Michigan Medicaid Audit Response: MDHHS Office of Inspector General Reviews and Appeals

How the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General audits Medicaid providers, the 30-day deadlines for records, rebuttals, and appeals, summary suspensions, and how to use internal conferences and administrative hearings.

KNOWLEDGE CENTER

11/15/202612 min read

The Michigan Department of Health and Human Services (MDHHS) administers Michigan Medicaid, including fee-for-service programs and the managed care programs operated through Medicaid Health Plans and Prepaid Inpatient Health Plans. The MDHHS Office of Inspector General (OIG) is responsible for protecting the integrity of programs administered by MDHHS, and it is authorized to perform post-payment reviews of paid Medicaid claims to identify and recover overpayments. OIG also investigates suspected fraud, refers cases to the Michigan Department of Attorney General, and supports summary suspensions of providers when emergency action is needed to protect public funds.

Michigan's audit process is built around a series of 30-day deadlines. Under the OIG's published audit process, a provider generally has 30 calendar days to respond to a records request, 30 days to agree with or rebut a Draft Findings Report, and 30 days after a Final Notice of Recovery to complete repayment or request an appeal through an internal conference or an administrative hearing. Missing any of these deadlines can make findings final and start recoupment.

This article explains how MDHHS OIG audits work, the appeal options, summary suspensions and payment suspensions, and practical strategies for responding. It is educational and not legal advice. Providers facing an MDHHS OIG audit or suspension should consult experienced Michigan healthcare counsel.

The Legal Framework

Michigan's Medicaid audit authority comes from several sources:

• The Social Welfare Act, including MCL 400.111a, which addresses audits, recovery of payments, collection of overpayments, and selection of providers for review based on criteria that may include comparison of services and costs with peers and prior warnings or sanctions.

• MCL 400.111b, which sets conditions of provider participation, including recordkeeping requirements. Under MCL 400.111b(8), a provider must retain required records for 7 years.

• MCL 400.111e and 400.111d, which describe grounds for sanctions and the actions the director may take.

• MCL 400.111f, which authorizes summary suspension of a provider when emergency action is needed to protect public funds.

• The Medicaid Provider Manual, particularly the General Information for Providers chapter, including Section 14.2 on pre- and post-payment review and Section 16 on post-payment review and fraud and abuse.

• The Medical Assistance Provider Enrollment and Trading Partner Agreement that each provider signs.

• Federal program integrity rules at 42 CFR Part 455, including 42 CFR 455.23 on payment suspensions.

The Medicaid Provider Manual requires providers to maintain legible records necessary to support services billed, and MDHHS has reminded providers that records must be retained for not less than seven years from the date of service, regardless of a change in ownership or termination of participation.

Types of OIG Audits

The OIG's post-payment audit process describes two main audit types.

Complex Audits

Complex audits require review of records. The OIG's audit contractor sends a Medical Record Request letter to the provider's correspondence address. The provider has 30 calendar days to respond. If records are submitted, the contractor typically has 180 days to audit and issue a Draft Findings Report. If no records are submitted, a Final Notice of Recovery is issued, and the provider has 30 days to appeal or recoupment begins.

Automated Audits

Automated audits do not require record review. Improper payments are identified from claim data, established policies, and rules, and a Draft Findings Report is sent directly to the provider. The provider has 30 days to agree or submit rebuttal documentation.

Scope and Limits

According to the OIG's FAQ:

• All provider types are subject to audit.

• The process described applies to fee-for-service claims. Managed care encounter claims, and claims where Medicare or a commercial payer was primary, are excluded from this process.

• The lookback typically reaches claims with dates of service on or after October 1, 2014.

• Record requests are limited to no more than 150 records per request, or 500 in three months, per billing NPI.

• Record copying costs are not reimbursable.

• Extension requests must be in writing, submitted before the deadline, and are granted at the OIG's sole discretion.

• Statistical sampling and extrapolation may be used to determine overpayment amounts.

