Pennsylvania Medicaid Provider Audit Response: Program Integrity Reviews and Recoupment
How Pennsylvania's DHS Bureau of Program Integrity reviews Medical Assistance providers, what penalties and recoupments are possible, and how to appeal to the Bureau of Hearings and Appeals within the 33-day deadline.
KNOWLEDGE CENTER
11/15/202612 min read
Pennsylvania's Medical Assistance (MA) program, the state's Medicaid program, is administered by the Department of Human Services (DHS) and serves millions of residents through fee-for-service and the HealthChoices managed care delivery system. Within DHS, the Bureau of Program Integrity (BPI) conducts post-payment and prepayment reviews of providers to determine whether services were provided and billed in accordance with applicable regulations. When BPI identifies problems, the consequences can include recovery of improperly paid funds, civil monetary penalties, corrective action plans, termination, preclusion from participation, and referrals to law enforcement.
Pennsylvania's provider regulations, primarily in Title 55 of the Pennsylvania Code, Chapter 1101, set out provider obligations, enforcement actions, and restitution. Provider appeals are governed by Chapter 11 of Title 67 of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes and by the provider appeal regulations at 55 Pa. Code Chapter 41, which are administered by DHS's Bureau of Hearings and Appeals (BHA). The deadlines are strict. If DHS mails notice of an agency action, the provider must file its request for hearing with BHA within 33 days of the date of the written notice, and BHA lacks jurisdiction over untimely requests except in limited circumstances.
This article explains how BPI reviews work, the enforcement tools available to DHS, the appeal process, and strategies for responding. It is educational and not legal advice. Providers facing BPI reviews or enforcement actions should consult experienced Pennsylvania healthcare counsel.
The Bureau of Program Integrity
Who Is Reviewed
BPI selects providers for review based on complaints, referrals, calls to the MA Provider Compliance Hotline, or fraud and abuse detection technology. BPI emphasizes that all providers are at risk of review.
Types of Review Activities
BPI review activities may include:
• Claims profile reviews for over- or underutilization patterns.
• Onsite visits to observe settings, interview staff, and obtain records.
• Recipient interviews, evaluations, or home visits.
• Record reviews by medical professionals, including peer review.
BPI conducts both post-payment reviews, after claims are paid, and prepayment reviews, before claims are paid.
Access to Records
Under 55 Pa. Code 1101.51(e), providers must make medical and fiscal records readily available for review and copying by state and federal officials. BPI has explained that HIPAA does not require patient authorization for providers to release necessary protected health information to BPI for oversight, and that BPI limits its use of that information to the minimum necessary.
Managed Care Providers
BPI may take administrative action against all providers, including those participating in the HealthChoices managed care delivery system. Providers under contract with a managed care organization are still MA providers and must comply with applicable regulations.
Federal Contractors
Pennsylvania providers may also be reviewed by federal contractors working with CMS. DHS has informed providers that a Medicaid Integrity Contractor may review provider services, audit claims, and identify overpayments, that onsite visits may be conducted, and that the contractor will notify the provider of preliminary findings and give the provider an opportunity to respond.
Possible Outcomes of a BPI Review
BPI has described a range of possible outcomes, including:
• Recovery of improperly paid funds, with or without penalty.
• A civil monetary penalty of twice the overpaid amount, plus interest.
• A request that the provider perform a self-audit.
• A corrective action plan or compliance plan.
• Termination of the provider agreement.
• Preclusion from direct and indirect participation in MA.
• Referrals to the Attorney General's Medicaid Fraud Control Section, the Pennsylvania Office of State Inspector General, or other agencies.
BPI may also issue discrepancy letters describing identified issues.
Enforcement Actions and Restitution
Under 55 Pa. Code 1101.77, DHS may terminate a provider's enrollment and direct and indirect participation in the MA program and seek restitution under 55 Pa. Code 1101.83 if it determines that a provider, an employee of the provider, or certain related persons engaged in specified prohibited conduct. Section 1101.83 governs restitution and repayment of overpayments.
