION_TO_SUSPENSION.pdf
• Ohio Administrative Code. Rule 5160-1-17.51, Suspension of Medicaid provider claims payments during a pending audit or investigation. https://codes.ohio.gov/assets/laws/administrative-code/authenticated/5160/0/1/5160-1-17-51_20260602.pdf
• Minnesota Office of the Legislative Auditor. DHS Investigations of Alleged Kickbacks in the EIDBI Program, Special Review (March 17, 2026). https://www.house.mn.gov/comm/docs/6h8RTyXVK0m9Bn0Qz0eY7A.pdf
• Minnesota Department of Human Services. Program integrity updates. https://content.govdelivery.com/accounts/MNDHS/bulletins/41ff70d

Some or all of the services described herein may not be permissible for HealthBridge US clients and their affiliates or related entities.
The information provided is general in nature and is not intended to address the specific circumstances of any individual or entity. While we strive to offer accurate and timely information, we cannot guarantee that such information remains accurate after it is received or that it will continue to be accurate over time. Anyone seeking to act on such information should first seek professional advice tailored to their specific situation. HealthBridge US does not offer legal services.
HealthBridge US is not affiliated with any department of public health agencies in any state, nor with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). We offer healthcare consulting services exclusively and are an independent consulting firm not affiliated with any regulatory organizations, including but not limited to the Accrediting Organizations, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), and state departments. HealthBridge is an anti-fraud company in full compliance with all applicable federal and state regulations for CMS, as well as other relevant business and healthcare laws. The badges, icons, and achievement graphics displayed on this website represent proprietary performance metrics, volume milestones, and internal corporate recognition issued exclusively by our corporate affiliate network at SummitRidge. These visual markers are utilized solely as historical indicators of enterprise growth, operational longevity, and volume-based milestones cleared within our shared corporate ecosystem.
© 2026 HealthBridge US, a California corporation. All rights reserved.
For more information about the structure of HealthBridge, visit www.myhbconsulting.com/governance
