New Jersey Medicaid Audit Response: Provider Integrity Reviews and Overpayment Appeals

How the New Jersey Office of the State Comptroller's Medicaid Fraud Division audits providers, issues overpayment notices and Notices of Claim, withholds payments, and how providers can respond and request hearings within the 20-day deadline.

KNOWLEDGE CENTER

11/15/202612 min read

New Jersey's Medicaid and CHIP program, NJ FamilyCare, is administered by the Division of Medical Assistance and Health Services (DMAHS) within the Department of Human Services. Most beneficiaries receive services through managed care organizations, while some services remain fee-for-service. Program integrity oversight, however, sits largely outside DMAHS. The Office of the State Comptroller (OSC), through its Medicaid Fraud Division (MFD), is charged with implementing the Medicaid Program Integrity and Protection Act, N.J.S.A. 30:4D-53 et seq., and conducts audits, investigations, data-driven reviews, and recoveries involving Medicaid providers.

MFD's work produces several kinds of documents that providers need to understand: records requests, summaries of findings, draft and final audit reports, notices of overpayment, Notices of Claim with Certificates of Debt, and notices of payment withholding. Each carries its own deadlines and options. Some offer an opportunity to submit documentation within 30 days or less; others trigger the 20-day deadline under N.J.A.C. 10:49-10.3 to request a hearing before the Office of Administrative Law (OAL).

This article explains how MFD audits and reviews work, the documents providers may receive, payment withholding, the hearing process, and practical strategies for responding. It is educational and not legal advice. Providers facing MFD audits, claims, or withholds should consult experienced New Jersey healthcare counsel.

The Legal Framework

Key authorities include:

• N.J.S.A. 52:15C-23 and the Medicaid Program Integrity and Protection Act, N.J.S.A. 30:4D-53 et seq., which authorize OSC's Medicaid program integrity work.

• The New Jersey Medical Assistance and Health Services Act, N.J.S.A. 30:4D-1 et seq., including provisions on recovery of overpayments and penalties. MFD notices have cited N.J.S.A. 30:4D-7(h) for recovery and N.J.S.A. 30:4D-17(e) for treble damages in appropriate cases.

• N.J.A.C. 10:49, the Medicaid Administration Manual, which sets out provider obligations, recordkeeping, withholding, and hearing rights.

• Program-specific chapters of N.J.A.C. Title 10 for each provider type, such as N.J.A.C. 10:60 for home care services.

• Federal program integrity rules at 42 CFR Part 455, including 42 CFR 455.23 on payment suspensions.

Recordkeeping and Certification

N.J.A.C. 10:49-9.8 is the regulation most often cited in MFD findings. It requires providers to certify that the information furnished on each claim is true, accurate, and complete, and to maintain records that fully disclose the services provided. MFD has noted that under N.J.A.C. 10:49-9.8(b), providers must retain documentation for five years, and MFD's review periods often reach back five years for that reason.

How MFD Audits and Reviews Work

Types of Reviews

MFD conducts several kinds of reviews:

• Full audits of a provider's claims over a defined period, often using a statistically valid random sample and extrapolation.

• Data-driven reviews targeting specific billing patterns, such as services billed while beneficiaries were hospital inpatients, services overlapping with another provider of the same type, or services billed beyond authorized limits.

• Investigations of complaints and referrals, including referrals from managed care organizations.

Audit Methodology

MFD audit reports describe methodologies that typically include identifying the claims universe, selecting a statistically valid random sample, requesting and reviewing records for sampled claims, applying the regulations governing the service, and extrapolating the error rate to the universe. In a 2021 audit of a home care provider, for example, MFD reviewed a random sample of 118 personal care claims from a universe of roughly 296,000 claims, found 19 sampled claims that did not comply with regulations, and extrapolated an overpayment of about $2.38 million, stating with 90 percent confidence that the true overpayment fell within a stated range.

The Audit Sequence

MFD audit reports describe a typical sequence:

• A records request and fieldwork, which may include onsite visits.

• A Summary of Findings and an exit conference with the provider and, often, its counsel.

• An opportunity for the provider to submit comments and additional records.

