Workers' Compensation Billing Audits: Responding to Bill Review and Utilization Review Denials

How workers' compensation payers audit and reduce medical bills through bill review and deny treatment through utilization review, and how providers can use state processes such as California's second bill review, independent bill review, and independent medical review and Texas's reconsideration and medical fee dispute resolution.

KNOWLEDGE CENTER

11/15/202612 min read

Workers' compensation is a separate world from health insurance. Each state has its own workers' compensation system, with its own fee schedules, treatment guidelines, billing rules, and dispute processes. Federal employees are covered by the Federal Employees' Compensation Act, administered by the Department of Labor's Office of Workers' Compensation Programs. Payers include insurance carriers, self-insured employers, third-party administrators, and state funds, and most use bill review vendors and utilization review organizations.

For providers, two types of payer review cause most disputes. Bill review determines how much to pay for a service, applying the state fee schedule, coding rules, and contract terms, and often reduces or denies charges. Utilization review determines whether proposed or provided treatment is medically necessary under the state's treatment guidelines, and can delay, modify, or deny care. Each has its own dispute pathway, with strict deadlines that, if missed, can forfeit payment entirely.

This article explains how bill review and utilization review work, the dispute processes in two major states, California and Texas, as examples, and practical strategies for providers. It is educational and not legal advice. Because workers' compensation rules vary significantly by state, providers should consult their state's rules and experienced counsel.

Bill Review

What Bill Review Does

When a provider submits a bill, the payer or its bill review vendor:

• Confirms that the claim is accepted and the treatment relates to the compensable injury.

• Checks for required documentation and authorization.

• Applies the state fee schedule or a contracted rate, such as a preferred provider network rate.

• Applies coding edits, such as bundling and multiple procedure rules.

• Reduces or denies line items that do not meet billing rules.

• Issues an explanation of review explaining the payment and any reductions.

Common Bill Review Reductions

• Fee schedule reductions to the maximum allowable amount.

• Network or preferred provider discounts.

• Bundling of services the payer considers included in another code.

• Denial for missing reports or documentation.

• Denial for lack of authorization.

• Denial because the service is unrelated to the accepted injury.

• Duplicate billing denials.

• Untimely billing denials.

Audits

Workers' compensation payers also conduct audits, including review of hospital bills against itemized charges and records, pharmacy and durable medical equipment audits, and reviews of physical therapy and chiropractic services. Some states regulate payer audits, while others leave them to contracts.

Utilization Review

What Utilization Review Does

Utilization review evaluates whether requested treatment is medically necessary and consistent with the state's treatment guidelines. In many states, utilization review must be performed by qualified reviewers, and denials based on medical necessity must be made by physicians. Utilization review may be prospective, before treatment; concurrent, during treatment; or retrospective, after treatment.

Treatment Guidelines

Many states have adopted treatment guidelines that define medically necessary care for workplace injuries. California uses the Medical Treatment Utilization Schedule, which includes guidelines and a drug formulary. Texas uses designated treatment guidelines and closed formulary rules. Requests that deviate from guidelines often require additional justification.

California's Dispute Processes

Bill Review: Second Bill Review

Under California Labor Code section 4603.2, payers must pay medical bills within 45 days after receipt, and must notify the provider in an explanation of review within 30 days if the bill is contested, denied, or incomplete. If the dispute is about the amount of payment, the provider may request a second review within 90 days of service of the explanation of review, using DWC Form SBR-1. If the provider fails to request a second review within 90 days, the bill is deemed adjudicated, and neither the employer nor the employee is liable for further payment. Within 14 days of a request for second review, the employer must respond with a final written determination on each disputed item.

Bill Review: Independent Bill Review

If the second review does not resolve the dispute and the only dispute is the amount of payment, the provider may request independent bill review under Labor Code section 4603.6 within 30 calendar days of service of the second review determination, using DWC Form IBR-1 and paying the required fee. If the provider fails to request independent bill review within 30 days, the bill is deemed satisfied. The Administrative Director must assign the request to an independent bill reviewer, and the reviewer issues a determination, which can be appealed to the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board on limited grounds.

