Physician Practice Audit Response: E/M Coding, Medical Necessity, and Modifier 25 Reviews
How physician practices should respond to E/M audits: who audits in 2026, office E/M rules based on MDM or time, G2211, medical necessity, OIG's 2025 modifier 25 findings for eye injections and podiatry, the 2026 OIG work plan item, extrapolation, response packets, and appeals.
KNOWLEDGE CENTER
11/15/202612 min read
Evaluation and management (E/M) services are the most frequently billed services in Medicare Part B and a constant focus of audits. Practices face reviews of E/M levels, medical necessity, and modifier 25, which allows separate payment for a significant, separately identifiable E/M service on the same day as a procedure or other service.
Modifier 25 has drawn particular attention. In 2025, OIG reported that documentation for 22 of 24 sampled E/M services billed with modifier 25 on the same day as eye injections did not support the modifier, and recommended reviews of up to $124 million in payments. OIG also found that 44 of 100 sampled podiatrist E/M claims billed with modifier 25 did not meet Medicare requirements, estimating about $39.6 million in improper payments. In 2026, OIG added a work plan item examining E/M services billed on the same day as minor surgical procedures without modifier 25.
This article explains the audit landscape, E/M and modifier 25 rules, how to respond to audits, and how to appeal. It is educational and does not replace legal or professional advice.
Who Audits Physician Practices
• Medicare Administrative Contractors conduct Targeted Probe and Educate reviews and other prepayment and postpayment reviews.
• Recovery Audit Contractors review claims for approved issues.
• The Comprehensive Error Rate Testing contractor reviews random samples.
• Unified Program Integrity Contractors investigate potential fraud and may use extrapolation.
• OIG audits individual practices and nationwide claim categories.
• Medicare Advantage plans, Medicaid programs, and commercial payers conduct their own audits.
E/M Coding Rules
Office and Outpatient Visits
Since 2021, office and outpatient E/M levels (99202 through 99215) are selected based on either medical decision making or total time on the date of the encounter. History and examination must be medically appropriate but do not determine the level. In 2023, CPT extended a similar framework to other E/M categories, including hospital, nursing facility, and emergency department services.
Medical Decision Making
MDM is based on two of three elements: the number and complexity of problems addressed, the amount and complexity of data reviewed and analyzed, and the risk of complications, morbidity, or mortality of patient management.
Time
When time is used, the practitioner must document total time personally spent on the date of the encounter, including face-to-face and non-face-to-face activities such as reviewing records, ordering tests, documenting, and communicating with other professionals. Medicare has its own rules for prolonged services.
G2211
Medicare pays an add-on code, G2211, for visit complexity inherent to office and outpatient E/M visits that are part of ongoing longitudinal care. CMS has issued rules on when G2211 may be billed, including limits when modifier 25 is used, with exceptions for certain preventive services. Documentation should show the ongoing relationship.
Split or Shared Visits
For split or shared visits in facility settings, Medicare rules determine which practitioner bills based on who performed the substantive portion. Follow the rules for the date of service.
Medical Necessity
Under Section 1862(a)(1)(A) of the Social Security Act, Medicare pays only for services that are reasonable and necessary for the diagnosis or treatment of illness or injury. For E/M services, medical necessity means the visit and its level must be justified by the patient's condition. CMS guidance states that medical necessity is the overarching criterion for payment, and documentation volume alone should not determine the level.
Common medical necessity issues include:
• Routine visits without a clinical reason.
• High-level visits for stable, minor problems.
• Visits scheduled at a frequency not supported by the patient's condition.
• Repeated visits that duplicate care provided by other practitioners.
Modifier 25
The Rule
Medicare's global surgery rules include payment for the evaluation that is part of a minor procedure. Modifier 25 is appended to an E/M service when, on the same day as a procedure or other service, the practitioner performs a significant, separately identifiable E/M service above and beyond the usual preprocedure, intraprocedure, and postprocedure care. Medicare guidance explains that the decision to perform a minor procedure is included in the procedure's payment and does not by itself justify a separate E/M.
