New York Medicaid OMIG Audit Response: Compliance Review Strategies for Providers

How New York's Office of the Medicaid Inspector General conducts audits and compliance program reviews, the Part 517 and Part 519 deadlines providers must meet, and strategies for responding effectively.

KNOWLEDGE CENTER

11/15/202612 min read

New York operates one of the largest and most complex Medicaid programs in the country, and its Office of the Medicaid Inspector General (OMIG) is one of the most active state program integrity agencies. OMIG conducts fiscal audits, compliance program reviews, investigations, and data analytics across fee-for-service Medicaid and managed care, and it publishes annual work plans that describe its priorities. In 2026, OMIG released a work plan that observers described as signaling an aggressive year of oversight, audits, and data-driven program integrity efforts.

New York's audit rules are set out in regulation, primarily in Title 18 of the New York Codes, Rules and Regulations (NYCRR). Part 517 governs provider audits, Part 518 governs recovery and withholding of payments, Part 519 governs provider hearings, and Part 521 governs compliance programs. These rules impose firm deadlines and place significant burdens on providers. A provider must object to a draft audit report within 30 days, generally must request a hearing within 60 days of a final determination, and at hearing bears the burden of showing that the agency's determination was incorrect. Issues not raised in objections to the draft audit report generally cannot be raised at hearing.

This article explains OMIG's audit and compliance review processes, the key regulatory requirements and deadlines, and strategies for responding effectively. It is educational and not legal advice. Providers facing OMIG audits, withholds, or investigations should consult experienced New York healthcare counsel.

OMIG's Role and Tools

OMIG is responsible for promoting and protecting the integrity of New York's Medicaid program. Its tools include:

• Fiscal audits and reviews of providers' claims, books, records, and reports under 18 NYCRR Part 517.

• Compliance program reviews under 18 NYCRR Part 521.

• Investigations of suspected fraud, waste, and abuse.

• Payment withholds and recoveries under Part 518.

• Sanctions, including exclusion from the program, under Part 515.

• Referrals to the New York Medicaid Fraud Control Unit.

• Audit protocols published for specific provider types.

• Annual work plans describing planned initiatives.

OMIG publishes audit protocols for many categories of service, such as opioid treatment programs, substance use disorder outpatient programs, mental health outpatient treatment and rehabilitative services, and continuing day treatment, and updates them periodically. Protocols describe the requirements auditors test and are among the most valuable preparation tools available to providers.

The Part 517 Audit Process

Audit Stages

OMIG has described its audit process as proceeding through an initial call to the provider, an audit notification letter, a call to schedule an entrance conference, the entrance conference, fieldwork, a pre-exit conference, an exit conference, a draft report, and a final report.

Look-Back Period

Provider records and claims for payment are generally subject to audit for six years under New York's recordkeeping and audit rules.

Entrance Conference

The entrance conference sets the scope, period, and logistics of the audit. Providers should confirm what will be reviewed, how records will be requested, and who the contacts are.

Fieldwork

During fieldwork, auditors review records and may interview staff. Providers should produce complete records promptly, keep copies, and track what was produced.

Exit Conference

At the exit conference, auditors present preliminary findings. This is an important opportunity to correct factual errors and supply missing documentation before the draft report.

Draft Audit Report

Under 18 NYCRR 517.5, the draft audit report must contain a clear statement of the action to be taken and must afford the provider the opportunity to object to the proposed action within 30 days of receipt. Receipt is presumed, absent evidence to the contrary, to be five days after the date on the draft report. The draft report must advise the provider that failure to object may result in the findings becoming final.

Final Audit Report

Under 18 NYCRR 517.6, after receipt of the provider's objections, or at any time after 40 days from mailing of the draft audit report without objections, OMIG may issue a final audit report. In preparing the final report, OMIG must consider the objections, supporting documents, the draft report, and any additional material that becomes available. The final report must advise the provider of the right to appeal the audit findings and the procedures for requesting an administrative hearing, and must state the effective date of the intended action, which is not less than 20 days from the date of the report.

Positive Results

When an audit identifies no findings requiring action, OMIG issues an Audit Summation Letter advising the provider that, under 18 NYCRR 517.3(h), the audit is concluded and no further action is required.

Why the Draft Report Response Matters Most

New York's hearing rules make the draft audit report response the most important document a provider submits. Under 18 NYCRR 519.18(a), an appellant may not raise at a hearing any new matter not considered by OMIG upon submission of objections to the draft audit report. Courts have upheld this rule. As a result, a provider that fails to raise an issue, or fails to submit supporting documentation, in its draft report objections may be barred from raising it later.

An effective draft audit report response:

• Is submitted within 30 days of receipt.

• Addresses every disputed finding specifically.

• Includes all supporting documentation.

• Challenges the sampling methodology and extrapolation, if applicable, with expert analysis where possible.

