Medical Director and Physician Contract Audits: Fair Market Value and Stark/AKS Documentation
How to audit medical director agreements and other physician compensation arrangements for Stark Law and Anti-Kickback Statute compliance, including fair market value, commercial reasonableness, written agreement and signature requirements, time documentation, and lessons from 2026 enforcement actions.
KNOWLEDGE CENTER
11/15/202612 min read
Medical director agreements and other physician services arrangements are among the most common, and most frequently scrutinized, financial relationships in healthcare. Hospitals, home health agencies, hospices, skilled nursing facilities, laboratories, imaging centers, and many other providers pay physicians to direct programs, supervise services, serve on call, provide administrative leadership, or consult. These arrangements serve legitimate purposes, but when the physician is also a source of referrals, they implicate the federal physician self-referral law, commonly called the Stark Law, and the federal Anti-Kickback Statute. Arrangements that do not satisfy applicable requirements can taint every claim for referred services and create False Claims Act liability.
Enforcement in 2026 has made the risks concrete. In January 2026, DOJ intervened in a False Claims Act case against a long-term care hospital group and a physician, alleging that three medical director agreements paying the physician more than $450,000 lacked any fair market value analysis, duplicated services already provided under another agreement, and were supported by inaccurate timesheets. The same month, a home health and hospice provider agreed to pay $34 million to resolve allegations including remuneration to medical directors in exchange for referrals, following its own self-disclosures. In the spring, a New York hospital agreed to pay about $6.8 million to resolve Stark and Anti-Kickback allegations involving three physician agreements. In July 2026, a laboratory agreed to pay $9.8 million after self-disclosing that it provided below fair market value services to referral sources.
This article explains the legal framework for physician compensation arrangements, what auditors and the government examine, how to document fair market value and commercial reasonableness, and how to conduct internal audits of medical director and physician contracts. It is educational and not legal advice. Stark and Anti-Kickback analyses are fact-specific, and organizations should work with experienced healthcare counsel and qualified valuation professionals.
The Legal Framework
The Stark Law
The Stark Law, at 42 U.S.C. 1395nn and 42 CFR 411.350 through 411.389, prohibits a physician from referring Medicare patients for designated health services to an entity with which the physician or an immediate family member has a financial relationship, unless an exception applies, and prohibits the entity from billing Medicare for services furnished pursuant to a prohibited referral. Designated health services include hospital inpatient and outpatient services, clinical laboratory services, physical and occupational therapy, radiology and imaging, durable medical equipment, home health services, outpatient prescription drugs, and others. The Stark Law is a strict liability statute for purposes of payment denial and refund obligations, meaning intent is not required. Knowing violations can lead to civil monetary penalties and False Claims Act liability.
Key Stark Exceptions for Physician Services
Physician compensation arrangements typically must meet an exception such as personal service arrangements under 42 CFR 411.357(d), fair market value compensation under 411.357(l), bona fide employment under 411.357(c), or indirect compensation arrangements under 411.357(p). Most exceptions share core requirements:
• The arrangement is set out in writing, signed by the parties, and specifies the services to be furnished.
• Compensation is set in advance.
• Compensation does not exceed fair market value.
• Compensation is not determined in any manner that takes into account the volume or value of referrals or other business generated by the physician.
• The arrangement is commercially reasonable even if no referrals were made.
• The term, for many exceptions, is at least one year.
CMS's 2020 Stark Law final rule, published December 2, 2020, clarified several of these concepts. It defined commercially reasonable to mean that the particular arrangement furthers a legitimate business purpose of the parties and is sensible considering their characteristics, and stated that an arrangement may be commercially reasonable even if it does not result in profit. It established special rules for determining when compensation takes into account the volume or value of referrals, refined the definition of fair market value, and added a limited remuneration exception for small amounts of compensation that do not meet all exception requirements, along with flexibility for writing and signature requirements for up to 90 days.