What Supports Modifier 25
• The patient presented with a problem or problems beyond the one treated by the procedure.
• The practitioner evaluated and managed another condition, such as adjusting medications for a chronic illness.
• The evaluation went beyond the usual preprocedure assessment.
• The documentation clearly separates the E/M from the procedure.
What Does Not Support Modifier 25
• The visit was scheduled only for the procedure.
• The E/M documentation describes only the evaluation leading to the procedure.
• The note is templated and does not show separate work.
OIG Findings
OIG's 2025 audit of E/M services billed with modifier 25 on the same day as intravitreal injections found that providers billed E/M services on the same day as 42 percent of eye injections and that documentation for 22 of 24 sampled services did not support modifier 25. OIG recommended that CMS clarify requirements, conduct medical reviews, recover improper payments, and educate providers, and CMS published education on billing these services correctly.
OIG's December 2025 audit of podiatrists' E/M claims billed with modifier 25 found that 44 of 100 sampled claims for calendar year 2019 did not meet Medicare requirements, with estimated improper payments of about $39.6 million of $222.5 million paid. OIG recommended that CMS work with MACs to determine whether additional oversight is needed, and CMS concurred.
OIG also reported in 2025 that dermatology providers generally met Medicare requirements for E/M services performed on the same day as minor surgical procedures, which shows that well-documented practices can withstand review.
The 2026 Work Plan Item
In 2026, OIG announced a review of E/M services billed on the same day as minor surgical procedures that were processed and paid without modifier 25, based on analysis of claims from 2023 through 2025. This review addresses claims that may have bypassed edits, and practices should check whether their claims processing and coding create this risk.
Responding to an Audit
Step 1: Understand the Request
• Identify the auditor, the review type, the claims selected, and the deadline.
• Determine whether the review is prepayment or postpayment and whether extrapolation may apply.
• Calendar the deadline. MAC additional documentation requests generally allow 45 days, and UPIC requests generally allow 30 days.
Step 2: Gather Complete Records
• The progress note for each date of service.
• Procedure notes for same-day procedures.
• Orders, test results, and referrals relevant to MDM.
• Signature logs or attestations for illegible or missing signatures, as allowed.
• Documentation for any time-based services.
• Prior notes that establish the patient's history and ongoing care.
Step 3: Review Before Submitting
• Recode each E/M using the correct rules for the date of service.
• Confirm medical necessity.
• Confirm that modifier 25 is supported.
• Identify errors honestly and decide how to address them.
Step 4: Prepare a Cover Letter
Summarize each claim, explain how the documentation supports the level and modifier, and provide page references. Keep the letter factual.
Step 5: Submit and Track
Use the auditor's accepted submission method, keep proof of submission, and keep a copy of the packet.
Extrapolation
Under Section 1893(f)(3) of the Social Security Act, Medicare contractors may use extrapolation only when there is a sustained or high level of payment error or when documented educational intervention has failed to correct the error. Extrapolated overpayments can be large. When facing extrapolation, practices should request the sampling methodology and data, have a statistician review it, and challenge errors in the universe definition, sample selection, or calculation on appeal, along with the individual claim determinations.
Appeals
Medicare appeals follow 42 CFR Part 405, Subpart I:
• Redetermination by the MAC within 120 days.
• Reconsideration by a Qualified Independent Contractor within 180 days.
• Administrative Law Judge hearing within 60 days, when the amount in controversy is at least $200 for requests filed in calendar year 2026.
• Medicare Appeals Council review.
• Federal district court review, with a threshold of $1,960 for requests filed in calendar year 2026.
For postpayment overpayments, filing a redetermination within 30 days and a reconsideration within 60 days limits recoupment during those levels under 42 CFR 405.379. Submit all evidence by the reconsideration level.
Appeal Arguments
• The documentation supports the billed level under MDM or time.
• The E/M addressed problems separate from the procedure, supporting modifier 25.
• The reviewer applied the wrong year's E/M guidelines.
• Medical necessity is supported by the patient's condition.
