North Carolina Medicaid Audit Defense: Program Integrity Reviews and Credible Allegation of Fraud Holds
How NC Medicaid's Office of Compliance and Program Integrity audits providers under N.C.G.S. Chapter 108C, the rules for extrapolation and prepayment review, credible allegation of fraud payment holds, and the reconsideration and OAH appeal deadlines.
KNOWLEDGE CENTER
11/15/202612 min read
North Carolina Medicaid is administered by the North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services (NCDHHS) through NC Medicaid, the Division of Health Benefits. Since 2021, most beneficiaries have been enrolled in managed care through Standard Plans and, for people with significant behavioral health needs and intellectual and developmental disabilities, Tailored Plans. NC Medicaid's Office of Compliance and Program Integrity (OCPI) is responsible for identifying and investigating potential fraud, waste, and abuse, conducting provider audits and reviews, and pursuing recoveries, often working with contractors and the North Carolina Department of Justice's Medicaid Investigations Division, which serves as the state's Medicaid Fraud Control Unit.
North Carolina is unusual because many audit rules are written into statute. Chapter 108C of the North Carolina General Statutes sets out provider requirements, payment suspensions, limits on extrapolated audits, prepayment claims review, cooperation obligations, and appeal rights. These provisions give providers meaningful protections, but they also impose strict deadlines and, in some cases, place the burden of proof on the provider.
This article explains how NC Medicaid program integrity reviews work, the statutory limits on audits, credible allegation of fraud payment holds, prepayment review, and the reconsideration and Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) appeal process. It is educational and not legal advice. Providers facing NC Medicaid audits or payment holds should consult experienced North Carolina healthcare counsel.
The Legal Framework
Key provisions of Chapter 108C include:
• Section 108C-2, which defines an adverse determination as a final decision by the Department to deny, terminate, suspend, reduce, or recoup a Medicaid payment, or to deny, terminate, or suspend a provider's or applicant's participation.
• Section 108C-3, which assigns providers to risk categories for enrollment screening and moves providers subject to a credible allegation of fraud payment suspension in the prior 12 months into a higher risk category.
• Section 108C-5, which addresses payment suspensions and audits using extrapolation.
• Section 108C-7, which governs prepayment claims review.
• Section 108C-9, which requires attestation and training for new applicants, including training on audit procedures and extrapolation.
• Section 108C-11, which requires providers to cooperate with audits and investigations.
• Section 108C-12, which governs appeals of adverse determinations as contested cases under the Administrative Procedure Act, Chapter 150B.
Federal program integrity rules at 42 CFR Part 455, including 42 CFR 455.23, also apply.
Program Integrity Reviews
Cooperation Obligations
Under section 108C-11, providers must cooperate with announced and unannounced site visits, audits, investigations, and reviews. Providers that deny prompt access or fail to timely provide designated documentation may be terminated. The Department must try to review documents without interfering with clinical activities.
Types of Reviews
OCPI and its contractors conduct a variety of reviews, including post-payment record reviews, data-driven reviews of billing patterns, targeted reviews of specific services, and investigations of complaints. Section 108C-5 allows the Department to conduct unannounced or targeted audits and to use contractors to send notices. Under section 108C-5(r), the Department must publish annually on its website notice of planned extrapolation audits, including the services, provider types, audit elements, and periods.
Tentative Notices and Additional Documentation
Audit results are typically communicated through a tentative notice, such as a Tentative Notice of Overpayment. Under section 108C-5(p), the provider has at least 30 days from receiving tentative results to submit additional documentation not previously provided. Under section 108C-5(o), clerical, typographical, scrivener's, and computer errors may be corrected before the final determination. Providers should use this window to supply missing records and correct errors.
Statutory Limits on Extrapolated Audits
North Carolina imposes several conditions on audits that use extrapolation:
• Threshold showing. Under section 108C-5(i), before extrapolating audit results, the Department must show and inform the provider of either a finding of substantial noncompliance with law or a credible allegation of fraud.
