WISeR Prior Authorization Denials: Resubmission and Claim Appeal Strategies for Medical Necessity

How to respond when a WISeR prior authorization request is non-affirmed or a claim is denied: reading the decision, fixing documentation, resubmitting, using Advance Beneficiary Notices, choosing between appeal and reopening, appeal levels and deadlines, and arguments grounded in NCDs and LCDs

KNOWLEDGE CENTER

11/15/202611 min read

Under the CMS Wasteful and Inappropriate Service Reduction (WISeR) Model, providers and suppliers in Arizona, New Jersey, Ohio, Oklahoma, Texas, and Washington must obtain prior authorization or accept prepayment medical review for selected services furnished to Original Medicare beneficiaries. Technology companies selected by CMS, called model participants, review requests and claims against existing Medicare coverage rules.

Not every request is affirmed. When a request is non-affirmed, providers face several decisions: whether to fix and resubmit, whether to proceed with the service, how to protect the patient and the practice financially, and whether to appeal a resulting claim denial. Claims submitted without prior authorization go through prepayment review and can also be denied.

This article explains the difference between a non-affirmation and a claim denial, how to analyze and respond to each, how to resubmit effectively, how Advance Beneficiary Notices fit in, and how to appeal. It is educational and does not replace legal or professional advice. WISeR procedures are updated periodically, so providers should confirm details in the current CMS operational guide and with their MAC and model participant.

Non-Affirmation Versus Claim Denial

A Non-Affirmation Is Not an Initial Determination

According to CMS's WISeR frequently asked questions, when a prior authorization request is non-affirmed, the provider receives the reasons and may resubmit the request an unlimited number of times. A non-affirmed prior authorization decision is not an initial claim determination, so it cannot be appealed through the Medicare claims appeals process. The remedy is resubmission.

A Claim Denial Is an Initial Determination

When a provider submits a claim, the MAC makes an initial determination. If the claim is denied, for example because the service was furnished after a non-affirmation or because prepayment review found the documentation did not support coverage, the denial can be appealed through the standard Medicare appeals process under 42 CFR Part 405, Subpart I.

Providers May Still Furnish Non-Affirmed Services

CMS's frequently asked questions state that providers can still furnish a non-affirmed service and bill for it. Before furnishing a non-affirmed service, the physician must notify the beneficiary using an Advance Beneficiary Notice of Noncoverage.

Step 1: Read the Decision Carefully

Each non-affirmation or denial should identify the reasons. Common reasons include:

• Missing documentation of conservative treatment and its duration.

• Missing or outdated imaging or test results.

• Diagnosis not supported or not among the covered indications.

• Missing documentation of prior treatment response, such as the percentage and duration of relief from a prior injection.

• Frequency limits exceeded without documentation supporting continued treatment.

• Required evaluations not documented, such as psychological evaluations or trial results for certain stimulators.

• Missing signatures or incomplete records.

• Coding errors, such as a code that does not match the documented procedure or a diagnosis code outside the indications listed for the service.

Identify whether the problem is missing documentation, a clinical criterion that the patient does not meet, or an administrative error. The response is different for each.

Step 2: Compare the Record With the Coverage Rules

WISeR does not create new coverage rules. Reviewers apply existing national coverage determinations (NCDs), local coverage determinations (LCDs), billing and coding articles, and other Medicare requirements. For each non-affirmed request:

• Identify the applicable NCD or LCD in the WISeR operational guide and the Medicare Coverage Database.

• List each coverage criterion and documentation requirement.

• Find the record evidence for each criterion.

• Note gaps.

This criterion-by-criterion comparison is the foundation of both resubmissions and appeals.

Step 3: Decide How to Respond

When Documentation Exists but Was Not Submitted

Resubmit with the missing records. This is the most common and easiest fix. Examples include prior physical therapy notes, imaging reports, or notes documenting prior injection response.

When Documentation Is Incomplete

If the clinician performed and documented care that supports coverage but the documentation is unclear, the clinician may add a late entry or addendum that is properly dated and identified, following Medicare Program Integrity Manual guidance and organizational policy. Late entries must reflect what actually occurred and must never be created to fill gaps that were not part of actual care.

When the Patient Does Not Yet Meet Criteria

If the patient has not completed required conservative care or other prerequisites, consider whether the treatment plan should be adjusted, such as completing a course of physical therapy before requesting the procedure.

When You Disagree With the Clinical Judgment

If the record meets the criteria and the reviewer appears to have misapplied them, resubmit with a cover letter that walks through each criterion with page references. If the participant offers clinical discussion with a reviewer, use it to explain the case. If non-affirmation persists and the service is clinically necessary, the provider may furnish the service with an Advance Beneficiary Notice and appeal any claim denial.