• If a level is not supported, the claim should be adjusted to a lower level rather than denied entirely.
Building a Compliance Program
• Audit a sample of E/M services for each practitioner at least annually.
• Monitor E/M level distribution and modifier 25 rates against peers.
• Audit same-day E/M and procedure combinations, including those without modifier 25.
• Educate practitioners on MDM, time, G2211, and modifier 25.
• Review templates to prevent cloned documentation.
• Report and return overpayments within 60 days under 42 CFR 401.305.
A Hypothetical Example
An ophthalmology practice receives a MAC review of E/M services billed with modifier 25 on the same day as intravitreal injections. Its internal review finds that most E/M notes described only the evaluation leading to the injection. The practice submits records for the claims it believes are supported, accepts denials for the rest, revises its policy so that modifier 25 is used only when a separate problem is evaluated and managed, and trains physicians. Its next review shows a sharply lower error rate.
Documentation That Supports Modifier 25
Clear documentation is the best protection for modifier 25 claims. Practical techniques include:
• Separating the note into a section for the E/M service and a section for the procedure, with distinct headings.
• Listing each problem addressed in the E/M, including chronic conditions managed and new complaints evaluated.
• Documenting data reviewed and decisions made for those problems, such as medication changes or new orders.
• Avoiding reliance on the procedure's diagnosis alone for the E/M claim when other problems were addressed, and linking the appropriate diagnoses to each service.
• Documenting the procedure separately, including the indication, consent, technique, and outcome.
When the only reason for the visit was the procedure, the practitioner should not bill a separate E/M, even if a brief history and examination were performed.
Preventive Visits and Problem-Oriented Visits
When a practitioner performs a preventive visit, such as an annual wellness visit, and also addresses a significant problem, a separate problem-oriented E/M may be billed with modifier 25 if documented. The documentation must show the additional work for the problem, separate from the preventive service. CMS has issued rules on G2211 in combination with preventive services and modifier 25, so practices should confirm the current rules.
Common Myths About E/M Audits
Myth: More Documentation Means a Higher Level
The level depends on MDM or time, not note length, and must be supported by medical necessity.
Myth: Modifier 25 Is Required Whenever an E/M and Procedure Occur Together
Modifier 25 should be used only when a separate E/M is performed. Otherwise, the E/M should not be billed.
Myth: Auditors Use the Same Rules for All Years
The applicable E/M guidelines depend on the date of service. Reviewers who apply the wrong year's rules can be challenged.
Myth: An Audit Means Fraud Is Suspected
Most audits are data-driven or random. Prompt, organized responses resolve many reviews.
Questions Leadership Should Ask
• How does our E/M level distribution compare with peers?
• What is our modifier 25 rate, and is it supported?
• Do our templates encourage cloned documentation?
• When did we last audit each practitioner?
• Do we have a process for responding to audits and tracking deadlines?
• Are we returning identified overpayments within 60 days?
Key Takeaways
• E/M levels are based on MDM or time, and medical necessity is the overarching requirement.
• OIG found widespread modifier 25 problems with eye injections and podiatry, and added a 2026 review of same-day E/M claims without modifier 25.
• Respond to audits with complete records, a clear cover letter, and timely submission.
• Challenge extrapolations with statistical review.
• Appeal well-supported claims and submit all evidence by reconsideration.
Prepayment Review and TPE
Many practices first encounter audits through Targeted Probe and Educate. Under TPE, a MAC reviews a sample of claims, provides one-on-one education on errors, and allows time to improve, for up to three rounds. Practices that continue to have high error rates may be referred to CMS for further action, which can include extended prepayment review, referral to a Recovery Audit Contractor, or extrapolation. Practices should take the education sessions seriously, implement changes between rounds, and track improvement.
Telehealth E/M Audits
Telehealth E/M services have their own requirements, including place of service and modifier rules, patient location, and the use of audio-only services, which have changed over time. Practices should audit telehealth claims separately to confirm that they meet the rules for each date of service.