• Qualified auditors. Under section 108C-5(j), extrapolated audits must be performed and reviewed by individuals credentialed in the relevant areas, such as coding or clinical issues.
• Defined scope. Under section 108C-5(k), before an extrapolated audit, the Department must identify the matters to be reviewed, such as medical necessity, coding, or authorization, and the time periods.
• Protection from repeat audits. Under section 108C-5(l), once those matters and periods are identified, the provider is not subject to further Department audits on them unless there is a credible allegation of fraud or a federal fraud action for the same period.
• Lookback limit. Under section 108C-5(q), extrapolated audits may cover up to 36 months from the date of payment, unless federal law or a fraud allegation requires otherwise.
Challenging an Extrapolated Error Rate
Under section 108C-5(n), providers in the limited or moderate risk categories may challenge extrapolated error rates. The provider must notify the Department within 15 days of receiving tentative results and choose a challenge method:
• Option 1. Conduct a 100 percent review of the files and submit results within 60 days of receiving the Department's notice.
• Option 2. Conduct a second audit on a Department-generated sample twice the size of the original. The Department must provide the sample within 30 days of the provider's request, and the provider has 60 days from receipt to complete the audit and report results.
Results are binding, although the Department may reject audits that do not comply with requirements. Providers may still challenge the accuracy of the audit, the methodology of the original sample, or the auditors' credentials. Because the 15-day notice window is short, providers should evaluate this option immediately upon receiving tentative extrapolated results.
Self-Audits
Under section 108C-5(m), the Department may set rules for voluntary self-audits and may reject any non-compliant self-audit. After the provider pays or agrees to pay the resulting amount, the same matters and periods are generally protected from further audit. Self-audits, done carefully with counsel, can resolve issues on more predictable terms.
Credible Allegation of Fraud Payment Holds
Authority
Under section 108C-5(a), the Department may suspend payments to a provider in accordance with the requirements and procedures in 42 CFR 455.23. Federal rules require the state to suspend all Medicaid payments after determining that a credible allegation of fraud exists, unless good cause exists not to suspend or to suspend only in part. Suspensions may be imposed without prior notice, and the state must refer the matter to the Medicaid Investigations Division.
Notice
Under 42 CFR 455.23, notice of the suspension must be sent within five days of taking action, unless law enforcement requests a delay, and must state that payments are being suspended in accordance with the regulation, describe the general allegations, state that the suspension is temporary and the circumstances under which it will end, specify affected claim types and business units where applicable, and inform the provider of its right to submit written evidence for consideration and of any applicable administrative appeal rights.
Consequences Beyond the Hold
A credible allegation of fraud hold has effects beyond cash flow. Under section 108C-3, a provider that was subject to a credible allegation of fraud payment suspension within the previous 12 months is placed in a higher risk category for enrollment screening, and the Department must return the provider to its original category no later than 12 months after the suspension ends. Managed care plans generally must suspend payments as well when the state does, under 42 CFR 438.608(a)(8).
Other Payment Suspensions
Section 108C-5 also authorizes other kinds of payment suspensions. The Department may suspend payments to a provider that owes a final overpayment, assessment, or fine without an approved payment plan, beginning on the 31st day after the debt becomes final and not exceeding the amount owed. It may suspend payments to affiliated providers sharing the same tax identification number or corporate parent, with 30 days advance written notice. Payment plans of up to 24 months may be approved. A debt is not final while it is being contested at the Department, at OAH, or in Superior Court when a stay has been entered.
Defense Strategies for Payment Holds
• Engage counsel immediately and issue a litigation hold.
• Read the notice carefully to understand the general allegations, scope, and appeal rights.
• Submit written evidence that directly addresses the allegations, including documentation that services were delivered and billed correctly.
• Develop good cause arguments, such as access to care for beneficiaries in underserved areas or for specialized services, and request a partial hold limited to the affected services or locations.
• Propose safeguards, such as prepayment review or independent monitoring, as an alternative to a full hold.