• Preserves every legal and factual argument the provider may want to make at hearing.

• Explains corrective actions taken.

Hearings Under Part 519

Requesting a Hearing

Under 18 NYCRR 519.7(a), a provider's request for a hearing must be made within 60 days of the date of the department's written determination. Hearing decisions have denied hearings when requests were received after the 60-day period, so timeliness is critical.

Burden of Proof

At hearing, the provider bears the burden of showing that the determination of the department was incorrect and that all claims submitted and denied were due and payable under the Medicaid program, under 18 NYCRR 518.1(c) and 519.18(d).

Extrapolation

Under 18 NYCRR 519.18(g), an extrapolation based upon an audit using a statistical sampling method certified as valid will be presumed, in the absence of expert testimony and evidence to the contrary, to be an accurate determination of the total overpayments made or penalty to be imposed. The provider may submit expert testimony challenging the extrapolation or an actual accounting of all claims paid in rebuttal. Providers facing extrapolated findings should retain a statistical expert early, ideally before the draft audit report response.

Decision Without a Hearing

OMIG may request a decision without a hearing in certain circumstances, and providers must respond within the timeframes set in 18 NYCRR 519.23.

Payment Withholds and Recovery

Under 18 NYCRR Part 518, OMIG may recover overpayments and withhold payments. Withholds may be imposed in cases of suspected fraud or abuse, consistent with federal requirements at 42 CFR 455.23, and to recover determined overpayments. Providers subject to withholds should review the notice carefully, understand the basis and duration, and use available rights to submit information and seek review.

Compliance Program Requirements and Reviews

Who Must Have a Compliance Program

New York Social Services Law section 363-d and 18 NYCRR Part 521 require certain Medicaid providers to adopt and maintain an effective compliance program. Providers subject to the requirement generally include those licensed under certain articles of the Public Health Law and Mental Hygiene Law, and other providers that meet a Medicaid billing threshold. OMIG revised Part 521 in recent years to update program requirements and expand provisions related to managed care organizations.

Required Elements

Compliance programs must include the elements specified in Part 521, which generally address written policies and procedures, a designated compliance officer and compliance committee, training and education, effective lines of communication including anonymous reporting, disciplinary standards, auditing and monitoring, responding to compliance issues, and policies prohibiting intimidation and retaliation. Providers must also maintain processes to identify, report, and return Medicaid overpayments within 60 days, consistent with Social Services Law section 363-d and federal law.

Compliance Program Reviews

Under 18 NYCRR 521-1.5, OMIG conducts compliance program reviews and gives providers notice of its intent to commence a review, generally with 30 days to respond, which OMIG may extend for good cause. OMIG may also separately review a managed care organization's compliance program. Providers have reported that compliance program reviews initiated after July 1, 2025 use a 12-month review period rather than the previous three-month period, and that OMIG expected to complete approximately 200 compliance reviews in 2026.

Preparing for a Compliance Program Review

• Maintain written documentation of each required element, including policies, committee minutes, training records, audit plans and results, investigation logs, and corrective actions.

• Show that the compliance program operates in practice, not just on paper, through evidence of audits performed, issues identified, and corrections made.

• Document the annual compliance program effectiveness review.

• Track overpayment identification and return.

• Make sure the board or governing body receives regular compliance reports.

• Keep evidence of exclusion screening of employees, contractors, and vendors.

Self-Disclosure

OMIG operates a self-disclosure program for providers that identify overpayments. Self-disclosure allows providers to report and return overpayments, often with more favorable treatment than if OMIG discovers the issue in an audit. Providers should evaluate self-disclosure with counsel whenever internal audits identify overpayments, keeping in mind the 60-day obligation to report and return identified overpayments.

Using the OMIG Work Plan

OMIG's annual work plan provides a roadmap of its planned program integrity initiatives. The work plan is not an exhaustive list, but it indicates where OMIG intends to direct resources, such as particular provider types, services, billing issues, and managed care oversight. Providers should review the work plan each year, identify initiatives relevant to their services, and audit those areas proactively. OMIG has also reminded providers that they must report damaged, lost, or destroyed records.

Managed Care Considerations

Most New York Medicaid members are enrolled in managed care. Managed care organizations have their own compliance obligations under Part 521 and contracts, conduct audits and special investigations, and report to OMIG. OMIG also audits managed care encounter data and network providers. Providers should coordinate responses to plan and OMIG audits and understand how plan recoveries relate to OMIG findings.

Response Strategies

Prepare Before the Audit

Use OMIG's audit protocols to self-audit. Correct problems, return overpayments, and document corrective actions. Organize records so they can be produced quickly.

Manage Fieldwork Actively

Designate a coordinator, track requests, and produce complete records. Ask auditors to explain preliminary concerns during fieldwork so you can respond with documentation early.