• The contractor does not identify underpayments.

The Path From Draft Findings to Final Notice

Draft Findings Report and Rebuttal

The Draft Findings Report describes the preliminary findings. The provider must submit any rebuttal documentation within 30 days of the report date. If no rebuttal is sent, the preliminary findings become final, and a Final Notice of Recovery is issued. If rebuttal is submitted, it is reviewed, and a Final Notice of Recovery is then issued reflecting the results.

Final Notice of Recovery

After the Final Notice of Recovery, the provider has 30 days to agree and complete the recoupment instructions or to request an appeal. If neither happens within 30 days, MDHHS starts recoupment. According to the OIG's FAQ, if a timely appeal is filed, no recovery occurs until the appeal is resolved.

Repayment Methods

The OIG describes several repayment methods. For claims adjudicated in CHAMPS, the preferred method is for the provider to adjust claims electronically and note the OIG audit in the comments field; unadjusted claims are voided or gross adjusted by MDHHS. For sampling and extrapolation audits, OIG applies a gross adjustment to future claims. Pharmacy and Home Help payments have their own procedures, and all adjustments must be submitted before the 30-day deadline in the Final Notice.

Appeal Options

Internal Conference

An internal conference must be requested in writing within 30 days of the adverse action, such as the Final Notice of Recovery. An appeal review officer determines whether the department acted according to Medical Services Administration policy. The request must include a copy of the Final Notice, a list of the items appealed, the dollar amount, and supporting documentation. Requests that miss the timeframe or omit required items may be denied.

Administrative Hearing

An administrative hearing must be requested in writing within 30 days of the Final Notice of Recovery or of the internal conference decision. Either the provider or MDHHS may request a hearing if it disagrees with the internal conference decision. The request must include a copy of the notice or decision, the specific disputed determinations, the reasons they are incorrect, the dollar amount, and documentary evidence. Hearings are conducted by administrative law judges at the Michigan Office of Administrative Hearings and Rules (MOAHR).

Appeal Outcomes

If findings are overturned, OIG issues a Final Notice of Appeal Overturn and recovery stops. If findings are upheld or amended, OIG issues a Revised Final Notice, and the provider has 30 days to complete the recoupment instructions before recoupment begins.

Choosing Between an Internal Conference and a Hearing

An internal conference can be faster and less formal and can resolve disputes about how policy was applied. An administrative hearing is a formal evidentiary proceeding. Because a provider may request a hearing after an unfavorable internal conference decision, many providers use the conference first. Counsel can help weigh the issues, evidence, and costs.

Summary Suspensions and Payment Suspensions

Summary Suspension Under MCL 400.111f

Under MCL 400.111f, the director may issue an order of summary suspension when emergency action is needed to protect public funds. Qualifying circumstances include a reasonable belief that the provider has violated Medicaid or health care false claims laws. A summary suspension can apply to pending or future claims or can bar the provider from participating in the program. A hearing is not required before the suspension takes effect. If the provider requests a hearing, MCL 400.111f requires the hearing to begin within 15 days of the suspension, so providers must act quickly.

Payment Suspensions Based on Credible Allegations of Fraud

Under 42 CFR 455.23, MDHHS must suspend payments after determining that a credible allegation of fraud exists, unless good cause exists not to suspend or to suspend only in part. Suspensions may be imposed without prior notice, and the state must refer the matter to the Medicaid Fraud Control Unit, which in Michigan is part of the Department of Attorney General's Health Care Fraud Division. Referrals can originate from managed care plans, from OIG audits and data analysis, or from complaints.

What Hearings Have Decided

Published MOAHR decisions show how summary suspension hearings are typically framed. In one 2022 decision, the issue was whether the Department properly issued the order of summary suspension, the hearing applied a standard of competent, material, and substantial evidence on the whole record, and the administrative law judge described the Department's burden of showing a credible allegation of fraud and the need for emergency action as a low burden. The judge upheld the suspension after finding that the audit evidence, including prescribers denying that they wrote prescriptions, supported a reasonable belief of fraud. Other decisions describe referrals from managed care plans reviewed by OIG committees before suspension.