• Coordinate with each Standard Plan and Tailored Plan on how the hold is being applied.
• Coordinate administrative and criminal defense through counsel, since the Medicaid Investigations Division will be involved.
Prepayment Claims Review
Grounds and Notice
Under section 108C-7, grounds for prepayment review include credible allegations of fraud, aberrant billing practices identified through investigations or data analysis, failure to timely respond to document requests, and other grounds set by rule. Providers are not paid before review. The Department must send written notice by first-class mail before review begins, explaining the decision and process, describing the claims and documents required, and stating the standard for exiting review. Prior-authorized services are not reviewed for medical necessity during prepayment review.
Processing Timelines
Clean claims must be processed within 20 calendar days of receiving complete documentation. If documents are missing, the Department must send written notice within 15 calendar days after the document due date, and processing then has an additional 20 days after receipt of the documents.
Exiting Prepayment Review
Review continues until the provider achieves three consecutive months with at least an 80 percent clean claims rate, provided the provider's monthly claim volume is at least 50 percent of its average monthly volume for the three months before review began. Months with no claims count as zero percent. If the provider fails to meet the standard within six months of placement, the Department may impose sanctions, including termination of the Medicaid Administrative Participation Agreement, or may continue prepayment review. Failure to meet the standard may lead to termination and exclusion. Providers may not withhold claims to avoid review.
Limited Appeal Rights
Under section 108C-7(f), placement on or continuation of prepayment review is not a contested case, and providers cannot appeal it. If a provider appeals sanctions imposed as a result of prepayment review to OAH, it has 45 days from filing the appeal to submit documents addressing the review findings, and later submissions are not considered. To overturn a prior denial, the provider must prove that all required documentation was submitted with the claim and that the claim should not have been denied.
Succeeding on Prepayment Review
Because placement cannot be appealed, success depends on operations. Providers should assign a dedicated team, submit complete documentation with every claim, track the clean claims rate weekly, correct recurring errors immediately, and maintain normal claim volume to meet the 50 percent requirement.
Reconsideration and OAH Appeals
Reconsideration Review
NC Medicaid adverse determination letters typically offer a reconsideration review by the NCDHHS Hearing Office. Current appeal language for certain provider letters generated through NCTracks allows 30 business days from the date of the letter to request reconsideration, with supporting documentation received within the same period. Providers may request a telephone or in-person hearing, and the Hearing Office issues a written reconsideration decision. Deadlines for reconsideration of audit findings can differ by letter type and by rule, so providers should follow the deadline stated in their specific notice.
Contested Case at OAH
Under section 108C-12, appeals of adverse determinations are contested cases under Article 3 of Chapter 150B. Current NC Medicaid letter language states that a provider has 60 calendar days from the date of the letter or the date of the reconsideration decision to file a petition for a contested case hearing with OAH, and that the provider may file without first requesting reconsideration. A copy of the petition must also be served on the NCDHHS Office of Legal Affairs. Missing the deadline can forfeit the right to appeal.
Burden of Proof and Timing
Under section 108C-12(d), the petitioner bears the burden of proof. Under section 108C-12(c), OAH must issue a final decision within 180 days of filing, extended for delays caused or requested by the Department. Because the provider carries the burden, it must come to OAH with organized, persuasive evidence on every disputed claim.
Managed Care Audits
Standard Plans and Tailored Plans conduct their own program integrity activities, including audits, special investigations, overpayment recovery, and referrals to NC Medicaid. Under section 108C-7(e3), plans may also use prepayment review and, with Department approval, remove a non-compliant provider from their networks. Plan disputes follow plan processes and contract terms, and some may proceed to OAH after plan appeals are exhausted. Providers should track each plan's audits and deadlines separately.
Building Audit Readiness in North Carolina
• Monitor the Department's annual published notice of planned extrapolation audits.
• Maintain documentation that supports medical necessity, coding, and authorization for every service.
• Conduct internal audits on the elements most often reviewed and track error rates.
• Prepare to produce records promptly and accommodate unannounced site visits.