Utilization Review: Independent Medical Review

Under Labor Code sections 4610 and 4610.5, utilization review decisions on requests for authorization must generally be made within five business days of receipt of the information reasonably necessary to make the determination, and no later than 14 days from receipt of the request. If utilization review denies or modifies a treatment request based on medical necessity, the employee may request independent medical review within 30 days of service of the utilization review decision, or within 10 days for disputes involving drugs on the formulary drug list. The independent medical review organization generally decides within 30 days. A provider of emergency medical treatment may request independent medical review on its own behalf for retrospective denials of emergency treatment. An internal utilization review appeal may also be available.

Practical Implications in California

California's deadlines are short and unforgiving. Missing the 90-day second review or 30-day independent bill review deadline can forfeit payment. Medical necessity disputes go through independent medical review, which belongs primarily to the injured worker, so treating physicians should communicate with patients and their representatives about utilization review denials.

Texas's Dispute Processes

Reconsideration

In the Texas workers' compensation system, administered by the Texas Department of Insurance, Division of Workers' Compensation, a health care provider must submit a medical bill no later than the 95th day after the date of service, with limited exceptions. If the carrier reduces or denies the bill, the provider must request reconsideration under 28 Texas Administrative Code section 133.250 no later than 10 months from the date of service. A provider is permitted to file for medical fee dispute resolution only after requesting reconsideration.

Medical Fee Dispute Resolution

Under 28 Texas Administrative Code section 133.307, a request for medical fee dispute resolution must generally be filed no later than one year after the date of service in dispute, with exceptions for related disputes about compensability, extent of injury, liability, or medical necessity. The Division's published decisions show that requests filed more than one year after the date of service are routinely dismissed as untimely, and that requesting reconsideration does not extend the one-year deadline.

Medical Necessity Disputes

Texas resolves medical necessity disputes through independent review organizations, under separate rules from fee disputes. Preauthorization requirements apply to certain services, and denials of preauthorization or retrospective medical necessity can be disputed through the applicable process.

Practical Implications in Texas

In Texas, the clock runs from the date of service. Providers must track the 95-day billing deadline, the 10-month reconsideration deadline, and the one-year dispute resolution deadline for every claim, regardless of how long the carrier takes to respond.

Other States and Federal Programs

Other states have their own processes. Many use state agency fee dispute processes, administrative hearings, or arbitration, and many require providers to exhaust payer reconsideration first. For federal employees, the Office of Workers' Compensation Programs administers medical bill payment and dispute processes under the Federal Employees' Compensation Act and its regulations at 20 CFR Part 10. Providers should identify the rules in each jurisdiction where they treat injured workers.

Responding to Bill Review Reductions

Read the Explanation of Review

Identify each reduction or denial and the reason code. Distinguish between payment amount disputes, documentation issues, authorization issues, and compensability issues, since each may follow a different path.

Correct and Resubmit When Appropriate

If the denial is due to missing documentation or a billing error, correct and resubmit promptly, following state rules on resubmission.

Request Reconsideration or Second Review

For payment amount disputes, request reconsideration or second review within the state deadline. Cite the fee schedule provision, coding rules, and any contract terms. Attach documentation.

Escalate to State Dispute Resolution

If the payer does not resolve the dispute, file with the state's dispute process within the deadline. Prepare a complete submission with the bill, the explanation of review, the reconsideration request and response, documentation, and the fee schedule calculation.

Track Network Discounts

If a network discount is applied, confirm that the provider is actually contracted with the network, that the network has the right to apply the discount, and that state rules on network notice and access are met.

Responding to Utilization Review Denials

Understand the Basis

Identify the treatment guideline or criteria the reviewer relied on and the specific reasons for the denial.