Pennsylvania's rules also address repayment while appeals are pending. Under 55 Pa. Code 1101.69a, an appeal by the provider of an audit disallowance does not suspend the provider's obligation to repay, and failure to respond to a settlement letter or to pay the overpayment when due will not stay DHS's action. A provider seeking to stay an agency action during an appeal may petition BHA for supersedeas.
Appealing to the Bureau of Hearings and Appeals
BHA's Role
The Bureau of Hearings and Appeals is the DHS entity charged with conducting administrative hearings and adjudicating appeals, including disputes regarding Medical Assistance provider enrollment and medical provider audit findings. Medical Assistance provider appeals filed after November 24, 2006 are governed by 55 Pa. Code Chapter 41.
Filing Deadlines
Under 67 Pa.C.S. 1102, a provider must file a written request for hearing with BHA within the time specified in the statute after notice of the departmental action. Under 55 Pa. Code 41.32, if the program office gives notice of an agency action by mailing it to the provider, the provider must file its request for hearing with BHA within 33 days of the date of the written notice. BHA lacks jurisdiction to hear a request that is not in writing and timely filed, except as permitted for appeals nunc pro tunc under 55 Pa. Code 41.33, which applies only in limited circumstances.
Preserving Issues
A request for hearing must raise the issues the provider intends to contest. BHA conducts a de novo review of the factual and legal issues that are timely raised and properly preserved in a provider appeal, under 55 Pa. Code 41.191. Issues not properly preserved may be lost.
Supersedeas
Under 55 Pa. Code 41.51, a provider that has filed a request for hearing may petition BHA to grant a supersedeas of the agency action, which would stay the action during the appeal. The petition must be in writing and may be filed during the provider appeal. Supersedeas is discretionary and requires a showing under the applicable standards.
Hearing and Determination
BHA holds hearings and conducts adjudications in accordance with Pennsylvania's administrative agency law. After the hearing and posthearing briefs, BHA issues a determination, generally within 30 days of the filing of posthearing briefs or, if briefs are waived, within 30 days of the close of the record or receipt of the transcript.
Further Review
Providers may seek reconsideration by the Secretary of Human Services and judicial review in the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania. The Commonwealth Court reviews whether findings are supported by substantial evidence, whether an error of law was committed, and whether constitutional rights were violated. Recent Commonwealth Court decisions have upheld BHA orders affirming audit results and have addressed denials of untimely appeal requests, underscoring the importance of building the record and meeting deadlines.
The Medicaid Provider Self-Review Protocol
DHS maintains a Medicaid Provider Self-Review Protocol for providers that identify overpayments. DHS has noted that BPI has identified hundreds of situations involving inappropriate payments to MA providers, many involving failure to maintain records in accordance with applicable regulations. The protocol describes how providers should conduct self-reviews, report findings, and return overpayments, including how to submit refund checks payable to the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania to BPI. Self-review and voluntary repayment demonstrate good faith and can reduce exposure. Federal law also requires providers to report and return identified overpayments, generally within 60 days, under section 1128J(d) of the Social Security Act.
Responding to a BPI Review
Respond to Record Requests Promptly
Make records readily available as required by 55 Pa. Code 1101.51(e). Track every request, produce complete records, keep copies, and confirm receipt.
Prepare for Onsite Visits
Make sure locations are operating as described in enrollment, staff can explain operations, and records are accessible.
Engage With Preliminary Findings
When BPI or a federal contractor shares preliminary findings or discrepancy letters, respond with specific documentation and explanations. Correct factual errors and supply missing records.
Evaluate Self-Audit Requests Carefully
If BPI requests a self-audit, work with counsel to design the methodology, understand how results will be used, and document the process.
Analyze Sampling and Extrapolation
If BPI extrapolates from a sample, request the sampling plan, universe, and calculations, and consider statistical review.
Calendar the 33-Day Appeal Deadline
As soon as a written notice of agency action arrives, calendar the 33-day deadline and prepare a timely written request for hearing that preserves all issues.
Consider Supersedeas
If repayment or termination would cause serious harm during the appeal, evaluate a petition for supersedeas.