• A Draft Audit Report, to which the provider may submit a formal written response.

• A Final Audit Report, which MFD may publish and which includes the provider's response and MFD's replies, recommended recovery, and recommendations such as a corrective action plan.

The provider's response to the Draft Audit Report matters. In the 2021 home care audit, MFD noted that the provider objected to the sampling methodology and findings but did not address recommendations, submit a corrective action plan, or state whether it would repay, and MFD characterized that silence as increasing risk to beneficiaries and Medicaid funds.

Notices of Overpayment

For targeted reviews, MFD often issues a Notice of Overpayment identifying improperly paid claims. These notices may give the provider a short window to respond. One notice gave the provider 30 days to submit a written explanation with supporting documents if it believed the claims were properly billed, and stated that if no response was received, MFD could issue a Notice of Claim, a Certificate of Debt, and a Notice of Withholding of future payments. Another notice stated that if payment was not received within ten business days, MFD would take further action. Published follow-ups show that MFD sometimes reduces the overpayment after reviewing provider documentation and information from managed care organizations.

Notice of Claim and Certificate of Debt

When an overpayment is not resolved, MFD may issue a Notice of Claim, often accompanied by a Certificate of Debt, formally seeking recovery. Notices of Claim have advised providers that they may request a pre-hearing conference with MFD or a formal hearing before the OAL, and that if a pre-hearing conference does not resolve the matter, the provider will have an additional opportunity to request a formal hearing.

Hearing Rights and Deadlines

The 20-Day Rule

Under N.J.A.C. 10:49-10.3, requests for a hearing must be made in writing within 20 days from the date of the notice of the agency action giving rise to the dispute. For claim denials or payment adjustments, the 20 days begins on the date shown on the Remittance Advice. Providers should treat the 20-day period as firm and confirm the deadline stated in each notice.

Pre-Hearing Conference

A pre-hearing conference with MFD can be an efficient way to resolve disputes over specific claims, documentation, or calculations. Providers should come prepared with organized documentation and a clear explanation of each disputed item. If the conference does not resolve the dispute, the provider can still pursue a formal hearing, according to the language used in MFD notices.

Office of Administrative Law

Formal hearings are conducted by administrative law judges at the OAL, an independent agency that hears contested cases for state agencies. The administrative law judge issues an initial decision, and the agency head then issues a final agency decision adopting, modifying, or rejecting it. Published appellate decisions show that MFD claims can be litigated over several years, that MFD may amend its claim during the proceedings, and that final agency decisions can be appealed to the Appellate Division of the Superior Court.

Payment Withholding

Grounds and Notice

Under N.J.A.C. 10:49-9.10, DMAHS may withhold payments to a provider in appropriate circumstances, including those involving credible allegations of fraud under federal rules. The Division must send notice of the withholding within five days of taking action.

Expedited Hearing

The withholding notice must set forth the provider's right to submit, within 20 days of receiving the notice, a request for an administrative hearing consistent with N.J.A.C. 10:49-10.3. Immediately upon receiving a request, the Division must ask the OAL to schedule the hearing on an expedited basis. Providers facing a withhold should request a hearing promptly and prepare to present evidence quickly.

Withholding to Collect Overpayments

MFD notices also describe withholding as a collection tool. If a provider does not respond to a notice of overpayment or pay a claim, MFD may issue a Notice of Withholding that holds back part of future claim payments until the debt is satisfied or a final adjudication occurs.

Common MFD Findings

Published MFD audit reports and notices reflect recurring findings across provider types:

• Documentation that does not fully disclose the services provided, in violation of N.J.A.C. 10:49-9.8.

• Services billed while beneficiaries were hospital inpatients.

• Services billed for the same day, service, and beneficiary as another provider of the same type, such as adult medical day care.

• Overlapping services billed by a single practitioner for different beneficiaries at the same time.

• Failure to follow CPT coding guidelines.

• Missing prior authorization or services beyond authorized periods.

• Missing proof of delivery for durable medical equipment.

• For home care, missing timesheets, timesheets that do not document services, aides with expired certifications, missed supervisory visits, and services before a plan of care was written.