The Anti-Kickback Statute
The Anti-Kickback Statute, at 42 U.S.C. 1320a-7b(b), makes it a felony to knowingly and willfully offer, pay, solicit, or receive remuneration to induce or reward referrals of items or services payable by federal health care programs. Unlike the Stark Law, the Anti-Kickback Statute requires intent and applies to anyone, not just physicians, and to all federal health care programs. Claims resulting from Anti-Kickback violations are false claims under the False Claims Act.
The Personal Services and Management Contracts Safe Harbor
The personal services and management contracts and outcomes-based payments safe harbor, at 42 CFR 1001.952(d), protects arrangements that meet all of its requirements, including a signed written agreement covering all services for at least one year, specification of the services, compensation methodology set in advance, compensation consistent with fair market value in an arm's-length transaction, compensation not determined in a manner that takes into account the volume or value of referrals or business generated, and services that do not exceed those reasonably necessary to accomplish the commercially reasonable business purpose. Arrangements that do not fit the safe harbor are not automatically illegal, but they are evaluated based on the facts, including intent.
Consequences
Violations can result in denial of payment and refund obligations under the Stark Law, civil monetary penalties, exclusion, criminal prosecution under the Anti-Kickback Statute, and False Claims Act liability with treble damages and per-claim penalties. Because a single noncompliant arrangement can taint all claims for designated health services referred by the physician during the period of noncompliance, exposure can be substantial.
What the Government Examines
The 2026 enforcement actions and earlier cases show recurring themes.
Fair Market Value
The government examines whether compensation was consistent with fair market value for the services actually provided, without regard to the physician's referrals. In the January 2026 long-term care hospital case, DOJ emphasized that neither the hospital group nor the hospital conducted a formal fair market value analysis for any of the three agreements. In other cases, the government has alleged that organizations relied on valuations they knew were inaccurate or that considered downstream revenue.
Commercial Reasonableness and Need
The government asks whether the organization had a legitimate need for the services, whether the number of medical directors was reasonable, and whether the services duplicated those provided by others. Multiple medical directorships for the same physician, or several physicians paid to direct the same program, draw scrutiny.
Services Actually Performed
The government examines whether physicians actually performed the contracted services. Missing, incomplete, or inaccurate timesheets, timesheets that do not match other records, and payments made without documentation of services are common allegations.
Relationship to Referrals
The government looks for evidence that compensation was tied to referrals, such as compensation increases following referral growth, selection of medical directors based on referral volume, communications linking payments to referrals, or terminations of physicians whose referrals declined. In the 2026 long-term care hospital case, the complaint cited communications allegedly instructing staff to deliver medical director checks to physicians and ask for patients.
Written Agreement Compliance
The government reviews whether agreements were signed, current, and followed in practice, including whether payments matched contract terms, whether arrangements continued after expiration without renewal, and whether compensation changed without amendment.
Below Fair Market Value Benefits
Arrangements in which an entity provides services, space, staff, or items to referral sources at below fair market value can also violate the Stark Law and Anti-Kickback Statute, as the July 2026 laboratory settlement illustrates.
Documenting Fair Market Value
Independent Valuation
For significant arrangements, organizations should obtain a fair market value opinion from a qualified independent valuation firm. The opinion should be based on the specific services, time commitment, physician qualifications, and market data, and should not consider the volume or value of referrals or downstream revenue.
Use of Survey Data
Valuations often rely on compensation surveys. Organizations should understand how survey data were applied, whether hourly rates are appropriate for the specialty and type of service, and whether adjustments were justified.
Consistency
Compensation for similar services should be consistent across physicians, and departures from internal compensation policies should be documented and justified.
Periodic Updates
Fair market value opinions should be updated periodically, typically every two to three years or when arrangements change materially, because market conditions and duties evolve.
Stacking
When a physician holds multiple arrangements with the same entity, such as several medical directorships, on-call coverage, and employment, the organization should evaluate total compensation and total time commitment to ensure the combined arrangements remain fair market value and are physically possible to perform.
Documenting Commercial Reasonableness
Needs Assessment
Before entering into an arrangement, the organization should document a needs assessment explaining why the services are needed, why this physician was selected, how the services fit with existing arrangements, and why the time commitment is appropriate. The needs assessment should not rely on the physician's referral potential.