• Screen owners, staff, and contractors against exclusion lists.
• Report and return identified overpayments within 60 days under section 1128J(d) of the Social Security Act.
• Keep NCTracks enrollment information current so notices reach you.
Common Mistakes
• Missing the 15-day window to challenge an extrapolated error rate.
• Failing to submit additional documentation within the 30-day window after tentative results.
• Missing the reconsideration or 60-day OAH deadline.
• Arriving at OAH without evidence sufficient to carry the burden of proof.
• Treating prepayment review as appealable and neglecting the 80 percent clean claims standard.
• Withholding claims during prepayment review.
• Responding to a credible allegation of fraud hold without counsel.
Preparing for an OAH Contested Case
Because the provider bears the burden of proof, preparation for OAH should begin as soon as a tentative notice arrives. Organize documentation by claim and finding, identify fact witnesses such as clinicians and billing staff, and retain experts where needed, including statisticians for extrapolation disputes and clinical reviewers for medical necessity disputes. Confirm which NC Medicaid clinical coverage policies applied on each date of service. Many contested cases resolve through settlement, so counsel should evaluate settlement options alongside litigation.
Coordinating Communications
Designate one person, usually a compliance officer or counsel, to receive OCPI, contractor, and plan requests, track every statutory deadline, and approve outgoing correspondence. Keep a log of each document produced, including the date and delivery method, so the provider can prove timely cooperation under section 108C-11 if questions arise.
Balancing Cooperation and Advocacy
Full cooperation with OCPI is required by statute, but cooperation does not mean accepting every finding. Providers can produce records promptly and support site visits while still using the additional documentation window, extrapolation challenges, reconsideration, and OAH to contest findings they believe are wrong. Respectful, timely advocacy builds a clear record for any later review.
Myths About NC Medicaid Audits
Myth: Providers Can Appeal Placement on Prepayment Review
Placement on or continuation of prepayment review is not a contested case and cannot be appealed.
Myth: The Department Must Prove Its Case at OAH
The petitioner bears the burden of proof in Medicaid provider appeals.
Myth: Extrapolated Audits Have No Limits
Chapter 108C requires a showing of substantial noncompliance or a credible allegation of fraud, qualified auditors, a defined scope, a 36-month lookback in most cases, and protection from repeat audits.
Myth: Reconsideration Is Required Before Going to OAH
Current letter language states that providers may file with OAH without requesting reconsideration.
Questions Leadership Should Ask
• Who reviews tentative notices within days to decide on an extrapolation challenge?
• Can we produce complete records quickly and support an unannounced visit?
• Would we meet the 80 percent clean claims standard if placed on prepayment review?
• Are we prepared to respond to a credible allegation of fraud hold?
• Do we track every reconsideration and OAH deadline?
• Are we monitoring audits by each Standard Plan and Tailored Plan?
Key Takeaways
• NC Medicaid's Office of Compliance and Program Integrity audits providers under Chapter 108C, which imposes cooperation duties and sets detailed rules for audits and payment suspensions.
• Extrapolated audits require a threshold showing, qualified auditors, a defined scope, and generally a 36-month lookback, and eligible providers can challenge extrapolated error rates if they act within 15 days.
• Credible allegation of fraud holds follow 42 CFR 455.23, can begin without notice, and raise a provider's enrollment risk category for up to 12 months after they end.
• Prepayment review cannot be appealed and ends only after three consecutive months at an 80 percent clean claims rate, with sanctions possible after six months.
• Reconsideration and OAH contested case deadlines are short, and the provider bears the burden of proof at OAH.
How HealthBridge Can Help
HealthBridge helps North Carolina Medicaid providers prepare for and respond to program integrity reviews and payment holds. Our team can analyze tentative notices, evaluate extrapolation challenge options under section 108C-5, organize additional documentation submissions, and support counsel in reconsideration and OAH proceedings. For providers on prepayment review, we help build claim submission processes that track and improve the clean claims rate. For credible allegation of fraud holds, we help assemble evidence, good cause arguments, and corrective action proposals. If your organization is facing an NC Medicaid audit or wants to strengthen its readiness, please get in touch with us. We will be happy to help you with this topic.