Step 4: Build a Stronger Resubmission

Cover Letter

Write a brief cover letter that:

• Identifies the beneficiary, the service, the codes, and the prior request.

• States the applicable NCD or LCD.

• Lists each coverage criterion and where it is documented.

• Responds directly to each non-affirmation reason.

Complete Records

Include:

• The order or treatment plan.

• Recent history and physical examination.

• Diagnostic test and imaging reports.

• Documentation of conservative care, including dates, type, duration, and response.

• Prior procedure notes and documented response.

• Required evaluations.

• Signed and dated documentation.

Coding Accuracy

Confirm that the CPT or HCPCS code matches the planned procedure and that the diagnosis codes reflect the documented condition and fall within the indications listed in the operational guide, where applicable.

Timing

Submit resubmissions promptly. CMS states that participants typically decide resubmitted requests within three days, or two days for expedited requests when a delay could seriously jeopardize the beneficiary's life or health.

Step 5: Protect the Patient and the Practice With an ABN

When an ABN Is Required

When a provider furnishes a non-affirmed WISeR service, CMS requires the physician to notify the beneficiary using an Advance Beneficiary Notice of Noncoverage (Form CMS-R-131). The ABN informs the beneficiary that Medicare may not pay, explains why, and allows the beneficiary to choose whether to receive the service and accept financial responsibility.

ABN Requirements

Under Section 1879 of the Social Security Act and Chapter 30 of the Medicare Claims Processing Manual, a valid ABN must:

• Be delivered before the service is furnished, with enough time for the beneficiary to consider options.

• Identify the specific service and the reason Medicare may deny payment.

• Include a good faith estimate of cost.

• Be signed by the beneficiary, who selects an option.

• Be retained in the record.

Billing With an ABN

When a valid ABN was obtained, claims should be submitted with the appropriate modifier, such as GA, as required by Medicare billing rules. If Medicare denies the claim, the beneficiary may be financially responsible, and the beneficiary retains appeal rights. Without a valid ABN, the provider generally cannot bill the beneficiary for a service denied as not reasonable and necessary.

Communicating With Patients

Explain the non-affirmation in plain language, the reasons, the options, and the expected costs. Document the conversation.

Step 6: Appeal Claim Denials

Prepayment Review Denials

When claims are submitted without prior authorization, the MAC suspends the claim and forwards it to the participant, which requests documentation. According to CGS's WISeR guidance for Ohio, providers have 45 days to submit documentation, and the MAC processes the claim based on the participant's decision. A denial after prepayment review is an initial determination that can be appealed.

Reopening Versus Redetermination

For some denials, especially those caused by clerical errors or failure to submit documentation, a reopening may be available instead of a formal appeal. CGS has published WISeR guidance on choosing between a redetermination and a medical review reopening for prepayment review denials. Providers should check their MAC's guidance, because the right path depends on the reason for the denial.

The Appeal Levels

Under 42 CFR Part 405, Subpart I:

• Redetermination by the MAC, requested within 120 days of receiving the initial determination.

• Reconsideration by a Qualified Independent Contractor, requested within 180 days of the redetermination decision.

• Administrative Law Judge hearing, requested within 60 days of the reconsideration decision, when the amount in controversy is at least $200 for requests filed in calendar year 2026.

• Medicare Appeals Council review.

• Federal district court review, when the amount in controversy is at least $1,960 for requests filed in calendar year 2026.

Providers generally must submit all evidence by the reconsideration level, because new evidence submitted later may be excluded without good cause.

What CMS Says About Overturned Non-Affirmations

CMS's frequently asked questions state that participants are not paid, or must return payment, for non-affirmations that are later overturned on appeal. This design is intended to discourage inappropriate non-affirmations and makes successful appeals meaningful for the model's evaluation.

Appeal Arguments That Work

Criterion-by-Criterion Proof

The strongest appeals show, with page references, that each NCD or LCD criterion was met before the service was furnished.

Correct Application of the Coverage Policy

If the reviewer applied criteria not in the NCD or LCD, or misread a requirement, explain the correct reading and cite the policy text. WISeR is supposed to apply existing coverage rules, not additional criteria.

Clinical Context

Explain why the service was reasonable and necessary for this patient, including comorbidities, failed alternatives, and the risks of delay. A physician's letter can help, but it should be consistent with the contemporaneous record.

Documentation of Urgency

When the service was furnished because delay posed a risk, document why and whether expedited review was requested.

Associated Codes

When associated services were denied because the primary service was denied, a successful appeal of the primary service should support payment of the associated services. Appeal them together.

Tracking and Learning

Build a Denial Log

Track each non-affirmation and denial by service, clinician, reason, resubmission outcome, and appeal outcome.

Look for Patterns

Common patterns include missing conservative care documentation, missing prior response documentation, and diagnosis coding errors. Address them with templates and training.