Regulatory Requirements
Some medical director roles are required by regulation, such as medical directors of skilled nursing facilities under 42 CFR 483.70(g) and hospice medical directors under 42 CFR 418.102. Documenting the regulatory basis supports commercial reasonableness but does not by itself justify the compensation level or the number of directorships.
Avoiding Duplication
The needs assessment should confirm that the services do not duplicate those provided under other arrangements.
Time and Activity Documentation
Time documentation is often the weakest point of medical director arrangements and a central issue in enforcement. Effective documentation practices include:
• Requiring physicians to submit detailed time records describing the specific services performed, the dates, and the time spent.
• Tying payment to the receipt and review of time records, with payments withheld when records are missing.
• Reviewing time records for consistency with contract duties and other records, such as meeting minutes and policy approvals.
• Retaining evidence of work product, such as committee minutes, policies reviewed, quality reports, and training provided.
• Flagging records that show identical entries every period, round numbers that match maximum allowable hours, or activities outside the scope of the contract.
Contract Management
Centralized Contract Database
Organizations should maintain a centralized database of all physician arrangements, including the parties, services, compensation, term, renewal dates, fair market value support, needs assessment, and responsible manager. The database should be reconciled regularly with accounts payable to identify payments to physicians without corresponding contracts.
Signatures and Terms
Contracts should be fully executed before services begin and payments are made. The database should track expiration dates and require renewal or termination before expiration. Holdover provisions should be used carefully and consistent with Stark rules.
Amendments
Compensation changes should be made only through written amendments and should comply with Stark rules on modifying compensation, which generally require that the modified compensation be set in advance, meet the exception requirements, and remain in place for at least one year.
Approval Workflow
Physician arrangements should go through a defined approval process that includes legal and compliance review, fair market value and needs assessment documentation, and appropriate leadership approval.
Auditing Physician Contracts
Scope
An internal audit should select a sample of physician arrangements, weighted toward high-compensation arrangements, physicians with multiple arrangements, high-referring physicians, and arrangements that recently changed.
Audit Steps
For each arrangement, the audit should confirm that:
• A written agreement signed by all parties was in effect for every period of payment.
• The agreement specified the services and compensation.
• A current fair market value analysis supports the compensation.
• A needs assessment documents commercial reasonableness.
• Payments matched the contract terms.
• Time and activity documentation supports each payment.
• Compensation was not tied to referrals.
• The arrangement meets an applicable Stark exception and, where possible, the Anti-Kickback safe harbor.
Identifying Gaps
Common gaps include expired agreements, missing signatures, missing or outdated valuations, payments exceeding contract terms, missing time records, and duplicated services.
Remediation
When gaps are found, counsel should evaluate whether the arrangement violated the Stark Law or the Anti-Kickback Statute, whether a Stark exception or special rule applies, and whether overpayments exist. Remediation may include correcting documentation where permitted, repaying overpayments, renegotiating or terminating arrangements, and disciplining responsible personnel.
Self-Disclosure
When an organization identifies a potential Stark violation, CMS's Voluntary Self-Referral Disclosure Protocol provides a process for disclosing and resolving Stark-only violations, often at amounts substantially lower than the full refund liability. When conduct may also violate the Anti-Kickback Statute, the OIG Health Care Fraud Self-Disclosure Protocol is the appropriate path. The 2026 settlements involving self-disclosed conduct show that DOJ continues to credit self-disclosure and cooperation in reaching resolutions. Counsel should guide the choice of disclosure path and the preparation of any disclosure.
Special Arrangement Types
On-Call Coverage
Hospitals frequently pay physicians for on-call coverage. On-call arrangements should be supported by documented need, such as coverage gaps or regulatory requirements, and by fair market value analysis that considers the burden of call, the likelihood of being called in, and whether the physician can bill separately for services provided. Paying physicians for call they would otherwise provide as a condition of medical staff membership, or paying for call that is rarely needed, can raise concerns.