References
• North Carolina General Assembly. N.C.G.S. Chapter 108C, Medicaid Provider Requirements. https://ncleg.gov/EnactedLegislation/Statutes/HTML/ByChapter/Chapter_108C.html
• North Carolina General Assembly. N.C.G.S. 108C-5, Payment suspension and audits utilizing extrapolation. https://ncleg.gov/EnactedLegislation/Statutes/HTML/BySection/Chapter_108C/GS_108C-5.html
• North Carolina General Assembly. N.C.G.S. 108C-7, Prepayment claims review. https://library.ncleg.gov/EnactedLegislation/Statutes/HTML/BySection/Chapter_108C/GS_108C-7.html
• North Carolina General Assembly. Session Law 2011-399. https://www.ncleg.gov/EnactedLegislation/SessionLaws/HTML/2011-2012/SL2011-399.html
• NCTracks, North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services. Update to Appeal Language in North Carolina Medicaid Provider Adverse Action Letters. https://www.nctracks.nc.gov/content/public/providers/provider-communications/2025-Announcements/Update-to-Appeal-Language-in-North-Carolina-Medicaid-Provider-Adverse-Action-Letters-.html
• NC Medicaid, North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services. Office of Compliance and Program Integrity presentation. https://medicaid.ncdhhs.gov/documents/providers/programs-services/pcs/program-integrity-pcs-fall-2017/download
• NC Medicaid, North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services. Proposed rule 10A NCAC 22F .0402. https://medicaid.ncdhhs.gov/documents/getinvolved/rulesactions/10a-ncac-22f-0402/download
• North Carolina Office of Administrative Hearings. Williams v. North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services, 12 DHR 00926. https://www.oah.nc.gov/documents/files/12-dhr-00926/open
• North Carolina Office of Administrative Hearings. Decision in 15 DHR 08051. https://www.oah.nc.gov/documents/files/15-dhr-08051/open
• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Credible Allegations of Fraud and Payment Suspensions podcast transcript. https://www.cms.gov/Medicare-Medicaid-Coordination/Fraud-Prevention/Medicaid-Integrity-Education/Downloads/podcast-Credible-Allegations-of-Fraud-transcript-[September-2015].pdf
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 455.23, Suspension of payments in cases of fraud. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-C/part-455/subpart-A/section-455.23
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 438.608, Program integrity requirements under the contract. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-C/part-438/subpart-H/section-438.608
• U.S. Code. 42 U.S.C. 1320a-7k(d), Reporting and returning of overpayments. https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid:USC-prelim-title42-section1320a-7k

Some or all of the services described herein may not be permissible for HealthBridge US clients and their affiliates or related entities.
The information provided is general in nature and is not intended to address the specific circumstances of any individual or entity. While we strive to offer accurate and timely information, we cannot guarantee that such information remains accurate after it is received or that it will continue to be accurate over time. Anyone seeking to act on such information should first seek professional advice tailored to their specific situation. HealthBridge US does not offer legal services.
HealthBridge US is not affiliated with any department of public health agencies in any state, nor with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). We offer healthcare consulting services exclusively and are an independent consulting firm not affiliated with any regulatory organizations, including but not limited to the Accrediting Organizations, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), and state departments. HealthBridge is an anti-fraud company in full compliance with all applicable federal and state regulations for CMS, as well as other relevant business and healthcare laws. The badges, icons, and achievement graphics displayed on this website represent proprietary performance metrics, volume milestones, and internal corporate recognition issued exclusively by our corporate affiliate network at SummitRidge. These visual markers are utilized solely as historical indicators of enterprise growth, operational longevity, and volume-based milestones cleared within our shared corporate ecosystem.
© 2026 HealthBridge US, a California corporation. All rights reserved.
For more information about the structure of HealthBridge, visit www.myhbconsulting.com/governance