Strengthen the Request

Many denials result from incomplete requests. Include objective findings, functional limitations, prior treatment and response, the treatment plan with measurable goals, and an explanation of how the request meets the guideline or why a deviation is justified.

Use Internal Appeals and Peer-to-Peer Discussions

Where available, request reconsideration or an internal appeal, and use peer-to-peer discussions to explain clinical facts.

Support Independent Review

When independent medical review or independent review organization review is available, help the patient or their representative submit timely requests with complete medical records.

Resubmit With New Information

If the patient's condition changes or new information becomes available, a new request for authorization may be appropriate.

Building a Workers' Compensation Billing Program

• Know the fee schedules, billing rules, and dispute deadlines for each state.

• Verify claim acceptance, adjuster contact, and authorization before treatment.

• Submit complete bills with required reports and documentation.

• Track explanations of review, reductions, and denials by payer and reason.

• Calendar every dispute deadline from the correct starting date.

• Use templates for second review, reconsideration, and dispute requests.

• Monitor network discounts and contracts.

• Train staff on state-specific rules.

Common Mistakes

• Missing California's 90-day second review or 30-day independent bill review deadlines.

• Missing Texas's 10-month reconsideration or one-year dispute resolution deadlines.

• Treating workers' compensation bills like health insurance claims.

• Submitting authorization requests without objective findings or guideline support.

• Failing to communicate utilization review denials to patients.

• Accepting network discounts without verifying contracts.

• Not tracking deadlines from the correct date.

Documentation That Supports Payment

Strong documentation reduces both bill review reductions and utilization review denials. For workers' compensation, documentation should:

• Link each service to the accepted body part and injury.

• Include required reports, such as initial evaluations, progress reports, and work status reports, in the format the state requires.

• Record objective findings and functional limitations.

• Document the treatment plan with measurable goals and expected duration.

• Show response to prior treatment.

• Support the level and units of service billed.

• Include authorization numbers where required.

Many states require specific forms or reports, such as primary treating physician progress reports, and missing reports are a common reason for nonpayment.

Working With Adjusters and Case Managers

Workers' compensation claims involve adjusters, nurse case managers, and employers. Good communication can prevent disputes. Confirm claim acceptance and the accepted body parts, provide timely reports, and respond quickly to adjuster questions. When disputes arise, a call to the adjuster may resolve simple issues, such as a missing report, faster than a formal dispute. Document all communications.

Compensability and Liability Disputes

Some denials are based on compensability, such as a claim that the injury is not work-related or that a body part is not accepted. These disputes are typically resolved through the state's claim adjudication process rather than bill review or utilization review. Providers may need to wait for compensability to be resolved, and in some states may file liens or participate in proceedings. Track these claims separately, and note that some dispute deadlines are extended while compensability is resolved, as Texas's rules provide for related disputes.

Coordinating Communications

Designate staff responsible for workers' compensation billing and disputes, track every deadline by state, and keep copies of all bills, explanations of review, dispute requests, and decisions.

Pharmacy and Durable Medical Equipment

Pharmacy and durable medical equipment bills often face distinct rules. Many states use drug formularies that require prior authorization for non-preferred drugs, limit compounded medications, and set specific pricing. Physician dispensing of medications is restricted or subject to special pricing rules in several states. Durable medical equipment may require authorization and specific documentation of medical necessity. Providers should know the state's formulary and equipment rules before dispensing.

Hospital and Facility Bills

Hospital and ambulatory surgery center bills are often reviewed against state facility fee schedules, which may use Medicare-based methodologies with workers' compensation multipliers, or against contracted rates. Disputes frequently involve implant reimbursement, outlier payments, and whether services were bundled. Facilities should understand the specific fee schedule methodology and keep invoices and documentation for implants and high-cost items.