Co-Management Agreements
Service line co-management arrangements pay physicians to help manage hospital service lines, often with a base fee and incentive payments tied to quality and efficiency metrics. These arrangements require careful attention to fair market value, clearly defined duties, objective metrics that are not tied to referrals, and documentation that physicians performed management services.
Value-Based Arrangements
The 2020 Stark and Anti-Kickback rules added exceptions and safe harbors for value-based arrangements within value-based enterprises. These protections have their own requirements, including defined value-based purposes, target patient populations, and monitoring obligations. Organizations relying on these protections should document how each requirement is met.
Employment Arrangements
Employed physician compensation must generally meet the bona fide employment exception, which requires compensation consistent with fair market value and not determined in a manner that takes into account the volume or value of referrals, although productivity bonuses based on personally performed services are permitted. Employment does not eliminate scrutiny, as cases have challenged compensation that exceeded fair market value or that was linked to referrals of designated health services.
Arrangements With Immediate Family Members
Financial relationships with a physician's immediate family members, such as a spouse employed by the entity, can create Stark financial relationships. Organizations should identify and evaluate these relationships as part of contract inventories.
Building a Sustainable Contract Compliance Program
Audits are most effective when paired with ongoing controls. Organizations should assign a single owner for physician arrangements, often within legal or compliance, and require that every arrangement pass through that owner before execution. Accounts payable should be instructed not to issue payments to physicians without a contract number from the central database and an approved time record where required. Leadership should receive periodic reports on expiring contracts, missing time records, valuations due for update, and audit results. Training for executives and department leaders who negotiate with physicians should cover Stark and Anti-Kickback basics and the organization's approval process.
Common Mistakes
• Paying physicians without signed, current agreements.
• Setting compensation without a fair market value analysis.
• Relying on valuations that consider referrals or downstream revenue.
• Failing to collect or review time records.
• Creating multiple directorships for high-referring physicians without documented need.
• Allowing compensation to change without written amendments.
• Providing services or space to referral sources below fair market value.
• Failing to reconcile payments with contracts.
Myths About Physician Contracts
Myth: A Required Medical Director Role Is Automatically Compliant
Regulatory requirements support the need for a role, but compensation must still be fair market value and services must be documented.
Myth: A Fair Market Value Opinion Solves Everything
A valuation addresses compensation level, but arrangements must also be commercially reasonable, documented, followed in practice, and not tied to referrals.
Myth: Missing Timesheets Are a Paperwork Problem
Missing documentation can support allegations that services were not performed and that payments were disguised kickbacks.
Myth: Small Arrangements Are Not Worth Auditing
Even modest arrangements can taint all claims for designated health services referred by the physician.
Questions Leadership Should Ask
• Do we have a complete, current inventory of physician arrangements?
• Does every arrangement have a signed agreement, fair market value support, and needs assessment?
• Do we withhold payment when time records are missing?
• How do we monitor total compensation for physicians with multiple arrangements?
• When did we last audit physician contracts?
• Do we have a process for evaluating and disclosing potential violations?
Key Takeaways
• Medical director and physician services arrangements must satisfy Stark exceptions and should be structured to fit Anti-Kickback safe harbors where possible.
• Core requirements include a signed writing, compensation set in advance, fair market value, no consideration of referrals, and commercial reasonableness.
• 2026 enforcement actions highlight missing fair market value analyses, duplicated services, inaccurate timesheets, and referral-linked payments.
• Independent valuations, needs assessments, time documentation, centralized contract management, and internal audits are essential safeguards.
• When problems are found, counsel should evaluate repayment and self-disclosure through CMS's Self-Referral Disclosure Protocol or OIG's Self-Disclosure Protocol.
How HealthBridge Can Help
HealthBridge helps hospitals, post-acute providers, laboratories, and other healthcare organizations manage and audit physician arrangements. Our team can inventory physician contracts, audit arrangements for written agreement, fair market value, commercial reasonableness, payment, and time documentation compliance, design contract management and approval workflows, and support counsel in evaluating remediation and disclosure options. We also help organizations build time documentation processes and ongoing monitoring. If your organization wants to review its medical director and physician arrangements, please get in touch with us. We will be happy to help you with this topic.