Working With Billing Companies
Many practices use outside billing companies. Practices remain responsible for the accuracy of their claims. Contracts should define coding responsibilities, require compliance with Medicare rules, and allow the practice to audit the billing company's work. Practices should review reports of modifier use and level distribution and ask questions about unusual patterns.
Self-Disclosure
If a practice discovers significant billing errors, it may need to report and return overpayments to the MAC within 60 days of identification. In cases involving potential fraud, the OIG Self-Disclosure Protocol may be appropriate. Practices should consult counsel when considering self-disclosure.
Responding to Prepayment Denials
Prepayment denials do not create overpayments, but they delay revenue. Practices should review each denial, correct and resubmit claims when appropriate, and appeal denials that are supported. Tracking denial reasons helps identify documentation issues before they become patterns that lead to extended review.
Payer Audits Beyond Medicare
Medicare Advantage plans, Medicaid programs, and commercial payers also audit E/M services and modifier 25, and many use automated tools to identify high-level coding or same-day E/M and procedure combinations. Their rules may differ from Medicare's. Practices should review payer policies and contracts, understand appeal rights, and apply consistent documentation standards across payers.
Peer Comparison Data
CMS and payers often compare a practitioner's E/M distribution with peers in the same specialty. Practitioners whose distributions differ substantially may be selected for review. Practices can use publicly available Medicare data and internal reports to compare distributions and to identify outliers for internal audit. Being an outlier is not proof of error, but it should be explained by documentation and patient mix.
Lessons From OIG's Modifier 25 Audits
OIG's recent audits show a consistent pattern. When practitioners routinely bill an E/M with every procedure, error rates tend to be high, as in the eye injection and podiatry audits. When practitioners bill E/M services only when they address separate problems, error rates are low, as in OIG's dermatology review. Practices should examine how often they bill E/M services with each procedure type and confirm that documentation shows separate work. A high rate of E/M billing with a particular procedure is a signal to audit.
Preparing Practitioners
Practitioners are more likely to document well when they understand why it matters. Short education sessions using the practice's own audit results, along with one-page tip sheets on MDM, time documentation, G2211, and modifier 25, help practitioners improve. Individual feedback after audits is especially effective. Practices should also give practitioners time to complete documentation, since rushed notes are more likely to be incomplete or templated. Celebrating improvements reinforces good habits and builds a culture of compliance.
Keeping Records Organized
Maintain a central log of every audit, including the requesting entity, claims involved, deadlines, submissions, results, and appeals. A complete log helps practices meet deadlines, track trends, and demonstrate an effective compliance program.
Review the log quarterly with leadership to spot recurring issues.
Consistent tracking also supports future appeals.
Frequently Asked Questions
How are office E/M levels selected?
Based on medical decision making or total time on the date of the encounter.
When is modifier 25 appropriate?
When a significant, separately identifiable E/M service is performed on the same day as a procedure or other service, beyond the usual work of the procedure.
What did OIG find for modifier 25 with eye injections?
Documentation for 22 of 24 sampled E/M services did not support modifier 25, and OIG recommended reviewing up to $124 million in payments.
Can Medicare extrapolate E/M overpayments?
Yes, when there is a sustained or high level of payment error or failed educational intervention.
What is the best audit defense?
Documentation that clearly shows medical necessity, supports the level, and separates E/M work from procedures.
Conclusion
E/M audits focus on level selection, medical necessity, and modifier 25. Practices that document clearly, audit regularly, use modifier 25 only when supported, respond to audits with organized records, and appeal well-supported claims will reduce overpayments and protect revenue.
How HealthBridge Can Help
HealthBridge is a healthcare management consulting firm that helps physician practices audit E/M coding and modifier 25 use, respond to MAC, RAC, UPIC, and OIG reviews, challenge extrapolations, and train practitioners. If your practice is facing an E/M audit, please get in touch with us. We will be happy to help you with this topic.