Responding to an MFD Audit

Respond to Records Requests Completely

Produce complete records for every sampled claim, including clinical notes, timesheets, orders, plans of care, authorizations, and credentials. Keep copies and proof of delivery. Records that cannot be produced will generally be treated as unsupported.

Use the Exit Conference

The exit conference is an early opportunity to understand findings and correct misunderstandings. Bring knowledgeable staff and counsel, ask questions, and follow up promptly with additional documentation.

Respond Fully to the Draft Audit Report

The response to the Draft Audit Report becomes part of the Final Audit Report. A strong response addresses each finding with documentation, challenges sampling and extrapolation methodology with supporting analysis, and addresses MFD's recommendations, including a corrective action plan. Because Final Audit Reports may be published, providers should write responses with that audience in mind.

Challenge Sampling and Extrapolation

Request the sampling plan, universe definition, sample selection method, and calculations. Consider retaining a statistician to review whether the sample was valid, whether the universe was properly defined, and whether the confidence interval and point estimate were calculated correctly. Providers have contested extrapolated findings in formal responses, and MFD addresses those arguments in its final reports.

Act Within Each Deadline

Calendar every deadline: the response window in a Notice of Overpayment, the 20-day hearing deadline for a Notice of Claim or withholding notice, and any deadlines set at pre-hearing conferences. Missing a deadline can allow MFD to proceed to a Certificate of Debt and withholding.

Consider Settlement

Many MFD matters resolve through negotiated settlements or repayment agreements. Counsel can evaluate the strength of the findings, the cost of litigation, and the potential for treble damages or other penalties when advising on settlement.

Managed Care Considerations

Because most NJ FamilyCare beneficiaries are enrolled in managed care, many MFD reviews involve managed care encounter claims, and MFD coordinates with managed care organizations' special investigations units. MCOs also conduct their own audits and recoupments under their contracts. Providers should track MCO audits separately, keep responses consistent across MFD and each MCO, and recognize that MCO referrals can lead to MFD action.

Self-Disclosure and Overpayment Obligations

Federal law requires providers to report and return identified Medicaid overpayments, generally within 60 days of identification, under section 1128J(d) of the Social Security Act. OSC maintains a self-disclosure process for Medicaid providers that identify overpayments or potential violations. Self-disclosure can lead to more favorable treatment than an audit finding and reduces exposure to penalties and false claims liability. Providers should evaluate self-disclosure with counsel when internal reviews identify problems.

Building Audit Readiness in New Jersey

• Retain complete documentation for at least five years, consistent with N.J.A.C. 10:49-9.8(b).

• Know the program-specific chapter of N.J.A.C. Title 10 for your services.

• Run data checks for common MFD targets, such as billing during inpatient stays and overlapping services.

• Conduct internal audits using sampling and track error rates.

• Verify staff licenses and certifications before assigning work and monitor expiration dates.

• Keep enrollment and correspondence information current so notices reach you.

• Maintain a written audit and claim response plan with responsibility for each deadline.

Common Mistakes

• Ignoring a Notice of Overpayment, which can lead to a Notice of Claim and withholding.

• Missing the 20-day hearing deadline under N.J.A.C. 10:49-10.3.

• Responding to a Draft Audit Report without addressing recommendations or a corrective action plan.

• Failing to challenge sampling and extrapolation with expert support.

• Producing incomplete records.

• Overlooking managed care audits and referrals.

Preparing for an OAL Hearing

An OAL hearing is a formal evidentiary proceeding, and MFD claims can involve large extrapolated amounts and complex regulatory questions. Preparation typically includes:

• Organizing the record. Assemble the records request, summary of findings, draft and final audit reports, notices, all correspondence, and the documentation for each claim.

• Building a claim matrix. List each disputed claim, the finding, the regulation cited, the provider's position, and the supporting exhibits.

• Identifying witnesses. Clinicians, aides, supervisors, billing staff, and compliance personnel may need to explain how services were delivered and documented.

• Retaining experts. A statistician may be needed to challenge sampling and extrapolation, and a clinical expert to address medical necessity or service standards.

• Confirming the regulation in effect. Program chapters of N.J.A.C. Title 10 are amended periodically, and the version in effect on the date of service governs.