Negotiate Where Appropriate
Many BPI matters resolve through settlement agreements, repayment plans, or corrective action plans. Counsel can evaluate the costs and benefits of settlement versus appeal.
Managed Care Audits
HealthChoices managed care organizations and behavioral health managed care organizations conduct their own audits through special investigation units and compliance departments, often with overpayment letters, audit spreadsheets, and internal dispute levels. Providers should understand each plan's process and coordinate responses with any BPI review. BHA may lack jurisdiction over certain managed care disputes, as Commonwealth Court has addressed in cases involving behavioral health managed care network decisions, so providers should identify the correct forum for each dispute.
Building Audit Readiness in Pennsylvania
• Maintain records that meet 55 Pa. Code Chapter 1101 requirements, including contemporaneous documentation of services.
• Conduct periodic self-reviews using the DHS protocol and correct identified issues.
• Monitor utilization patterns, because BPI uses claims profile reviews.
• Screen owners and staff against federal exclusion lists and Pennsylvania's Medicheck precluded provider list.
• Train staff on MA program requirements for your provider type.
• Keep enrollment information current so notices reach you.
• Maintain an audit response plan with clear responsibility for deadlines.
Common Mistakes
• Missing the 33-day deadline to request a hearing.
• Failing to preserve issues in the request for hearing.
• Assuming an appeal stops repayment without seeking supersedeas.
• Failing to make records readily available.
• Treating managed care audits as unrelated to BPI.
• Ignoring the self-review protocol when problems are identified.
Settlement Letters and Repayment
At the conclusion of many BPI reviews, providers receive a settlement letter or similar communication describing the findings, the amount of the overpayment, any penalty, and the options for resolution. Providers should treat this letter as a critical document. Under 55 Pa. Code 1101.69a, failure to respond to a settlement letter or to pay the overpayment when due will not stay DHS's action, and an appeal of an audit disallowance does not suspend the obligation to repay.
When a settlement letter arrives, providers should:
• Calendar every deadline, including the deadline to respond and the 33-day deadline to request a hearing if notice was mailed.
• Review each finding against the documentation and the regulations in effect on the dates of service.
• Determine whether the overpayment was calculated from actual claims or extrapolated from a sample.
• Evaluate whether the penalty, if any, is appropriate and whether mitigating facts exist.
• Consider whether to accept, negotiate, or appeal.
• Ask about repayment options, such as installment plans or offsets, if accepting the findings.
Responding promptly and in writing protects the provider's options. Ignoring a settlement letter does not delay DHS's ability to collect.
Preparing a Strong Request for Hearing
Because BHA reviews only issues timely raised and properly preserved, the request for hearing is one of the most important documents in a Pennsylvania provider appeal. A strong request:
• Identifies the agency action being appealed, including the date of the notice and any reference numbers.
• States each issue the provider intends to contest, including factual disputes, legal errors, and challenges to the sampling and extrapolation methodology.
• Challenges the penalty separately, if a penalty was assessed.
• Raises procedural issues, such as defects in notice.
• Is filed in writing with BHA within the deadline.
Providers sometimes file a brief request to meet the deadline and then seek to add issues later. Whether additional issues can be raised later depends on the regulations and BHA's rulings, so counsel should draft the initial request to preserve every reasonable issue.
The Hearing Process at BHA
BHA provider appeals are formal adjudications. The process may include prehearing conferences, exchange of documents, discovery under the applicable rules, motions, an evidentiary hearing before an administrative law judge, and posthearing briefs. Providers should prepare as they would for litigation:
• Organize all documentation by claim and finding.
• Identify fact witnesses, such as clinicians and billing staff.
• Retain experts where needed, including statisticians and clinical reviewers.
• Prepare a clear theory of the case explaining why the findings are wrong.
• Draft posthearing briefs that tie the evidence to the legal standards.
Because the Commonwealth Court generally reviews BHA decisions for substantial evidence and errors of law, the record built at BHA is usually the record on appeal. Evidence not presented to BHA is unlikely to be considered later.
Common Findings in Pennsylvania MA Reviews
BPI reviews and Commonwealth Court decisions reflect several recurring issues:
• Failure to maintain records required by Chapter 1101 and program-specific chapters.