Use the Exit Conference

Treat the exit conference as an opportunity to supply missing documents and correct misunderstandings.

Treat the Draft Report Response as the Main Event

Because new matters generally cannot be raised at hearing, include every argument and document in the draft report objections, submitted within 30 days.

Engage a Statistician Early

If extrapolation is used, obtain expert analysis before submitting draft report objections.

Calendar the Hearing Deadline

Calendar the 60-day hearing request deadline from the date of the final determination and file early.

Consider Settlement

Many OMIG audits are resolved through negotiated settlements or repayment agreements. Counsel can evaluate the merits and costs of settlement versus hearing.

Common Mistakes

• Missing the 30-day deadline for draft report objections.

• Submitting objections without complete documentation.

• Failing to raise extrapolation challenges at the draft report stage.

• Missing the 60-day hearing request deadline.

• Treating the compliance program as a paper exercise.

• Ignoring OMIG audit protocols and work plan priorities.

• Failing to report and return identified overpayments within 60 days.

Record Retention and Lost Records

New York providers must prepare and maintain contemporaneous records and retain them for at least six years from the date of service or payment, as required by OMIG and Department of Health regulations. OMIG's 2026 work plan reminded providers that they must report damaged, lost, or destroyed records. Providers should maintain secure, retrievable records, protect them against loss, and document any incidents that affect records. An audit is not the time to discover that records are missing.

Fiscal Audits of Rate-Based Providers

Many New York providers, such as nursing homes, clinics, and programs licensed by the Office of Mental Health, the Office of Addiction Services and Supports, and the Office for People With Developmental Disabilities, are paid through rates based on cost reports and program-specific requirements. OMIG audits these providers for compliance with rate-setting rules, cost reporting requirements, and program standards. Providers should understand the specific regulations governing their rates and services, maintain documentation for reported costs and statistics, and review OMIG's audit protocols for their program type.

Coordination With State Licensing Agencies

New York providers often operate under licenses or certifications from multiple state agencies, each with its own standards and surveys. OMIG audits frequently test compliance with program requirements set by these agencies, such as treatment planning, staffing, and documentation standards. Providers should align their compliance programs with both Medicaid billing requirements and licensing agency standards, and should respond to findings from any agency with an eye to how they may affect Medicaid audits.

Preparing Staff for OMIG Reviews

Staff who interact with auditors should understand the audit process, know where records are kept, and answer questions accurately. Leaders should remind staff never to alter records after an audit begins and to route questions about findings to the designated coordinator. Clinical leaders should be prepared to explain documentation practices and medical necessity decisions.

Managed Care Encounter Data and Network Provider Audits

OMIG's oversight increasingly focuses on managed care, including the accuracy of encounter data submitted by plans and the compliance of network providers. Providers paid by managed care plans may receive audit requests from OMIG, from the plan, or from both. Encounter data must accurately reflect services provided, and providers should make sure their claims to plans are coded correctly, because errors can surface in OMIG data analytics. Providers should also understand how plans handle recoveries identified by OMIG and coordinate to avoid duplicate recoupment.

Technology and Data Analytics

OMIG uses data analytics to identify billing patterns, outliers, and potential fraud, waste, and abuse. Providers can anticipate OMIG's questions by analyzing their own data, such as service volumes per patient, coding distributions, billing after a patient's death or during inpatient stays, and growth over time. Explaining and correcting unusual patterns before an audit reduces the risk of findings and demonstrates an active compliance program.

When an Audit Suggests Fraud

If an OMIG audit or investigation suggests possible fraud, the matter may be referred to the New York Medicaid Fraud Control Unit. Providers should involve counsel immediately, preserve records, avoid altering documentation, and coordinate all communications. Administrative responses to OMIG can affect criminal and civil proceedings, so strategy must account for both.

Early involvement of counsel also helps preserve privilege for internal reviews conducted in response to OMIG findings, and helps the provider decide whether self-disclosure or settlement is appropriate.

A brief internal memo summarizing each OMIG interaction, prepared at counsel's direction, can also help maintain a consistent record throughout the process.

Consistency is valuable throughout.

It matters greatly.

Myths About OMIG Audits

Myth: New Arguments Can Be Raised at Hearing

New matters not considered upon submission of objections to the draft audit report generally cannot be raised at hearing.

Myth: OMIG Must Prove the Overpayment at Hearing

The provider bears the burden of showing that the determination was incorrect and that all claims were due and payable.

Myth: Extrapolation Is Hard for OMIG to Defend

An extrapolation based on a certified valid sampling method is presumed accurate absent expert testimony and evidence to the contrary.

Myth: Compliance Programs Are Only Reviewed on Paper

OMIG reviews whether compliance programs are effective in practice, using a longer review period for reviews initiated after July 1, 2025.

Questions Leadership Should Ask

• Have we reviewed OMIG's current work plan and audit protocols for our services?