These decisions suggest that providers contesting a summary suspension should focus on directly undermining the factual basis for the allegation and on presenting organized, credible evidence quickly, rather than on general claims of compliance.

Responding to an MDHHS OIG Audit

Respond to the Records Request on Time

Gather complete records for every claim listed, including notes, orders, plans of care, signatures, and supporting documentation. Use an approved submission method and keep proof of delivery. If more time is needed, submit a written extension request before the deadline.

Analyze the Draft Findings Report

Compare each finding with the record and the Medicaid Provider Manual in effect on the date of service. Identify findings based on missing pages, misread documentation, or misapplied policy.

Submit a Complete Rebuttal Within 30 Days

Organize the rebuttal by claim, include all supporting documentation, and explain clearly why each finding is wrong. Challenge sampling and extrapolation methodology if used.

Decide Whether to Appeal the Final Notice

Within 30 days of the Final Notice of Recovery, decide whether to agree and repay or to request an internal conference or administrative hearing. File a complete, timely request with all required items.

Prepare for the Hearing

Build a claim-by-claim exhibit set, identify witnesses, retain experts when needed, and research the applicable policy. Because the hearing record will matter on any further review, present all evidence at the hearing.

Managed Care Audits

Michigan's Medicaid Health Plans and Prepaid Inpatient Health Plans conduct their own audits and investigations and refer suspected fraud to MDHHS OIG. Because the OIG's published audit process applies to fee-for-service claims, managed care audits follow each plan's procedures and contract terms, with their own deadlines and dispute processes. Providers should track every plan audit, keep responses consistent, and recognize that plan referrals can lead to OIG action, including payment suspensions.

Self-Review and Overpayment Obligations

Federal law requires providers to report and return identified Medicaid overpayments, generally within 60 days of identification, under section 1128J(d) of the Social Security Act. Providers that identify problems through internal audits should work with counsel to quantify and return overpayments and to evaluate whether a disclosure to MDHHS OIG is appropriate. Voluntary correction demonstrates good faith and reduces exposure to penalties and false claims liability under the Michigan Medicaid False Claim Act and federal law.

Building Audit Readiness in Michigan

• Maintain complete, legible records for at least seven years from the date of service.

• Know the Medicaid Provider Manual chapters that apply to your services.

• Conduct periodic internal audits and track error rates.

• Monitor billing patterns compared with peers, since providers may be selected based on comparisons with peers.

• Keep your CHAMPS correspondence address current so record requests and notices reach you.

• Screen owners, staff, and contractors against exclusion lists.

• Develop a written audit response plan with responsibility for each 30-day deadline.

Common Mistakes

• Missing the 30-day records deadline, which can lead directly to a Final Notice of Recovery.

• Failing to rebut the Draft Findings Report, which makes findings final.

• Submitting an incomplete internal conference or hearing request.

• Missing the 30-day appeal deadline after a Final Notice of Recovery.

• Failing to request a prompt hearing after a summary suspension.

• Treating managed care audits as unrelated to OIG oversight.

Preparing a Strong Rebuttal

Because the rebuttal is often the provider's best opportunity to reduce findings before they become final, it deserves careful preparation. A strong rebuttal:

• Addresses every finding individually, identifying the claim, the finding, and the provider's response.

• Attaches the specific documentation that supports each service, with page references.

• Cites the Medicaid Provider Manual provisions in effect on the date of service.

• Explains any differences between the auditor's interpretation of policy and the provider's.

• Identifies claims where the provider agrees with the finding, which builds credibility.

• Challenges sampling and extrapolation methodology, if used, with supporting analysis.

• Is delivered by a trackable method before the 30-day deadline.

Documentation submitted should be authentic and created at the time of service. Records created after the fact to fill gaps can undermine the entire response and create legal risk.