Measure Affirmation Rates

Affirmation rates matter for planned gold carding, under which providers meeting an affirmation threshold would generally be exempt from prior authorization and prepayment review for a period. Strong resubmission and documentation practices improve these rates.

Service-Specific Tips

Epidural Steroid Injections

Document the diagnosis, symptom duration, functional impact, imaging findings, conservative care, and, for repeat injections, the percentage and duration of relief from prior injections. Follow frequency limits in the applicable LCD.

Cervical Fusion

Document the indication, imaging, neurological findings, conservative care, and the rationale for surgery.

Neurostimulators

Document the diagnosis, failed alternatives, required evaluations, and trial results when the coverage policy requires a trial.

Skin and Tissue Substitutes

Document wound type, size, duration, standard of care and response over the required period, vascular status, and product use consistent with the LCD.

Knee Arthroscopy

Document the specific indication supporting the procedure, since arthroscopic lavage and debridement for osteoarthritis alone are generally not covered under the national coverage determination.

A Hypothetical Example

A spine practice in Texas receives non-affirmations for several epidural steroid injection requests because the records did not document conservative care duration or response to prior injections. The practice builds a template that captures conservative care dates and type, functional scores, and the percentage and duration of relief after each injection. It resubmits with cover letters that map each LCD criterion to the record, and most requests are affirmed. For one patient whose request remained non-affirmed despite meeting criteria, the physician obtained an ABN, performed the injection, and appealed the claim denial. The denial was reversed at redetermination.

Organizing the Resubmission Workflow

Resubmissions succeed when they are handled consistently. A practical workflow includes:

• Intake: log every non-affirmation the day it arrives, with the reasons, service, clinician, and scheduled date of service.

• Triage: classify the problem as missing records, unclear documentation, unmet criteria, or administrative error.

• Clinical review: have a nurse or other clinician review the reasons against the coverage policy and the record.

• Clinician input: ask the ordering clinician to clarify the plan or provide additional records when needed.

• Resubmission: assemble the cover letter and records, confirm codes, and submit through the participant's portal when possible.

• Follow-up: track the decision and update scheduling.

• Patient communication: inform the patient of each step and any changes to the date of service.

Assigning a single owner for each case prevents requests from stalling while the procedure date approaches.

When to Proceed Without Affirmation

Proceeding with a service after a non-affirmation is a clinical and financial decision. Factors to weigh include the urgency of the service, the strength of the record, the likelihood of success on appeal, the patient's preferences and financial situation after receiving an ABN, and the practice's capacity to manage appeals. For urgent cases, providers should request expedited review when a delay could seriously jeopardize the patient's life or health. Providers should never delay medically necessary emergency care because of WISeR; emergency services are excluded from the model.

Common Myths About WISeR Denials

Myth: A Non-Affirmation Means Medicare Will Never Pay

A non-affirmation can be resubmitted without limit, and a later claim denial can be appealed.

Myth: The Reviewer's Criteria Are New Rules

Reviewers are supposed to apply existing NCDs, LCDs, and Medicare rules. If a decision appears to rely on criteria outside those rules, point that out.

Myth: An ABN Is Optional

CMS requires the physician to notify the beneficiary with an ABN before furnishing a non-affirmed service.

Myth: Appeals Are Not Worth It

Overturned non-affirmations affect participant payment, and successful appeals recover revenue and document problems with the review process.

Questions Leadership Should Ask

• What is our affirmation rate by service, clinician, and location?

• What are the top non-affirmation reasons?

• How quickly do we resubmit after a non-affirmation?

• Are ABNs delivered correctly when we proceed without affirmation?

• What is our success rate on appeals?

• Are our templates aligned with the applicable NCDs and LCDs?

• Are we tracking performance for gold carding?

Key Takeaways

• Non-affirmations are resubmitted, not appealed; claim denials are appealed.

• Compare every decision with the applicable NCD or LCD and fix gaps with complete documentation.

• Use a valid ABN before furnishing a non-affirmed service.

• Appeal claim denials with criterion-by-criterion proof and submit all evidence by reconsideration.

• Track reasons and outcomes to improve affirmation rates.

Coordinating Facility and Professional Claims

For services furnished in hospital outpatient departments and ambulatory surgery centers, WISeR prior authorization and prepayment review apply to the facility claim, and associated professional claims may be flagged if the facility claim is non-affirmed or denied. This means that a single documentation gap can affect several claims. Facilities and physician practices should agree on who submits the request, share the decision and Unique Tracking Number, and coordinate appeals. When a facility claim is denied, the physician practice should be informed promptly so it can evaluate its own claim, and both should consider appealing together with consistent documentation.

Beneficiary Appeals

Beneficiaries have their own appeal rights when claims are denied. When a beneficiary signed an ABN and is billed for a denied service, the beneficiary may appeal. Providers should explain these rights and, when appropriate, help the beneficiary obtain records. Beneficiary and provider appeals can proceed in parallel, but providers should coordinate to avoid inconsistent submissions.