• Can we respond to a draft audit report with complete documentation within 30 days?

• Do we have access to a statistical expert if needed?

• Is our compliance program documented and operating effectively?

• Are we identifying, reporting, and returning overpayments within 60 days?

• Who tracks the 60-day hearing request deadline?

Key Takeaways

• OMIG audits providers under 18 NYCRR Part 517, with stages from notification through entrance conference, fieldwork, exit conference, draft report, and final report.

• Providers must object to a draft audit report within 30 days, and new matters not raised then generally cannot be raised at hearing.

• Hearing requests must be made within 60 days of the final determination, and providers bear the burden of proof.

• Extrapolations based on certified valid sampling are presumed accurate absent expert evidence to the contrary.

• Part 521 requires effective compliance programs, and OMIG conducts compliance program reviews with expanded review periods.

How HealthBridge Can Help

HealthBridge helps New York Medicaid providers prepare for and respond to OMIG audits and compliance program reviews. Our team can self-audit your services using OMIG's audit protocols and work plan priorities, organize records for fieldwork, analyze exit conference and draft audit findings claim by claim, and coordinate statistical review of sampling and extrapolation. We help providers prepare comprehensive draft report objections that preserve every issue, support counsel in hearings, and build Part 521 compliance programs that operate effectively in practice. If your organization wants to strengthen its OMIG audit readiness, please get in touch with us. We will be happy to help you with this topic.

References

• New York State Department of Health. 18 NYCRR 517.5, Draft audit report. https://regs.health.ny.gov/node/54131

• New York State Department of Health. 18 NYCRR 517.6, Final audit report. https://regs.health.ny.gov/node/53821

• New York State Office of the Medicaid Inspector General. Audit. https://omig.ny.gov/audit

• New York State Office of the Medicaid Inspector General. Audit Protocols. https://omig.ny.gov/audit/audit-protocols

• New York State Office of the Medicaid Inspector General. Positive Audit Reports. https://omig.ny.gov/audit/positive-audit-reports

• New York State Office of the Medicaid Inspector General. Work Plans. https://omig.ny.gov/information-resources/work-plans

• New York State Office of the Medicaid Inspector General. Compliance. https://omig.ny.gov/compliance

• New York State Office of the Medicaid Inspector General. Self-Disclosure. https://omig.ny.gov/provider-resources/self-disclosure

• New York State Department of Health. Medicaid provider hearing decision applying 18 NYCRR 519.7(a) timeliness (Grandell Rehabilitation and Nursing Center, 2018). https://health.ny.gov/health_care/medicaid/decisions/docs/grandell_rehab_and_nursing_ctr_12_19_2018.pdf

• New York State Department of Health. Medicaid provider hearing decision applying 18 NYCRR 519.18(g) extrapolation (Byram Hills Health Care Center, 2019). https://health.ny.gov/health_care/medicaid/decisions/docs/byram_hcc_f&a_signed_12-16-19.pdf

• New York State Department of Health. Medicaid provider hearing decision on burden of proof (Tatiana Gouskova, M.D., 2015). https://health.ny.gov/health_care/medicaid/decisions/docs/tatiana_gouskova_md_2015-12-09.pdf

• New York State Senate. Social Services Law section 363-d, Provider compliance program. https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/SOS/363-D

• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 455.23, Suspension of payments in cases of fraud. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-C/part-455/subpart-A/section-455.23

• U.S. Code. 42 U.S.C. 1320a-7k(d), Reporting and returning of overpayments. https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid:USC-prelim-title42-section1320a-7k

Some or all of the services described herein may not be permissible for HealthBridge US clients and their affiliates or related entities.

The information provided is general in nature and is not intended to address the specific circumstances of any individual or entity. While we strive to offer accurate and timely information, we cannot guarantee that such information remains accurate after it is received or that it will continue to be accurate over time. Anyone seeking to act on such information should first seek professional advice tailored to their specific situation. HealthBridge US does not offer legal services.

HealthBridge US is not affiliated with any department of public health agencies in any state, nor with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). We offer healthcare consulting services exclusively and are an independent consulting firm not affiliated with any regulatory organizations, including but not limited to the Accrediting Organizations, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), and state departments. HealthBridge is an anti-fraud company in full compliance with all applicable federal and state regulations for CMS, as well as other relevant business and healthcare laws. The badges, icons, and achievement graphics displayed on this website represent proprietary performance metrics, volume milestones, and internal corporate recognition issued exclusively by our corporate affiliate network at SummitRidge. These visual markers are utilized solely as historical indicators of enterprise growth, operational longevity, and volume-based milestones cleared within our shared corporate ecosystem.

© 2026 HealthBridge US, a California corporation. All rights reserved.

For more information about the structure of HealthBridge, visit www.myhbconsulting.com/governance

Legal

Resources