Coordinating Communications

Providers should designate a single point of contact for each audit, usually a compliance officer or counsel, who receives requests, tracks deadlines, and approves outgoing correspondence. All communications should be documented, and important conversations should be confirmed in writing. A log of every document produced, including the date and method of delivery, protects the provider if questions later arise about whether records were submitted on time.

Corrective Action After an Audit

Whether or not a provider appeals, audit findings point to processes that need attention. A practical corrective action plan identifies the root cause of each type of finding, assigns responsibility, sets deadlines, includes staff training, and adds follow-up monitoring. If the findings suggest that similar problems affected claims outside the audit sample or period, providers should evaluate their obligation to quantify and return additional overpayments. Documented corrective action also demonstrates good faith to MDHHS OIG and to managed care plans in future reviews.

Responding to a Summary Suspension

A summary suspension requires immediate action. Within the first days, providers should engage counsel, request a hearing promptly so that it can begin within the statutory timeframe, issue a litigation hold to preserve all records, and assemble evidence that directly addresses the allegations, such as documentation that services were provided, prescriber or referral confirmations, and staff records. Providers should also evaluate the operational effects, including payroll, beneficiary transitions, and communications with managed care plans, and coordinate any contact with the Department of Attorney General through counsel. Because the hearing standard focuses on whether the Department had a reasonable basis for emergency action, evidence should be organized to show that the specific facts behind the allegation are wrong or incomplete.

Balancing Cooperation and Advocacy

Cooperating fully with MDHHS OIG and contesting its findings are not in conflict. Providers can produce records promptly and answer questions professionally while still using the rebuttal, internal conference, and hearing processes to challenge findings they believe are wrong. Respectful, timely, and well-documented advocacy protects the provider's rights and creates a clear record for any later review.

Myths About MDHHS OIG Audits

Myth: Findings Are Not Final Until the Provider Agrees

If no rebuttal is submitted within 30 days, preliminary findings become final, and a Final Notice of Recovery is issued.

Myth: Recoupment Starts Even if a Timely Appeal Is Filed

According to the OIG's FAQ, if a timely appeal is filed, no recovery occurs until the appeal is resolved.

Myth: Summary Suspensions Require a Prior Hearing

MCL 400.111f does not require a hearing before an emergency suspension, though a requested hearing must begin promptly.

Myth: Extensions Are Automatic

Extension requests must be in writing and submitted before the deadline, and they are granted at the OIG's sole discretion.

Questions Leadership Should Ask

• Can we produce complete records for up to 150 claims within 30 days?

• Who tracks every 30-day deadline in the audit process?

• Are we retaining records for at least seven years from the date of service?

• Would we choose an internal conference or a hearing for a disputed finding?

• Are we prepared to respond within days to a summary suspension?

• Do we monitor managed care plan audits and referrals?

Key Takeaways

• MDHHS OIG conducts complex and automated post-payment audits of fee-for-service Medicaid claims and may use sampling and extrapolation.

• Providers generally have 30 days to respond to records requests, 30 days to rebut Draft Findings Reports, and 30 days to repay or appeal a Final Notice of Recovery.

• Appeals may be pursued through an internal conference or an administrative hearing before MOAHR, each requiring a timely, complete written request.

• Summary suspensions under MCL 400.111f and payment suspensions under 42 CFR 455.23 can be imposed without prior notice, and requested hearings on summary suspensions must begin within 15 days.

• Complete records, timely rebuttals, careful appeal requests, and strong documentation practices are the core of an effective Michigan audit response.

How HealthBridge Can Help

HealthBridge helps Michigan Medicaid providers prepare for and respond to MDHHS OIG audits. Our team can organize record production, analyze Draft Findings Reports claim by claim, prepare complete rebuttals, and review sampling and extrapolation methodology. We help providers prepare internal conference and administrative hearing requests that include every required item, and we support counsel in hearings and summary suspension matters. We also help providers build documentation, internal audit, and overpayment processes that reduce risk. If your organization is facing an MDHHS OIG audit or wants to be prepared, please get in touch with us. We will be happy to help you with this topic.