• Documentation that does not support the service, level of service, or units billed.
• Missing signatures, dates, or practitioner credentials.
• Services provided by staff who did not meet qualification requirements.
• Billing for services not ordered or not included in a required treatment plan.
• Billing for services when the recipient was not eligible.
• Billing patterns inconsistent with peer providers.
DHS has noted that many inappropriate payments it identified involved failure to maintain records in accordance with applicable regulations. Strengthening recordkeeping is therefore one of the most effective ways to reduce exposure.
Corrective Action and Compliance Plans
BPI may require a corrective action plan or compliance plan as part of resolving a review. Even when not required, a provider should develop one. An effective plan identifies root causes, assigns responsibility, sets timelines, includes staff training, and builds in monitoring through follow-up audits. A provider that can show DHS a well-documented compliance program is in a stronger position in future reviews and negotiations.
Coordinating Communications During a Review
Providers should designate one person, usually a compliance officer or counsel, to receive BPI requests, track deadlines, and approve outgoing correspondence. Staff should route reviewer questions to that person. Keep a log of every document produced and confirm important conversations in writing. During onsite visits, a designated staff member should accompany reviewers, note what was requested and reviewed, and make sure copies of all produced records are retained.
Balancing Cooperation and Advocacy
Cooperating with BPI and contesting its findings are not in conflict. Providers can produce records promptly, accommodate onsite visits, and answer questions professionally while still challenging findings through settlement discussions or a BHA appeal. Respectful, documented, and timely advocacy protects the provider's rights and its relationship with the Department, and it creates a clear record that will matter if the dispute later reaches BHA or the Commonwealth Court. Providers that cooperate fully and respond with organized evidence are often better positioned to negotiate reasonable resolutions, including repayment plans and corrective action plans in place of more severe sanctions.
Documenting each step of the review, from the first record request to the final resolution, also gives leadership a clear history to draw on when preparing for future reviews.
Myths About Pennsylvania MA Audits
Myth: Filing an Appeal Stops Recoupment
An appeal of an audit disallowance does not suspend the obligation to repay. A provider must petition for supersedeas to seek a stay.
Myth: Late Appeals Can Be Accepted for Good Reasons
BHA lacks jurisdiction over untimely requests except in the limited circumstances that permit nunc pro tunc appeals.
Myth: Managed Care Providers Are Outside BPI's Reach
BPI may take administrative action against all providers, including those in HealthChoices.
Myth: HIPAA Requires Patient Authorization Before Producing Records to BPI
BPI has explained that HIPAA does not require patient authorization for releasing necessary information to BPI for oversight.
Questions Leadership Should Ask
• Who tracks notices of agency action and the 33-day appeal deadline?
• Are our records readily available for review and copying?
• Have we conducted a self-review using the DHS protocol?
• Do we know which disputes go to BHA and which go through managed care processes?
• Would we need supersedeas if DHS sought repayment or termination?
• Do we have counsel experienced in BHA appeals?
Key Takeaways
• Pennsylvania's DHS Bureau of Program Integrity conducts post-payment and prepayment reviews of all MA providers, including HealthChoices providers.
• Possible outcomes include recovery of overpayments, civil monetary penalties of twice the overpaid amount plus interest, corrective action plans, termination, preclusion, and referrals.
• Providers must make records readily available under 55 Pa. Code 1101.51(e).
• Requests for hearing must be filed with BHA within 33 days of a mailed notice under 55 Pa. Code 41.32, and issues must be preserved for BHA's de novo review.
• An appeal does not suspend repayment, but providers may petition for supersedeas, and further review is available in Commonwealth Court.
How HealthBridge Can Help
HealthBridge helps Pennsylvania Medical Assistance providers prepare for and respond to BPI reviews and enforcement actions. Our team can organize record production, prepare for onsite visits, analyze discrepancy letters and preliminary findings, review sampling and extrapolation, and help design self-audits and self-reviews under the DHS protocol. We support counsel in preparing timely requests for hearing that preserve all issues, assembling evidence for BHA, and evaluating supersedeas. We also help providers build documentation, compliance, and audit response programs. If your organization is facing a BPI review or wants to be prepared, please get in touch with us. We will be happy to help you with this topic.