Measuring Performance

Track workers' compensation metrics such as days to payment, denial and reduction rates by payer and reason, second review and reconsideration success rates, dispute outcomes, and the amount forfeited due to missed deadlines. Use the data to target training, improve documentation, and address payers with unusual reduction patterns. Reporting these metrics to leadership regularly helps maintain focus on this often-overlooked revenue stream.

Balancing Cooperation and Advocacy

Providers can work cooperatively with adjusters and bill review vendors while still disputing improper reductions and denials. Organized, timely disputes are a normal part of the workers' compensation system and often recover significant amounts.

Training Staff

Workers' compensation billing requires specialized knowledge. Train billing and front-desk staff to verify claim information, obtain authorization, submit required reports, read explanations of review, and recognize when a reduction should be disputed. Clinical staff should understand the documentation and reporting requirements that affect payment and authorization. Refresh training when states update fee schedules, forms, or rules, which happens frequently.

Multi-State Providers

Providers that treat injured workers from multiple states, or that operate in several states, face multiple sets of rules. Build a state-by-state reference that summarizes fee schedules, billing deadlines, required forms, reconsideration and dispute deadlines, and utilization review processes. Assign responsibility for keeping each state's information current.

Using Liens and Board Proceedings

In some states, providers may file liens or participate in workers' compensation board proceedings to recover payment, particularly when compensability is disputed or when bill review and utilization review processes do not apply. California, for example, has specific lien filing rules and fees, and liens are subject to deadlines and activation requirements. Providers should understand when liens are available, the costs and deadlines involved, and how lien claims interact with the bill review and independent bill review processes.

Avoiding Common Billing Errors

Many reductions and denials result from preventable errors. Common examples include billing with incorrect codes or modifiers for the state's fee schedule, missing required reports, billing for unaccepted body parts, missing authorization numbers, and submitting bills after the state's billing deadline. Pre-billing checks tailored to each state's rules can prevent many of these problems and reduce the need for disputes.

Review denial trends quarterly to identify which errors recur and which checks would prevent them, and update billing edits and staff training accordingly.

Myths About Workers' Compensation Billing Disputes

Myth: Providers Can Always Bill the Patient if Workers' Compensation Does Not Pay

Many states prohibit billing injured workers for treatment of compensable injuries, so dispute processes may be the only path to payment.

Myth: Deadlines Run From the Payer's Response

In Texas, key deadlines run from the date of service, and in California, deadlines run from service of the explanation of review or second review determination.

Myth: Utilization Review Denials Are Final

Independent medical review and other processes allow denials to be overturned.

Myth: All States Use the Same Process

Each state has its own fee schedules, rules, and dispute procedures.

Questions Leadership Should Ask

• Do we track workers' compensation dispute deadlines by state?

• Are our authorization requests complete and guideline-based?

• Do we monitor bill review reductions and network discounts?

• Do we use second review, reconsideration, and dispute resolution consistently?

• Are we forfeiting payment by missing deadlines?

• Do staff understand each state's rules?

Key Takeaways

• Workers' compensation payers use bill review to determine payment amounts and utilization review to determine medical necessity, each with separate dispute pathways.

• In California, payment disputes go to second bill review within 90 days of the explanation of review and then independent bill review within 30 days, while medical necessity disputes go to independent medical review within 30 days.

• In Texas, providers must request reconsideration within 10 months of the date of service and file medical fee dispute resolution within one year of the date of service.

• Missing workers' compensation deadlines can forfeit payment entirely.

• State-specific knowledge, complete documentation, deadline tracking, and consistent use of dispute processes are essential.

How HealthBridge Can Help

HealthBridge helps providers that treat injured workers improve workers' compensation billing and resolve disputes. Our team can map state-specific fee schedules, billing rules, and dispute deadlines, build tracking systems, analyze bill review reductions and network discounts, and prepare second review, reconsideration, and dispute resolution requests. We also help clinical teams strengthen authorization requests and support patients in independent medical review. If your organization is facing workers' compensation billing audits or denials, please get in touch with us. We will be happy to help you with this topic.