• Evaluating penalties. Where MFD seeks treble damages or other penalties, counsel should evaluate the legal basis and any mitigating circumstances.

Published appellate decisions show that MFD sometimes narrows or amends its claim during litigation, changing the regulations relied on or reducing the amount sought. Careful preparation can expose weaknesses in the claim and support negotiation.

Coordinating Communications

Designate a single point of contact, usually a compliance officer or counsel, to receive MFD requests, track deadlines, and approve outgoing correspondence. Keep a log of every document produced, including the date and delivery method. Confirm important conversations in writing. During onsite visits, a designated staff member should accompany auditors and note what was requested and reviewed.

Corrective Action Plans

MFD Final Audit Reports routinely recommend that providers submit corrective action plans. A credible plan identifies the root cause of each type of finding, assigns responsibility, sets deadlines, includes staff training, and adds monitoring through follow-up internal audits. For example, if findings involved expired aide certifications, the plan should describe how the provider will verify credentials before assigning work and track expiration dates. Submitting a well-designed plan demonstrates good faith and can influence how MFD characterizes the provider in its final report.

Balancing Cooperation and Advocacy

Providers can cooperate fully with MFD, producing records promptly and accommodating onsite visits, while still contesting findings they believe are wrong. Professional, documented, and timely advocacy is a normal part of the process. Because Final Audit Reports may be published with the provider's response, a measured, factual tone serves the provider well. Providers that combine cooperation with organized evidence and a credible corrective action plan are often better positioned to negotiate reasonable resolutions, such as reduced claims or repayment agreements, and to avoid escalation to a Notice of Claim, a Certificate of Debt, or withholding of future payments.

Understanding Treble Damages and Penalties

MFD Notices of Claim have cited N.J.S.A. 30:4D-17(e) in assessing treble damages in certain cases, in addition to recovery of the overpayment itself. Providers facing penalty assessments should ask counsel to evaluate the statutory basis, whether the conduct alleged meets the applicable standard, and whether mitigating facts support a reduced amount in settlement. Penalty exposure is also a key factor in deciding whether to litigate or resolve a claim early.

Myths About MFD Audits

Myth: A Notice of Overpayment Is Final

MFD notices often provide an opportunity to submit documentation, and MFD has reduced overpayments after reviewing provider responses.

Myth: Providers Have Months to Request a Hearing

Hearing requests must generally be made in writing within 20 days of the notice of agency action.

Myth: Final Audit Reports Are Confidential

MFD may publish Final Audit Reports, including the provider's response.

Myth: Withholding Cannot Begin Until a Hearing Is Held

DMAHS may withhold payments and must send notice within five days, with an expedited hearing available on request.

Questions Leadership Should Ask

• Can we produce complete records for any claim within the past five years?

• Do we run checks for inpatient overlaps and duplicate services?

• Who tracks the 20-day hearing deadline and other MFD deadlines?

• Would our response to a Draft Audit Report include a credible corrective action plan?

• Do we have access to a statistician if MFD extrapolates?

• Have we identified any overpayments that should be self-disclosed?

Key Takeaways

• OSC's Medicaid Fraud Division audits and reviews New Jersey Medicaid providers under the Medicaid Program Integrity and Protection Act, often using sampling and extrapolation.

• N.J.A.C. 10:49-9.8 requires true, accurate, and complete claims and records that fully disclose services, with documentation retained for five years.

• MFD may issue Notices of Overpayment, Draft and Final Audit Reports, Notices of Claim with Certificates of Debt, and Notices of Withholding.

• Hearing requests are generally due in writing within 20 days of the notice, and withholding notices carry a right to an expedited OAL hearing.

• Complete record production, strong responses to draft reports, methodology challenges, and corrective action plans are central to an effective response.

How HealthBridge Can Help

HealthBridge helps New Jersey Medicaid providers prepare for and respond to Medicaid Fraud Division audits and reviews. Our team can organize record production, analyze summaries of findings and draft audit reports claim by claim, review sampling and extrapolation, and prepare responses that address findings and recommendations, including corrective action plans. We support counsel in pre-hearing conferences and OAL hearings, and we help providers run internal data checks for common MFD targets. If your organization is facing an MFD audit, overpayment notice, or withholding, or wants to strengthen its readiness, please get in touch with us. We will be happy to help you with this topic.