References
• Pennsylvania Department of Human Services. Post and Prepayment Reviews. https://www.pa.gov/agencies/dhs/report-fraud/post-prepayment-review
• Pennsylvania Department of Human Services. Medicaid Provider Self-Review Protocol. https://www.pa.gov/agencies/dhs/report-fraud/medicaid-provider-self-audit-protocol
• Pennsylvania Department of Human Services. Bureau of Program Integrity. https://www.dhs.pa.gov/contact/DHS-Offices/Pages/OA-Bureau%20of%20Program%20Integrity.aspx
• Pennsylvania Department of Human Services. Bureau of Hearings and Appeals. https://www.pa.gov/en/agencies/dhs/departments-offices/oa-info/oa-bureau-hearings-appeals.html
• Pennsylvania Department of Human Services. Hearings and Appeals Process. https://www.pa.gov/en/agencies/dhs/resources/hearings-and-appeals/hearing-appeals-process.html
• Pennsylvania Department of Human Services. Quick Tip 77, Medicaid Integrity Contractor Reviews. https://prddhs.pwpca.pa.gov/providers/Quick-Tips/Documents/Qtip%2077.pdf
• Pennsylvania Code. 55 Pa. Code Chapter 1101, General Provisions (including 1101.51, 1101.69a, 1101.77, 1101.83). https://www.pacodeandbulletin.gov/Display/pacode?file=/secure/pacode/data/055/chapter1101/chap1101toc.html
• Pennsylvania Code. 55 Pa. Code Chapter 41, Medical Assistance Provider Appeal Procedures (including 41.32, 41.33, 41.51, 41.191). https://www.pacodeandbulletin.gov/Display/pacode?file=/secure/pacode/data/055/chapter41/chap41toc.html
• Pennsylvania General Assembly. 67 Pa.C.S. Chapter 11, Medical Assistance Hearings and Appeals (section 1102). https://www.legis.state.pa.us/cfdocs/legis/LI/consCheck.cfm?txtType=HTM&ttl=67&div=0&chpt=11
• Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania. Eye Consultants of Pennsylvania, P.C. v. Department of Human Services, No. 109 C.D. 2024 (2025). https://www.pacourts.us/assets/opinions/Commonwealth/out/109CD24_6-9-25.pdf
• Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania. Opinion No. 1281 C.D. 2023 (2025). https://www.pacourts.us/assets/opinions/Commonwealth/out/1281CD23_9-26-25.pdf
• U.S. Code. 42 U.S.C. 1320a-7k(d), Reporting and returning of overpayments. https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid:USC-prelim-title42-section1320a-7k

Some or all of the services described herein may not be permissible for HealthBridge US clients and their affiliates or related entities.
The information provided is general in nature and is not intended to address the specific circumstances of any individual or entity. While we strive to offer accurate and timely information, we cannot guarantee that such information remains accurate after it is received or that it will continue to be accurate over time. Anyone seeking to act on such information should first seek professional advice tailored to their specific situation. HealthBridge US does not offer legal services.
HealthBridge US is not affiliated with any department of public health agencies in any state, nor with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). We offer healthcare consulting services exclusively and are an independent consulting firm not affiliated with any regulatory organizations, including but not limited to the Accrediting Organizations, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), and state departments. HealthBridge is an anti-fraud company in full compliance with all applicable federal and state regulations for CMS, as well as other relevant business and healthcare laws. The badges, icons, and achievement graphics displayed on this website represent proprietary performance metrics, volume milestones, and internal corporate recognition issued exclusively by our corporate affiliate network at SummitRidge. These visual markers are utilized solely as historical indicators of enterprise growth, operational longevity, and volume-based milestones cleared within our shared corporate ecosystem.
© 2026 HealthBridge US, a California corporation. All rights reserved.
For more information about the structure of HealthBridge, visit www.myhbconsulting.com/governance