References
• U.S. Code. 42 U.S.C. 1395nn, Limitation on certain physician referrals (Stark Law). https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid:USC-prelim-title42-section1395nn
• U.S. Code. 42 U.S.C. 1320a-7b(b), Anti-Kickback Statute. https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid:USC-prelim-title42-section1320a-7b
• U.S. Code. 31 U.S.C. 3729-3733, False Claims Act. https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid:USC-prelim-title31-section3729
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR Part 411, Subpart J, Financial Relationships Between Physicians and Entities Furnishing Designated Health Services. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-411/subpart-J
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 411.357, Exceptions to the referral prohibition related to compensation arrangements. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-411/subpart-J/section-411.357
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 1001.952(d), Personal services and management contracts and outcomes-based payments safe harbor. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-V/subchapter-B/part-1001/subpart-C/section-1001.952
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 483.70, Administration (nursing facility medical director). https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-G/part-483/subpart-B/section-483.70
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 418.102, Condition of participation: Medical director (hospice). https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-418/subpart-C/section-418.102
• Federal Register. Medicare Program; Modernizing and Clarifying the Physician Self-Referral Regulations (85 FR 77492, December 2, 2020). https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2020/12/02/2020-26140
• Federal Register. Medicare and State Health Care Programs: Fraud and Abuse; Revisions to Safe Harbors Under the Anti-Kickback Statute (85 FR 77684, December 2, 2020). https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2020/12/02/2020-26072
• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Voluntary Self-Referral Disclosure Protocol. https://www.cms.gov/medicare/regulations-guidance/physician-self-referral/self-referral-disclosure-protocol
• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Physician Self-Referral. https://www.cms.gov/medicare/regulations-guidance/physician-self-referral
• HHS Office of Inspector General. Health Care Fraud Self-Disclosure Protocol. https://oig.hhs.gov/compliance/self-disclosure-info/
• HHS Office of Inspector General. A Roadmap for New Physicians: Fraud and Abuse Laws. https://oig.hhs.gov/compliance/physician-education/
• U.S. Department of Justice. Florida Laboratory Agrees to Pay $9.8M to Resolve False Claims Act Liability Relating to Self-Disclosure of Compensation Arrangements (July 2026). https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/florida-laboratory-agrees-pay-98m-resolve-false-claims-act-liability-relating-self
• U.S. Department of Justice. Trinity Hospital Agrees to Pay $1.7M to Resolve Alleged Stark Law Violations. https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/trinity-hospital-agrees-pay-17m-resolve-alleged-stark-law-violations

Some or all of the services described herein may not be permissible for HealthBridge US clients and their affiliates or related entities.
The information provided is general in nature and is not intended to address the specific circumstances of any individual or entity. While we strive to offer accurate and timely information, we cannot guarantee that such information remains accurate after it is received or that it will continue to be accurate over time. Anyone seeking to act on such information should first seek professional advice tailored to their specific situation. HealthBridge US does not offer legal services.
HealthBridge US is not affiliated with any department of public health agencies in any state, nor with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). We offer healthcare consulting services exclusively and are an independent consulting firm not affiliated with any regulatory organizations, including but not limited to the Accrediting Organizations, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), and state departments. HealthBridge is an anti-fraud company in full compliance with all applicable federal and state regulations for CMS, as well as other relevant business and healthcare laws. The badges, icons, and achievement graphics displayed on this website represent proprietary performance metrics, volume milestones, and internal corporate recognition issued exclusively by our corporate affiliate network at SummitRidge. These visual markers are utilized solely as historical indicators of enterprise growth, operational longevity, and volume-based milestones cleared within our shared corporate ecosystem.
© 2026 HealthBridge US, a California corporation. All rights reserved.
For more information about the structure of HealthBridge, visit www.myhbconsulting.com/governance