References
• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General. Medicare Payments for Evaluation and Management Services Provided on the Same Day as Eye Injections Were at Risk for Noncompliance With Medicare Requirements (A-09-23-03014). https://oig.hhs.gov/reports/all/2025/medicare-payments-for-evaluation-and-management-services-provided-on-the-same-day-as-eye-injections-were-at-risk-for-noncompliance-with-medicare-requirements/
• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General. Podiatrists' Claims for Evaluation and Management Services Did Not Comply With Medicare Requirements (A-09-22-03012). https://oig.hhs.gov/reports/all/2025/podiatrists-claims-for-evaluation-and-management-services-did-not-comply-with-medicare-requirements
• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General. Dermatology Providers Generally Met Medicare Requirements for Evaluation and Management Services Performed on Same Day as Minor Surgical Procedures. https://oig.hhs.gov/reports/all/2025/dermatology-providers-generally-met-medicare-requirements-for-evaluation-and-management-services-performed-on-same-day-as-minor-surgical-procedures/
• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General. Work Plan: Evaluation and Management Services on Same Day as Minor Surgery With No Modifier 25 (OAS-26-04-028). https://oig.hhs.gov/reports/work-plan/browse-work-plan-projects/evaluation-and-management-services-on-same-day-as-minor-surgery-with-no-modifier-25
• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Evaluation and Management Services and Intravitreal Injections: Bill Correctly (MLN Fast Facts). https://www.cms.gov/outreach-and-education/medicare-learning-network-mln/mlnproducts/fast-facts/evaluation-management-services-intravitreal-injections-bill-correctly
• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Medicare Claims Processing Manual, Chapter 12, Physicians/Nonphysician Practitioners. https://www.cms.gov/Regulations-and-Guidance/Guidance/Manuals/downloads/clm104c12.pdf
• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Medicare Program Integrity Manual, Chapter 3, Verifying Potential Errors and Taking Corrective Actions. https://www.cms.gov/Regulations-and-Guidance/Guidance/Manuals/downloads/pim83c03.pdf
• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Medicare Program Integrity Manual, Chapter 8, Administrative Actions and Statistical Sampling for Overpayment Estimation. https://www.cms.gov/Regulations-and-Guidance/Guidance/Manuals/downloads/pim83c08.pdf
• U.S. Social Security Administration. Social Security Act, Section 1862, Exclusions From Coverage. https://www.ssa.gov/OP_Home/ssact/title18/1862.htm
• U.S. Social Security Administration. Social Security Act, Section 1893, Medicare Integrity Program. https://www.ssa.gov/OP_Home/ssact/title18/1893.htm
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR Part 405, Subpart I, Determinations, Redeterminations, Reconsiderations, and Appeals Under Original Medicare. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-405/subpart-I
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 405.379, Limitation on Recoupment of Provider and Supplier Overpayments. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-405/subpart-C/section-405.379
• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR 401.305, Requirements for Reporting and Returning of Overpayments. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-A/part-401/subpart-D/section-401.305

Some or all of the services described herein may not be permissible for HealthBridge US clients and their affiliates or related entities.
The information provided is general in nature and is not intended to address the specific circumstances of any individual or entity. While we strive to offer accurate and timely information, we cannot guarantee that such information remains accurate after it is received or that it will continue to be accurate over time. Anyone seeking to act on such information should first seek professional advice tailored to their specific situation. HealthBridge US does not offer legal services.
HealthBridge US is not affiliated with any department of public health agencies in any state, nor with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). We offer healthcare consulting services exclusively and are an independent consulting firm not affiliated with any regulatory organizations, including but not limited to the Accrediting Organizations, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), and state departments. HealthBridge is an anti-fraud company in full compliance with all applicable federal and state regulations for CMS, as well as other relevant business and healthcare laws. The badges, icons, and achievement graphics displayed on this website represent proprietary performance metrics, volume milestones, and internal corporate recognition issued exclusively by our corporate affiliate network at SummitRidge. These visual markers are utilized solely as historical indicators of enterprise growth, operational longevity, and volume-based milestones cleared within our shared corporate ecosystem.
© 2026 HealthBridge US, a California corporation. All rights reserved.
For more information about the structure of HealthBridge, visit www.myhbconsulting.com/governance