References

• California Department of Industrial Relations, Division of Workers' Compensation. California Code of Regulations, Title 8, Section 9792.5.5, Second Review of Bill. https://www.dir.ca.gov/t8/9792_5_5.html

• California Department of Industrial Relations, Division of Workers' Compensation. DWC Form SBR-1, Provider's Request for Second Bill Review. https://www.dir.ca.gov/dwc/DWCPropRegs/IBR/FormSBR_1.pdf

• California Department of Industrial Relations, Division of Workers' Compensation. Independent Bill Review. https://www.dir.ca.gov/dwc/IBR/IBR.htm

• California Department of Industrial Relations, Division of Workers' Compensation. Independent Medical Review Frequently Asked Questions. https://dir.ca.gov/DWC/IMR/IMR_FAQs.htm

• California Department of Industrial Relations, Division of Workers' Compensation. California Code of Regulations, Title 8, Section 9792.10.1, Utilization Review Decision; Dispute. https://www.dir.ca.gov/t8/9792_10_1.html

• California Department of Industrial Relations, Division of Workers' Compensation. California Code of Regulations, Title 8, Section 9792.10.6, Independent Medical Review Standards and Timeframes. https://dir.ca.gov/t8/9792_10_6.html

• California Workers' Compensation Appeals Board. Panel Decision, Belanger (2026). https://www.dir.ca.gov/wcab/Panel-Decisions-2026/Robert-BELANGER-ADJ11788125.pdf

• California Legislative Information. Labor Code Sections 4603.2, 4603.6, 4610, and 4610.5. https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=LAB&sectionNum=4603.6

• Texas Department of Insurance, Division of Workers' Compensation. Medical Fee Dispute Resolution Findings and Decision, M4-25-2094. https://www.tdi.texas.gov/medcases/medfee25/m4252094.pdf

• Texas Department of Insurance, Division of Workers' Compensation. Medical Fee Dispute Resolution Findings and Decision, M4-23-2211. https://www.tdi.texas.gov/medcases/medfee23/m4232211.pdf

• Texas Secretary of State. 28 Texas Administrative Code Chapter 133, General Medical Provisions (including 133.20, 133.250, and 133.307). https://texreg.sos.state.tx.us/public/readtac$ext.ViewTAC?tac_view=4&ti=28&pt=2&ch=133

• U.S. Department of Labor, Office of Workers' Compensation Programs. Federal Employees' Compensation Act, Medical Bill Processing. https://www.dol.gov/agencies/owcp/FECA

• Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 20 CFR Part 10, Claims for Compensation under the Federal Employees' Compensation Act. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-20/chapter-I/subchapter-B/part-10

Some or all of the services described herein may not be permissible for HealthBridge US clients and their affiliates or related entities.

The information provided is general in nature and is not intended to address the specific circumstances of any individual or entity. While we strive to offer accurate and timely information, we cannot guarantee that such information remains accurate after it is received or that it will continue to be accurate over time. Anyone seeking to act on such information should first seek professional advice tailored to their specific situation. HealthBridge US does not offer legal services.

HealthBridge US is not affiliated with any department of public health agencies in any state, nor with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). We offer healthcare consulting services exclusively and are an independent consulting firm not affiliated with any regulatory organizations, including but not limited to the Accrediting Organizations, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), and state departments. HealthBridge is an anti-fraud company in full compliance with all applicable federal and state regulations for CMS, as well as other relevant business and healthcare laws. The badges, icons, and achievement graphics displayed on this website represent proprietary performance metrics, volume milestones, and internal corporate recognition issued exclusively by our corporate affiliate network at SummitRidge. These visual markers are utilized solely as historical indicators of enterprise growth, operational longevity, and volume-based milestones cleared within our shared corporate ecosystem.

© 2026 HealthBridge US, a California corporation. All rights reserved.

For more information about the structure of HealthBridge, visit www.myhbconsulting.com/governance

Legal

Resources