References

• New Jersey Office of the State Comptroller. Audit of Heart to Heart Healthcare Services, LLC, Medicaid Billing Practices (September 16, 2021). https://www.nj.gov/comptroller/reports/2021/20210916.shtml

• New Jersey Office of the State Comptroller. An Audit of Sokkyun Yi, An Intensive In-Community Mental Health Provider (August 24, 2023). https://nj.gov/comptroller/reports/2023/20230824.shtml

• New Jersey Office of the State Comptroller. Audit Report (October 31, 2023). https://nj.gov/comptroller/reports/2023/approved/20231031.shtml

• New Jersey Office of the State Comptroller. Notice of Overpayment, Full Circle Health Services. https://www.nj.gov/comptroller/news/docs/full_circle_letter.pdf

• New Jersey Office of the State Comptroller. Medical Day Care Overpayment Notice. https://www.nj.gov/comptroller/news/docs/medical_daycare_overpayment_notice.pdf

• New Jersey Office of the State Comptroller. Notice of Claim, Gentle Dental Group. https://nj.gov/comptroller/news/docs/notices_of_%20Claim_gentle_dental.pdf

• New Jersey Office of the State Comptroller. Sunrise Clinical Laboratories Final Audit Report, Appendix B. https://www.nj.gov/comptroller/library/reports/Sunrise/Sunrise_FAR_Appendix_B.pdf

• New Jersey Department of Human Services, Division of Medical Assistance and Health Services. Medicaid Communication No. 26-06, Operational Changes to Fair Hearing Process (June 23, 2026). https://www.nj.gov/humanservices/dmahs/documents/providers-stakeholders/resources/medicaid/2026/26-06_Operational_Changes_to_Fair_Hearing_Process.pdf

• New Jersey Courts. Mercer County Children's Medical Daycare, LLC v. Division of Medical Assistance and Health Services, No. A-3804-16 (App. Div. 2019). https://njcourts.gov/system/files/court-opinions/2019/a3804-16.pdf

• New Jersey Courts. Opinion No. A-4560-15 (App. Div. 2017). https://njcourts.gov/system/files/court-opinions/2017/a4560-15.pdf

• New Jersey State Library. N.J.A.C. 10:49, Administration Manual. https://dspace.njstatelib.org/bitstreams/502c6b59-7aa6-4768-bc77-c2c00b7a67f9/download

• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 455.23, Suspension of payments in cases of fraud. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-C/part-455/subpart-A/section-455.23

• U.S. Code. 42 U.S.C. 1320a-7k(d), Reporting and returning of overpayments. https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid:USC-prelim-title42-section1320a-7k

Some or all of the services described herein may not be permissible for HealthBridge US clients and their affiliates or related entities.

The information provided is general in nature and is not intended to address the specific circumstances of any individual or entity. While we strive to offer accurate and timely information, we cannot guarantee that such information remains accurate after it is received or that it will continue to be accurate over time. Anyone seeking to act on such information should first seek professional advice tailored to their specific situation. HealthBridge US does not offer legal services.

HealthBridge US is not affiliated with any department of public health agencies in any state, nor with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). We offer healthcare consulting services exclusively and are an independent consulting firm not affiliated with any regulatory organizations, including but not limited to the Accrediting Organizations, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), and state departments. HealthBridge is an anti-fraud company in full compliance with all applicable federal and state regulations for CMS, as well as other relevant business and healthcare laws. The badges, icons, and achievement graphics displayed on this website represent proprietary performance metrics, volume milestones, and internal corporate recognition issued exclusively by our corporate affiliate network at SummitRidge. These visual markers are utilized solely as historical indicators of enterprise growth, operational longevity, and volume-based milestones cleared within our shared corporate ecosystem.

© 2026 HealthBridge US, a California corporation. All rights reserved.

For more information about the structure of HealthBridge, visit www.myhbconsulting.com/governance

Legal

Resources