Documentation Quality as Prevention

The best way to manage WISeR denials is to prevent them. Practices should audit a sample of requests each month, including affirmed ones, to confirm documentation quality and identify risks before reviewers do. Sharing results with clinicians helps reinforce what reviewers need to see.

Practices should also keep copies of every submission and decision in a central file, so that records are readily available for appeals, internal audits, and any future gold carding review.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a WISeR non-affirmation be appealed?

No. A non-affirmation is not an initial determination. It can be resubmitted an unlimited number of times.

Can a provider perform a service after a non-affirmation?

Yes. CMS states that providers may furnish the service and bill for it, but the beneficiary must first be notified with an Advance Beneficiary Notice.

How long do providers have to submit records for prepayment review?

According to CGS's guidance for Ohio, 45 days after the documentation request.

What happens when a non-affirmation is overturned on appeal?

CMS states that the participant is not paid, or must return payment, for non-affirmations later overturned on appeal.

What are the 2026 appeal thresholds?

$200 for an Administrative Law Judge hearing and $1,960 for federal district court review.

Conclusion

WISeR non-affirmations and denials are manageable with a disciplined approach: read the reasons, compare the record with the coverage policy, resubmit complete documentation, use ABNs correctly when proceeding, and appeal claim denials with criterion-by-criterion proof. Tracking results and improving templates will raise affirmation rates and position providers for gold carding.

How HealthBridge Can Help

HealthBridge is a healthcare management consulting firm that helps providers in WISeR states analyze non-affirmations, build documentation templates, prepare resubmissions, manage ABN processes, and appeal denied claims. If your organization is facing WISeR denials, please get in touch with us. We will be happy to help you with this topic.

References

• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. WISeR (Wasteful and Inappropriate Service Reduction) Model. https://www.cms.gov/priorities/innovation/innovation-models/wiser

• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. WISeR Model Frequently Asked Questions. https://www.cms.gov/priorities/innovation/files/document/wiser-model-frequently-asked-questions

• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. WISeR Model Provider and Supplier Operational Guide. https://www.cms.gov/priorities/innovation/files/wiser-provider-supplier-guide.pdf

• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. WISeR Model Provider Fact Sheet. https://www.cms.gov/priorities/innovation/files/wiser-provider-fact-sheet.pdf

• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Medicare Coverage Database. https://www.cms.gov/medicare-coverage-database/search.aspx

• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Medicare Claims Processing Manual, Chapter 30, Financial Liability Protections. https://www.cms.gov/Regulations-and-Guidance/Guidance/Manuals/downloads/clm104c30.pdf

• Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Medicare Program Integrity Manual, Chapter 3, Verifying Potential Errors and Taking Corrective Actions. https://www.cms.gov/Regulations-and-Guidance/Guidance/Manuals/downloads/pim83c03.pdf

• U.S. Social Security Administration. Social Security Act, Section 1879, Limitation on Liability of Beneficiary Where Medicare Claims Are Disallowed. https://www.ssa.gov/OP_Home/ssact/title18/1879.htm

• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR Part 405, Subpart I, Determinations, Redeterminations, Reconsiderations, and Appeals Under Original Medicare. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-42/chapter-IV/subchapter-B/part-405/subpart-I

• Federal Register. Medicare Appeals; Adjustment to the Amount in Controversy Threshold Amounts for Calendar Year 2026. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2025-12-04/html/2025-21879.htm

Some or all of the services described herein may not be permissible for HealthBridge US clients and their affiliates or related entities.

The information provided is general in nature and is not intended to address the specific circumstances of any individual or entity. While we strive to offer accurate and timely information, we cannot guarantee that such information remains accurate after it is received or that it will continue to be accurate over time. Anyone seeking to act on such information should first seek professional advice tailored to their specific situation. HealthBridge US does not offer legal services.

HealthBridge US is not affiliated with any department of public health agencies in any state, nor with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). We offer healthcare consulting services exclusively and are an independent consulting firm not affiliated with any regulatory organizations, including but not limited to the Accrediting Organizations, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), and state departments. HealthBridge is an anti-fraud company in full compliance with all applicable federal and state regulations for CMS, as well as other relevant business and healthcare laws. The badges, icons, and achievement graphics displayed on this website represent proprietary performance metrics, volume milestones, and internal corporate recognition issued exclusively by our corporate affiliate network at SummitRidge. These visual markers are utilized solely as historical indicators of enterprise growth, operational longevity, and volume-based milestones cleared within our shared corporate ecosystem.

© 2026 HealthBridge US, a California corporation. All rights reserved.

For more information about the structure of HealthBridge, visit www.myhbconsulting.com/governance

Legal

Resources