References

• Michigan Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General. Post Payment Audit Process and FAQ. https://www.michigan.gov/documents/mdhhs/Audit_Process_and_FAQ-final_630178_7.pdf

• Michigan Department of Health and Human Services. Numbered Letter L 18-41, Post-Payment Reviews by the Office of Inspector General. https://www.michigan.gov/documents/mdhhs/L_18-41_629987_7.pdf

• Michigan Department of Health and Human Services. Medicaid Provider Manual. https://www.michigan.gov/medicaidproviders

• Michigan Department of Health and Human Services. Record Keeping Reminder (November 5, 2026). https://www.michigan.gov/mdhhs/assistance-programs/medicaid/portalhome/medicaid-providers/medicaid-provider-alerts/all-alerts-and-updates/november-5-2026-record-keeping-reminder

• Michigan Department of Health and Human Services. Office of Inspector General FY 2021 Annual Report. https://www.michigan.gov/-/media/Project/Websites/mdhhs/Folder1/Folder101/FY-2021-OIG-Annual-Report---Final.pdf

• Michigan Legislature. MCL 400.111a. https://www.legislature.mi.gov/documents/mcl/pdf/mcl-400-111a.pdf

• Michigan Legislature. MCL 400.111b. https://renderpdf.legislature.mi.gov/documents/mcl/pdf/MCL-400-111B.pdf

• Michigan Legislature. MCL 400.111e. https://zeus-milenia.legislature.mi.gov/documents/mcl/pdf/MCL-400-111E.pdf

• Michigan Legislature. MCL 400.111f. https://ombudsman.legislature.mi.gov/documents/mcl/pdf/MCL-400-111F.pdf

• Michigan Office of Administrative Hearings and Rules. Decision in Docket Nos. 22-001070 and 22-001071 (2022). https://gsaindexed.apps.lara.state.mi.us/MOAHR/2022/22-001070,%2022-001071.pdf

• Michigan Office of Administrative Hearings and Rules. Decision in Docket Nos. 21-005139 and 21-005141 (2021). https://gsaindexed.apps.lara.state.mi.us/MOAHR/2021/21-005139,%2021-005141.pdf

• Michigan Office of the Auditor General. Follow-Up Report, Medicaid Home Help Program (November 2024). https://audgen.michigan.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/r391070819F-187901.pdf

• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 455.23, Suspension of payments in cases of fraud. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-C/part-455/subpart-A/section-455.23

• U.S. Code. 42 U.S.C. 1320a-7k(d), Reporting and returning of overpayments. https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid:USC-prelim-title42-section1320a-7k

Some or all of the services described herein may not be permissible for HealthBridge US clients and their affiliates or related entities.

The information provided is general in nature and is not intended to address the specific circumstances of any individual or entity. While we strive to offer accurate and timely information, we cannot guarantee that such information remains accurate after it is received or that it will continue to be accurate over time. Anyone seeking to act on such information should first seek professional advice tailored to their specific situation. HealthBridge US does not offer legal services.

HealthBridge US is not affiliated with any department of public health agencies in any state, nor with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). We offer healthcare consulting services exclusively and are an independent consulting firm not affiliated with any regulatory organizations, including but not limited to the Accrediting Organizations, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), and state departments. HealthBridge is an anti-fraud company in full compliance with all applicable federal and state regulations for CMS, as well as other relevant business and healthcare laws. The badges, icons, and achievement graphics displayed on this website represent proprietary performance metrics, volume milestones, and internal corporate recognition issued exclusively by our corporate affiliate network at SummitRidge. These visual markers are utilized solely as historical indicators of enterprise growth, operational longevity, and volume-based milestones cleared within our shared corporate ecosystem.

© 2026 HealthBridge US, a California corporation. All rights reserved.

For more information about the structure of HealthBridge, visit www.myhbconsulting.com/governance

Legal

Resources